Bank reserves: A dispute over words and classification
A prominent philosophical/legal case for requiring 100% bank reserves employs a flawed style of argument. It involves essentialism (criticized by Karl Popper and Joseph Schumpeter), persuasive definitions (identified by Charles L. Stevenson), faulty classification, and the piling up of irrelevant facts and considerations.
KeywordsBank reserves “Essentialist” argument and “persuasive definitions”
JEL CodesG21 B53 A12 B40
I thank David Howden and Philipp Bagus for conversations and correspondence that were stimulating for me even though—or especially because—we disagree on key points. I also thank an anonymous referee for suggestions, particularly about the work of Henry Dunning Macleod.
- Champion R. (n.d.). “Essentialism and the Organic State”. http://www.the-rathouse.com/popessent.html.
- Dioguardi, M. (n.d.). “Notes on Essentialism”. http://www.geocities.com/criticalrationalist/essentialism.htm?220931.
- Hayek, F. A. (1952). The sensory order. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
- Huerta de Soto, J. (2006). Money, bank credit, and economic cycles. Trans. from the 1998 Spanish original by Melinda A. Stroup. Auburn, AL: Ludwig von Mises Institute.Google Scholar
- Hummel, W. F. (n.d.). The credit theory of money. http://wfhummel.cnchost.com/innes.html.
- Innes, M. A. (1913). What is money? Banking Law Journal, May 1913. http://www.ces.org.za/docs/what%20is%20money.htm or http://www.moslereconomics.com/mandatory-readings/what-is-money/
- Innes, A. M. (1914). The credit theory of money. Banking Law Journal, 31, 151–168. http://www.ces.org.za/docs/The%20Credit%20Theory%20of%20Money.htm (but access apparently requires logging in with a password.Google Scholar
- Kiyotaki, N., & Moore, J. (2001). Evil is the root of all money. Clarendon Lecture 1, 2001. www.princeton.edu/~kiyotaki/papers/Evilistherootofallmoney.pdf.
- Kocherlakota, N. R. (1996). Money is memory. Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Staff Report no. 218.Google Scholar
- Macleod, H. D. (1889). The theory of credit, vol. I. London: Longmans, Green. http://books.google.com/books?id=pu9AAAAAIAAJ&pg=PR3&dq=Henry+Dunning+Macleod++Theory+of+Credit+1889#v=onepage&q=Henry%20Dunning%20Macleod%20%20Theory%20of%20Credit%201889&f=false.Google Scholar
- O’Hear, A. (1980). Karl Popper. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Popper, K. (1982). Unended quest. Revised edition. LaSalle and London: Open Court.Google Scholar
- Rothbard, M. N. (1983). The mystery of banking. New York: Richardson & Snyder.Google Scholar
- Schumpeter, J. A. (1954). History of economic analysis. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Shahar, D. C. (2009). Justice and climate change: Toward a libertarian analysis. Independent Review, 14, 219–237.Google Scholar
- Smith, B. (1994). Aristotelianism, apriorism, essentialism. In P. J. Boettke (Ed.), The Elgar companion to Austrian economics (pp. 33–37). Aldershot, England, and Brookfield, VT: Elgar.Google Scholar
- Stevenson, C. L. (1944). Ethics and language. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar