Do European fiscal rules induce a bias in fiscal forecasts? Evidence from the Stability and Growth Pact
- 317 Downloads
Enforcement of European fiscal rules, to a large extent, hinges on fiscal forecasts prepared by the European Commission (EC). The reliability of these forecasts has received little attention in the literature, despite the fact that (i) the forecasts have potentially far-reaching consequences for national governments, especially in the euro area while (ii) the EC depends on information supplied by national officials in preparing its forecasts. We hypothesize that the EC’s forecasts are biased upwards when national governments expect European fiscal rules to bind. Reconstructing this expectation using real-time information, we show that for euro area countries the EC’s fiscal forecasts are indeed biased upwards when the budget deficit threatens to exceed the critical value of 3 % of GDP. For non-euro area countries, which do not face the risk of fines, this bias cannot be established. Our results are robust to various ways of controlling for crisis-induced budgetary problems and the exclusion of various country groups. We offer suggestive evidence that the presence of independent fiscal councils at the national level helps to attenuate the bias induced by the 3 % threshold.
KeywordsForecast errors Stability and Growth Pact Fiscal policy Political economy
JEL ClassificationC53 H3 H68 E62
The views expressed in this paper are those of the authors and not necessarily the views of De Nederlandsche Bank. We would like to thank Peter Keus, Paul Mul and Rob Vet for help in constructing the dataset and Diederik Dicou, Peter van Els, Jakob de Haan, Jos Jansen, Cherry Muijsson, Andreas Pick, Maarten van ’t Riet, Wim Suyker, as well as the editor, William F. Shughart II, the anonymous referees, participants of the 30th Annual Congress of the European Economic Association in Mannheim, participants of the 2015 ‘Dutch Economists’ Day’(Nederlandse Economendag) in Amsterdam, and seminar participants at the Dutch central bank, for valuable comments and suggestions.
- Andrle, M., Bluedorn, J., Eyraud, L., Kinda, T., Koeva Brooks, P., Schwartz, G., & Weber, A. (2015). Reforming fiscal governance in the European Union. IMF Staff Discussion Note 09.Google Scholar
- Bohn, F. (2014). Countercyclical policies caused by political opportunism. NiCE Working Paper 14-101.Google Scholar
- Brogan, M. (2012). The politics of budgeting: Evaluating the effects of the political election cycle on state-level budget forecast errors. Public Administration Quarterly, 36(1), 82–112.Google Scholar
- Cabanillas, L., & Terzi, A. (2012). The accuracy of the European Commission’s forecasts re-examined. EC Economic Papers 476.Google Scholar
- Claeys, G., Darvas, Z., & Leandro, A. (2016). A proposal to revive the European fiscal framework. Bruegel Policy Contribution, 2016(3).Google Scholar
- De Haan, J., Gilbert, N., Hessel, J., & Verkaart, S. (2013). How to enforce fiscal discipline in EMU: A proposal. Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics, 149(2), 205–217.Google Scholar
- Debrun, X., & Kinda, T. (2014). Strengthening post-crisis fiscal credibility fiscal councils on the rise. A new dataset. IMF Working Paper 14(58).Google Scholar
- Debrun, X., Kinda, T., Curristine, T., Eyraud, L., Harris, J., & Seiwald, J. (2013). The functions and impact of fiscal councils. IMF Policy Paper.Google Scholar
- EC (1990). One Market, one Money—an evaluation of the potential benefits and costs of forming an economic and monetary union. European Economy 44.Google Scholar
- EC (2010). Report on Greek government deficit and debt statistics. http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/documents/4187653/6404656/COM_2010_report_greek/c8523cfa-d3c1-4954-8ea1-64bb11e59b3a.
- EC (2012). Common principles on national fiscal correction mechanisms. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52012DC0342.
- EC (2014a). Commission takes steps under the Excessive Deficit Procedure (EDP). http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-14-382_en.htm.
- EC (2014b). Numerical fiscal rules in the EU member states. http://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/db_indicators/fiscal_governance/fiscal_rules/index_en.htm.
- EC (2015). Introduction to economic forecasts. http://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/eu/forecasts/index_en.htm.
- EC (2016). Vade Mecum on the Stability and Growth Pact. Institutional Paper 021.Google Scholar
- Frankel, J., & Schreger, J. (2013). Over-optimistic official forecasts and fiscal rules in the eurozone. Review of World Economics (Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv), 149(2), 247–272.Google Scholar
- Gandrud, C., & Hallerberg, M. (2014). Bad banks in the EU: The impact of Eurostat rules. Bruegel Working Papers 2014/15.Google Scholar
- Gentry, W. (1989). Do state revenue forecasters utilize available information? National Tax Journal, 42, 429–439.Google Scholar
- Jong-A-Pin, R., Sturm, J., & De Haan, J. (2012). Using real-time data to test for political budget cycles. CESifo Working Paper Series 3939.Google Scholar
- Keereman, F. (1999). The track record of the Commission forecasts. Economic Papers 137.Google Scholar
- Larch, M., Van den Noord, P., & Jonung, L. (2010). The Stability and Growth Pact: Lessons from the great recession. European Commission, Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs.Google Scholar
- Melander, A., Sismanidis, G., & Grenouilleau, D. (2007). The track record of the Commission’s forecasts—An update. Economic Papers 291.Google Scholar
- Prammer, D., & Reiss, L. (2016). The Stability and Growth Pact since 2011: More complex—But also stricter and less procyclical? Monetary Policy and the Economy Q1/16.Google Scholar
- Tirole, J. (2012). The euro crisis: Some reflexions on institutional reform. Financial Stability Review, 16, 225–642.Google Scholar
- Wooldridge, J. (2002). Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar