Promises beyond assurance
Breaking a promise is generally taken to involve committing a certain kind of moral wrong, but what (if anything) explains this wrong? According to one influential theory that has been championed most recently by Scanlon, the wrong involved in breaking a promise is a matter of violating an obligation that one incurs to a promisee in virtue of giving her assurance that one will perform or refrain from performing certain acts. In this paper, we argue that the “Assurance View”, as we call it, is susceptible to two kinds of counterexamples. The first show that giving assurance is not sufficient for incurring the kind of obligation of fulfillment that one violates in breaking a promise. The second show that giving assurance is not necessary. Having shown that the Assurance View fails in these ways, we then very briefly sketch the outline of what we take to be a better view—a view that we claim is not only attractive in its own right and that avoids the earlier counterexamples, but that also affords us a deeper explanation of why the Assurance View seems initially plausible, yet nonetheless turns out to be ultimately inadequate.
KeywordsPromises Promissory obligation Scanlon
Previous versions of this paper were presented at the Australasian Association of Philosophy Conference at the Australian National University, as well as at the Centre for Applied Philosophy and Public Ethics, the University of Sydney and the London School of Economics. We are grateful to audiences on those occasions as well as to many other friends and colleagues, too numerous to list here, for their invaluable input. Southwood’s work on the article was carried out under ARC Discovery Grant DP0663060.
- Hume, D. (2000). A treatise of human nature. Oxford, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- MacCormick, N. (1972). Voluntary obligations and normative powers I. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 46, 59–78.Google Scholar
- Narveson, J. (1971). Promising, expecting and utility. Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 1, 207–233.Google Scholar
- Pratt, M. (2004). Promising and promissory obligation. unpublished dissertation.Google Scholar
- Scanlon, T. M. (1998). What we owe to each other. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Sidgwick, H. (1874). The methods of ethics. London: MacMillan and Co.Google Scholar
- Thomson, J. J. (1990). The realm of rights. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar