Law Without Legitimacy or Justification? The Flawed Foundations of Philosophical Anarchism
- 416 Downloads
In this article, I examine A. John Simmons’s philosophical anarchism, and specifically, the problems that result from the combination of its three foundational principles: the strong correlativity of legitimacy rights and political obligations; the strict distinction between justified existence and legitimate authority; and the doctrine of personal consent, more precisely, its supporting assumptions about the natural freedom of individuals and the non-natural states into which individuals are born. As I argue, these assumptions, when combined with the strong correlativity and strict distinction theses, undermine Simmons’s claim, which is central to his philosophical anarchism, that a state may be justified in enforcing the law, even if illegitimate or unjustified in existing.
KeywordsA. John Simmons Philosophical anarchism Political obligation Rights and obligations Justification and legitimacy
I am grateful to Prof. John Horton and Prof. Glen Newey, as well as two anonymous referees from Res Publica, for their helpful comments on earlier drafts of this paper.
- Department of Defense. 2011. Report on progress toward security and stability in Afghanistan and United States plan for sustaining the Afghanistan national security forces. http://www.defense.gov/news/1230_1231report.pdf. Accessed 9 November 2011.
- Foreign Policy. 2011. The failed states index 2011. http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/06/17/2011_failed_states_index_interactive_map_and_rankings. Accessed 9 November 2011.
- Hamed, Mohammad. 2011. Suicide bomber kills 30 as Afghan violence spreads. Reuters. February 18. http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/02/21/us-afghanistan-bomb-idUSTRE71K19220110221. Accessed 23 April 2011.
- Horton, John. 2010. Political obligation, 2nd ed. Basingstoke: Macmillan Press Ltd.Google Scholar
- House of Representatives. 2006. A failure of initiative. http://www.gpoaccess.gov/katrinareport/fullreport.pdf. Accessed 23 April 2011.
- Knowles, Dudley. 2010. Political obligation: A critical introduction. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- NPR. 2008. Transcript of Barack Obama’s victory speech. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=96624326&ft=1&f=1001. Accessed April 23, 2011.
- Quinn, Andrew. 2011. U.S. launches diplomatic surge to end Afghan war. Reuters. February 18. http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/02/18/us-afghanistan-usa-idUSTRE71H40G20110218. Accessed 23 April 2011.
- Senor, Thomas. 1987. What if there are no political obligations? A reply to A. J. Simmons. Philosophy & Public Affairs 16: 260–268.Google Scholar
- Simmons, A. John. 1979. Moral principles and political obligations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Simmons, A. John. 1987. The anarchist position: A reply to Klosko and Senor. Philosophy & Public Affairs 16: 269–279.Google Scholar
- Simmons, A. John. 1992. The Lockean theory of rights. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Simmons, A. John. 1993. On the edge of anarchy: Locke, consent, and the limits of society. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Simmons, A. John. 2001. Justification and legitimacy: Essays on rights and obligations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Stewart, Phil and Susan Cornwell. 2011. Afghanistan violence to rise in 2011: U.S. military. Reuters. February 16. http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/02/16/us-usa-afghanistan-idUSTRE71F4SI20110216. Accessed 23 April 2011.
- Wolff, Robert Paul. 1970. In defense of anarchism. New York: Harper & Row.Google Scholar