Remediation of Fluency: Word Specific or Generalised Training Effects?
The present study examines whether reading fluency benefits more from repeated reading of a limited set of words or from practicing reading with many different words. A group of 37 reading delayed Dutch children repeatedly read the same 20 words with limited exposure duration, whereas another group of 37 poor readers received the same reading exercises with 400 different words. Results demonstrated that improvements in accuracy and speed of trained words were larger for the repeated reading group than for the children who had only practiced with these words once. No difference in generalisation of effects to untrained neighbour and control words was found between the two conditions. Furthermore, rapid naming skill was unrelated to improvements in reading fluency and transfer effects in both training conditions. Results demonstrate that the practical value of repeated reading lies in its word specific training effects.
KeywordsReading fluency Generalisation Repeated reading Decoding Rapid naming
Benson, N. J., Lovett, M. W., Kroeber, C. L. 1997Training and transfer-of-learning effects in disabled and normal readers: Evidence of specific deficitsJournal of Experimental Child Psychology64343366CrossRefGoogle Scholar Bourassa, D. C., Levy, B. A., Dowin, S., Casey, A. 1998Transfer effects across contextual and linguistic boundaries: Evidence from poor readersJournal of Experimental Child Psychology714561CrossRefGoogle Scholar Bowers, P. G. 1993Text reading and rereading: Determinants of fluency beyond word recognitionJournal of Reading Behavior25133153Google Scholar Bowers, P. G., Wolf, M. 1993Theoretical links among naming speed, precise timing mechanisms and orthographic skill in dyslexiaReading and Writing56985CrossRefGoogle Scholar Bowey, J. A., Vaughan, L., Hansen, J. 1998Beginning readers’ use of orthographic analogies in word readingJournal of Experimental Child Psychology68108133CrossRefGoogle Scholar Brus, B. T., Voeten, M. J. M. 1973Eén-Minuut-Test., [One Minute Test] BerkhoutNijmegenGoogle Scholar Castles, A., Coltheart, M. 2004Is there a causal link from phonological awareness to success in learning to read?Cognition9177111CrossRefGoogle Scholar Chard, D. J., Vaughn, S., Tyler, B. J. 2002A synthesis of research on effective interventions for building reading fluency with elementary students with learning disabilitiesJournal of Learning Disabilities35386406Google Scholar Cunningham, A. E., Perry, K. E., Stanovich, K. E. 2001Converging evidence for the concept of orthographic processingReading and Writing14549568CrossRefGoogle Scholar Farrington-Flint, L., Wood, C., Canobi, K. H., Faulkner, D. 2004Patterns of analogical reasoning among beginning readersJournal of Research in Reading27226247CrossRefGoogle Scholar Fleisher, L.S., Jenkins, J.R., Pany, D. 1979–1980Effects on poor readers’ comprehension of training in rapid decodingReading Research Quarterly153048Google Scholar Foorman, B. R., Breier, J. I., Fletcher, J. M. 2003Interventions aimed at improving reading success: An evidence-based approachDevelopmental Neuropsychology24613639CrossRefGoogle Scholar Hatcher, P. J., Hulme, C., Snowling, M. J. 2004Explicit phoneme training combined with phonic reading instruction helps young children at risk of reading failureJournal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry45338358CrossRefGoogle Scholar Humphrey, N., Hanley, J. R. 2004The role of orthographic analogies in reading for meaning: Evidence from readers with dyslexiaJournal of Research in Reading27265280CrossRefGoogle Scholar Kraemer, H. C. 2003“Rules” of evidence in assessing the efficacy and effectiveness of treatmentsDevelopmental Neuropsychology24705718CrossRefGoogle Scholar Kuhn, M. R., Stahl, S. A. 2003Fluency: A review of developmental and remedial practicesJournal of Educational Psychology95321CrossRefGoogle Scholar Lemoine, H. E., Levy, B. A., Hutchinson, A. 1993Increasing the naming speed of poor readers: Representations formed across repetitionsJournal of Experimental Child