Philosophical Studies

, Volume 128, Issue 2, pp 229–256 | Cite as

Dualism and Secondary Quality Eliminativism: Putting a New Spin on the Knowledge Argument

  • Emmett L. Holman


Frank Jackson formulated his knowledge argument as an argument for dualism. In this paper I show how the argument can be modified to also establish the irreducibility of the secondary qualities to the properties of physical theory, and ultimately “secondary quality eliminativism”–the view that the secondary qualities are physically uninstantiated. In addition to being of interest in its own right, this new argument provides a perspective to better see that certain popular would-be refutations of the knowledge argument do not work (against either version). But it also introduces some complications that will force us to take an unexpected detour through the pros and cons of naturalizing intentionality before (tentatively) embracing Jackson’s dualist conclusion.


Physical Theory Secondary Quality Knowledge Argument Dualist Conclusion 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Armstrong, D. 1968A Materialist Theory of the MindHumanities PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  2. Averill, E. (1985): ‘Color and the Anthropocentric Problem’, Journal of Philosophy 82, 281–304, Reprinted in A. Byrne and D. Hilbert (eds.) (1997a).Google Scholar
  3. Block, N.Flanagan, O.Guzeldere, G. eds. 1997The Nature of ConsciousnessMIT PressCambridge, MA and LondonGoogle Scholar
  4. Boghossian, P. and Velleman, D. (1989): ‘Colour as a Secondary Quality’, Mind 98, 81–193. reprinted in A. Byrne and D. Hilbert (eds.) (1997a).Google Scholar
  5. Broackes, J. (1992): ‘The Autonomy of Colour’, in D. Charles, and K. Lennon, (eds) (1992), reprinted in A. Byrne, and D. Hilbert, (eds.) (1997a).Google Scholar
  6. Byrne, A. and Hilbert, D. (eds.) (1997a): Readings on Color, vol. 1: The Philosophy of Color, Cambridge, MA, London: MIT PressGoogle Scholar
  7. Byrne, A. and Hilbert, D. (eds.) (1997b): Readings on Color, vol. 2: The Science of Color, Cambridge, MA, London: MIT PressGoogle Scholar
  8. Carruthers, P. 2000Phenomenal ConsciousnessCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  9. Carruthers, P. (2001): ‘Response to Joe Levine’, Sito Web Italiano per la Filosofia, Philosophy of Mind Forums, Scholar
  10. Chalmers, D. 1996The Conscious MindOxford University PressNew York, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  11. Chalmers, D. 1999‘Materialism and the Metaphysics of Modality’Philosophy and Phenomenological Research59473495Google Scholar
  12. Charles, D.Lennon, K. eds. 1992Reduction, Explanation and RealismOxford University PressNew York, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  13. Churchland, P. 1989A Neurocomputational PerspectiveMIT PressCambridge, MA and LondonGoogle Scholar
  14. Churchland, P. 2002‘Outer Space and Inner Space: The New Epistemology’Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association762548Google Scholar
  15. Clark, A. 2000A Theory of SentienceOxford University PressOxford, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  16. Conee, E. 1994‘Phenomenal Knowledge’Australasian Journal of Philosophy72136150Google Scholar
  17. Cronly-Dillon, J.R.Gregory, R.L. eds. 1991Evolution of the Eye and Visual SystemCRC PressBoca Raton, FLGoogle Scholar
  18. Davis, S. eds. 2000Color Perception: Philosophical, Psychological, Artistic and Computational PerspectivesOxford University PressOxford, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  19. Dennett, D. 1991Consciousness ExplainedLittle, Brown and CompanyBoston, Toronto, LondonGoogle Scholar
  20. Dretske, F. 1995Naturalizing the MindMIT PressCambridge, MA, LondonGoogle Scholar
  21. Feigl, H. (1958): ‘The ‘Mental’ and the “Physical”’, in H. Feigl, and M. Scriven, (eds.)Google Scholar
  22. Feigl, H.Scriven, M. eds. 1956Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science, vol. IUniversity of Minnesota PressMinneapolisGoogle Scholar
  23. Feigl, H.Scriven, M.Maxwell, G. eds. 1958Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science, vol. IIUniversity of Minnesota PressMinneapolisGoogle Scholar
  24. Fodor, J. 1987Psychosemantics: The Problem of Meaning in the Philosophy of MindMIT PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  25. Fodor, J. 1990A Theory of ContentMIT PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  26. Fodor, J. 1998ConceptsClarendon PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  27. French, P.Uehling, T.Wettstein, H. eds. 1977Midwest Studies in Philosophy, vol 2: Studies in SemanticsUniversity of Minnesota PressMinneapolisGoogle Scholar
  28. Gerhardt, V., Horstmann, R.-P., Schumacher, R. 2001Kant und die Berliner Aufklarung: Akten des IX Inernationalen Kant-KongressesWalter de Gruyter PressBerlin, NewYorkGoogle Scholar
