, Volume 88, Issue 2, pp 663–667 | Cite as

Problems with “natural selection of academic papers”

  • L. Egghe


In this short communication we give critical comments on the paper of Perakakis et al. (Scientometrics 85(2):553–559, 2010) on “Natural selection of academic papers”. The criticism mainly focusses on their unbalanced criticism of peer review and their negative evaluation of the link of peer review with commercial publishing.


Peer review Commercial publishing Open access 


  1. Antelman, K. (2004). Do open-access articles have a greater research impact? College and Research Libraries, 65(5), 372–382.Google Scholar
  2. Bornmann, L., & Daniel, H.-D. (2010). The usefulness of peer review for selecting manuscripts for publication: A utility analysis taking as an example an high-impact journal. PloS ONE, 5(6), e11344.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bornmann, L., & Egghe, L. (2011). Journal peer review as an information retrieval process. Preprint.Google Scholar
  4. Hernon, P., & Schwartz, C. (2011). Editorial. Modification of peer review? Library and Information Science Research, 33, 1–2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Mandavilli, A. (2011). Trial by twitter. Blogs and tweets are ripping papers apart within days of publication, leaving researchers unsure how to react. Nature, 469, 286–287.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Meyer, C. A. (2010). Researcher tools for evaluating trustworthiness: CrossCheck plagiarism screening and CrossMark. Library Connect, 3(1), 7.Google Scholar
  7. Perakakis, P., Taylor, M., Mazza, M., & Trachana, V. (2010). Natural selection of academic papers. Scientometrics, 85(2), 553–559.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Rousseau, R. (2006). After the journal impact factor and the web impact factor a referee factor enters the fray: Some comments. ISSI Newsletter, 2(2), 2–3.Google Scholar
  9. Wilson, R., & Lancaster, J. (2006). Referee factor would reward a vital contribution. Nature, 441, 812.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest, Hungary 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Universiteit Hasselt (Uhasselt)DiepenbeekBelgium
  2. 2.Universiteit Antwerpen (UA)AntwerpenBelgium

Personalised recommendations