Psychology55297328CrossRefGoogle Scholar Levy, B.A., Abello, B., Lysynchuk, L. 1997Transfer from word training to reading in context: Gains in reading fluency and comprehensionLearning Disability Quarterly20173188Google Scholar Levy, B. A., Bourassa, D. C., Horn, C. 1999Fast and slow namers: Benefits of segmentation and whole word trainingJournal of Experimental Child Psychology73115138CrossRefGoogle Scholar Levy, B. A., Nicholls, A., Kohen, D. 1993Repeated readings: Process benefits for good and poor readersJournal of Experimental Child Psychology56303327CrossRefGoogle Scholar Logan, G. D. 1997Automaticity and reading: Perspectives from the instance theory of automatizationReading & Writing Quarterly13123147Google Scholar Lovett, M. W., Borden, S. L., DeLuca, T., Lacerenza, L., Benson, N. J., Brackstone, D. 1994Treating the core deficits of developmental dyslexia: Evidence of transfer of learning after phonologically- and strategy-based reading training programsDevelopmental Psychology30805822CrossRefGoogle Scholar Meyer, M. S., Felton, R. H. 1999Repeated reading to enhance fluency: Old approaches and new directionsAnnals of Dyslexia49283306Google Scholar Meyler, A., Breznitz, Z. 2003Processing of phonological, orthographic and cross-modal word representations among adult dyslexic and normal readersReading and Writing16785803CrossRefGoogle Scholar Perfetti, C. A., Hart, L. 2002The lexical quality hypothesisVerhoeven, L.Elbro, C.Reitsma, P. eds. Precursors of functional literacy John BenjaminsAmsterdam, The Netherlands189213Google Scholar Reitsma, P. 1997How to get friends in beginning word recognitionLeong, C. K.Joshi, R. M. eds. Cross-language studies of learning to read and spell KluwerDordrecht, The Netherlands213233Google Scholar Savage, R., Stuart, M. 2001Orthographic analogies and early reading: Explorations of performance and variation in two transfer tasksReading and Writing14571598CrossRefGoogle Scholar Share, D. L. 1995Phonological recoding and self-teaching: Sine qua non of reading acquisitionCognition55151218CrossRefGoogle Scholar Share, D. L. 1999Phonological recoding and orthographic learning: A direct test of the self-teaching hypothesisJournal of Experimental Child Psychology7295129CrossRefGoogle Scholar Share, D. L. 2004Orthographic learning at a glance: On the time course and developmental onset of self-teachingJournal of Experimental Child Psychology87267298CrossRefGoogle Scholar Storkel, H. L. 2004Do children acquire dense neighborhoods? An investigation of similarity neighborhoods in lexical acquisitionApplied Psycholinguistics25201221CrossRefGoogle Scholar Tan, A., Nicholson, T. 1997Flashcards revisited: Training poor readers to read words faster improves their comprehension of textJournal of Educational Psychology89276288CrossRefGoogle Scholar Bos, K. P., Zijlstra, B. J. H., Lutje Spelberg, H. C. 2002Life-span data on continuous-naming speeds of numbers, letters, colors, and pictured objects, and word-reading speedScientific Studies of Reading62549Google Scholar Bosch, K., Bon, W. H. J., Schreuder, R. 1995Poor readers’ decoding skills: Effects of training with limited exposure durationReading Research Quarterly30110125Google Scholar Wentink, H. W. M. J., Bon, W. H. J., Schreuder, R. 1997Training of poor readers’ phonological decoding skills: Evidence for syllable-bound processingReading and Writing9163192CrossRefGoogle Scholar Wolf, M., Katzir-Cohen, T. 2001Reading fluency and its interventionScientific Studies of Reading5211239CrossRefGoogle Scholar Wolf, M., O’Rourke, A. G., Gidney, C., Lovett, M., Cirino, P., Morris, R. 2002The second deficit: An investigation of the independence of phonological and naming-speed deficits in developmental dyslexiaReading and Writing154372CrossRefGoogle Scholar Wood, C. 2002Orthographic analogies and phonological priming effectsJournal of Research in Reading25144159Google Scholar Young, A. R., Bowers, P. G., MacKinnon, G. E. 1996Effects of prosodic modeling and repeated reading on poor readers’ fluency and comprehensionApplied Psycholinguistics175984Google Scholar