  29. Harman, G. (1990): ‘The Intrinsic Quality of Experience’, in J. Tomberlin (ed.)Google Scholar
  30. Harman, G.: ‘Explaining Objective Color in Terms of Subjective Reactions’ in E. Villenueva (ed.) (1996). Reprinted in A. Byrne, and D. Hilbert, (eds.) (1997a).Google Scholar
  31. Hardin, C.L. 1992‘The Virtues of Illusion’Philosophical Studies68371382CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Hilbert, D. and Kalderon, M.E. (2000): ‘Color and the Inverted Spectrum’, in S. Davis (ed.) (2000).Google Scholar
  33. Hill, C., McLaughlin, B. 1999‘There are Fewer Things in Reality than are Dreamt of in Chalmers’ Philosophy’Philosophy and Phenomenological Research59445454Google Scholar
  34. Holman, E.L. 2002‘Color Eliminativism and Color Experience’Pacific Philosophical Quarterly833856CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Honderich, T. eds. 1985Morality and ObjectivityRoutledge & Kegan PaulLondonGoogle Scholar
  36. Jackson, F. 1982‘Epiphenomenal Qualia’Philosophical Quarterly32127136Google Scholar
  37. Jackson, F. 1986‘What Mary Didn”t Know’The Journal of Philosophy83291295Google Scholar
  38. Jackson, F. 1998Mind, Method and ConditionalsRoutledgeLondon and New YorkGoogle Scholar
  39. Jackson, F. (2000): ‘Philosophizing about Color’, in Davis (2000).Google Scholar
  40. Johnston, M. (1992): ‘How to Speak of the Colors’, Philosophical Studies 68, 221–63. Reprinted in A. Byrne and D. Hilbert, (eds.) (1997a).Google Scholar
  41. Kant, I. 1987Critique of JudgmentHackett PressIndianapolisGoogle Scholar
  42. Kripke, S. 1980Naming and NecessityHarvard University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  43. Levine, J. (2001): “Commentary on Peter Carruthers’, Phenomenal Consciousness,” Sito Web Italiano per la Filosofia Philosophy of Mind Forums, Scholar
  44. Lewis, D. (1990): ‘What Experience Teaches’, in Lycan, W. (ed.) (1990b).Google Scholar
  45. Loar, B. (1990): ‘Phenomenal States’, in Tomberlin, J. (ed.) (1990).Google Scholar
  46. Loar, B. (1997): ‘Phenomenal States’, in N. Block, O. Flanagan, and G. Guzeldere, (eds.) (1997).Google Scholar
  47. Loar, B. 1999“David Chalmers’ The Conscious MindPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research59465472Google Scholar
  48. Lycan, W. (1990a): ‘What is the “Subjectivity” of the Mental?’, in J. Tomberlin (ed.) (1990).Google Scholar
  49. Lycan, W. eds. 1990bMind and CognitionBasil BlackwellCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  50. McDowell, J. (1985): ‘Values and Secondary Qualities’, in T. Honderich (ed.) (1985).Google Scholar
  51. Meehl, P.E. and Sellars, W. (1956): ‘The Concept of Emergence’, in H. Feigl, and M. Scriven, (eds.) (1956).Google Scholar
  52. Millikan, R. 1984Language, Thought and Other Biological CategoriesMIT PressCambridge, MA and LondonGoogle Scholar
  53. Mollon, J.D. (1989): ‘Tho’ She Kneeled in that Place Where They Grew: The Uses and Origins of Primate Colour Vision’, Journal of Experimental Biology 146, 21–38. Reprinted in A. Byrne and D. Hilbert (1997b).Google Scholar
  54. Mollon, J.D. (1991): “Uses and Evolutionary Origins of Primate Colour Vision”, in J.R. Cronly-Dillon and R.L. Gregory (eds.) (1991).Google Scholar
  55. Moore, G.E. 1903‘The Refutation of Idealism’Mind12433453Google Scholar
  56. Nemirow, L. (1990): ‘Physicalism and the Cognitive Role of Acquaintance’, in W. Lycan (ed.) (1990b).Google Scholar
  57. Peacocke, C. 1984‘Colour Concepts and Colour Experience’Synthese58365382CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Scherer, I. 1995The Crisis of Judgment in Kant’s Three CritiquesPeter Lang PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  59. Scherer, I. (2001): ‘Revisiting Kant’s General Metaphysics: in Terms of a Completed Transcendental Psychology’ in V. Gerhardt, R.-P. Horstmann and R. Schumacher (eds.) (2001).Google Scholar
  60. Stampe, D. (1977): ‘Towards a Causal Theory of Linguistic Representation’, in P.French, T. Uehling, and H. Wettstein, (eds.) (1997).Google Scholar
  61. Stoljar, D. 2001‘Two Conceptions of the Physical’Philosophy and Phenomenological Research62253281Google Scholar
  62. Tomberlin, J. eds. 1990Philosophical Perspectives, vol 4: Action Theory␣and Philosophy of MindRidgeview Publishing CoAtascadero, CAGoogle Scholar
  63. Tye, M. 1995Ten Problems of ConsciousnessMIT PressCambridge, MA, LondonGoogle Scholar
  64. Tye, M. 2000Consciousness, Color and ContentMIT PressCambridge, MA, LondonGoogle Scholar
  65. Villenueva, E. eds. 1996Philosophical Issues, vol. 7Ridgeview Publishing CoAtascadero, CAGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Phil. & Reli. studiesGeorge Mason UniversityUSA

Personalised recommendations