Abstract
In this investigation, four scenarios were used to quantify the balance between the benefits of levees for flood protection and their potential to increase flood risk using Hazards U.S. Multi-Hazard flood-loss software and hydraulic modeling of the Middle Mississippi River (MMR). The goals of this study were (1) to quantify the flood exposure under different flood-control configurations and (2) to assess the relative contributions of various engineered structures and flood-loss strategies to potential flood losses. Removing all the flood-control structures along the MMR, without buyouts or other mitigation, reduced the average flood stages between 2.3 m (100-year flood) and 2.5 m (500-year), but increased the potential flood losses by $4.3–6.7 billion. Removing the agricultural levees downstream of St. Louis decreased the flood stages through the metro region by ~1.0 m for the 100- and 500-year events; flood losses, without buyouts or other mitigation, were increased by $155 million for the 100-year flood, but were decreased by $109 million for the 500-year flood. Thus, agricultural levees along the MMR protect against small- to medium-size floods (up to the ~100-year flood level) but cause more damage than they prevent during large floods such as the 500-year flood. Buyout costs for the all the buildings within the 500-year floodplain downstream of urban flood-control structures near St. Louis are ~40% less than the cost of repairing the buildings damaged by the 500-year flood. This suggests large-scale buyouts could be the most cost-effective option for flood loss mitigation for properties currently protected by agricultural levees.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Association of State Flood Plain Managers (2007) National flood programs and policies in review. http://www.floods.org/PDF/NFPPR_2007. Accessed 31 Jan 2011
Belt CB (1975) The 1973 flood and man’s constriction of the Mississippi River. Science 189:681–684
Bhowmik NG, Demissie M (1982) Carrying capacity of flood plains. J Hydraul Div ASCE 108:443–452
Black H (2008) Unnatural disaster: human factors in the Mississippi floods. Environews Spheres Influ 116:A390–A393
Burton CG, Cutter SL (2008) Levee failures and social vulnerability in the Sacramento, San-Joaquin Delta-Area, California. Nat Hazards Rev 9(3):136–149
Carlson ML (2010) Using HAZUS-MH flood model as a floodplain management tool: evaluation of river engineering effects on flood losses for the Middle Mississippi River. MS thesis, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, pp 104
Census of Population and Housing (2000a) Summary Tape File 3 on CD-ROM/prepared by the Bureau of Census
Census of Population and Housing (2000b) Summary Tape File 1B extract on CD-ROM/prepared by the Bureau of Census
Criss RE, Shock EL (2001) Flood enhancement through flood control. Geology 29:875–878
Davinroy RD (1990) Bendway weir design manual. http://www.mvs.usace.army.mil/arec/documents/Files/BendwayWeirDesignManual.pdf. Accessed 10 May 2010
Department of Energy [DOE] (1995a) A look at commercial buildings in 1995 DOE/EIA 0625(97). US Department of Energy, Washington, DC
Department of Energy [DOE] (1995b) Housing characteristics 1993. Office of Energy Markets and End Use
Department of Energy [DOE] (1999) A look at residential energy consumption in 1997. DOE/EIA 0632
Dobney FJ (1978) River engineers on the Middle Mississippi: a history of the St. Louis District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Superintendent of Documents, US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC
Dun and Bradstreet (2006) Business population report aggregated by Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) and census block
Dyhouse GR (1985) Levees at St. Louis—more harm than good? Unpublished Manuscript, presented at American Society of Civil Engineers Hydraulics Division Specialty Conference
Federal Emergency Management Agency [FEMA] (1998) Property acquisition handbook for local communities. http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/acqhandbook.shtm. Accessed 20 Jan 2011
Federal Emergency Management Agency [FEMA] Mitigation Division (2007) Multi-hazard loss estimation methodology flood model Hazus-MH MR3 technical manual. http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=3033. Accessed 22 June 2009
Federal Emergency Management Agency [FEMA] Region X Mitigation (2009) HAZUS analysis for the Green River Valley. http://www.fema.gov/plan/prevent/hazus/hz_validationstudies.shtm. Accessed 18 Jan 2010
Flor A, Pinter N, Remo JWF (2011) The ups and downs of levees: GPS-based change detection, Middle Mississippi River USA. Geology 39:55–58. doi:10.1130/g31493.1
Gall M, Boruff BJ, Cutter SL (2007) Assessing flood hazard zones in the absence of digital floodplain maps: comparison of alternative approaches. Nat Hazard Rev 8:1–12. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)1527-6988(2007)8:1(1)
Galloway GE (2000) Three centuries of river management along the Mississippi River: engineering and hydrological aspects. In: Smits AJ, Nienhuis PH, Leuven RE (eds) New approaches to river management. Backhuys, Leiden, pp 51–64
General Accounting Office [GAO] (1995) Midwest flood: information on the performance, effects and control of levees. http://www.gao.gov/docsearch/featured/dprr.html. Accessed 19 Feb 2010
Gergel SE, Dixon MD, Turner MG (2002) Consequences of human-altered floods: Levees, floods, and floodplain forests along the Wisconsin River. Ecol Appl 12:1755–1770
Gordon DC (2004) A remedy for a chronic dredging problem. Engineer: The Professional Bulletin for Army Engineers, Oct to Nov, pp 32–36
Hall BR (1991) Impact of agricultural levees on flood hazards: technical report H L-91-21. US Army Corps of Engineers Waterway Experiment Station, pp 1–37
Heine RA, Pinter N (in press) Levee effects upon flood levels: an empirical assessment. Hydrol Process
Hillig T (2010a) Firm chosen for levee work British company says it can do Metro East job in 2½ years for $129.9 million. St. Louis Post
Hillig T (2010b) Metro East levee repairs much more expensive than thought. St. Louis Post-Dispatch
Jemberie AA, Pinter N, Remo JW (2008) Hydrologic history of the Mississippi and Lower Missouri Rivers based upon a refined specific-gauge approach. Hydrol Process 7046–7058. doi:10.1002/hyp.7046
Krauch AL (2008) Hazards assessment of St. Charles County—Earthquake and floods. http://scholarsmine.mst.edu/thesis/Hazards_assessment_o_09007 dcc805e91 a1.html. Accessed 5 March 2010
Maher TF (1964) Study of effect of regulating works on stream flow. Oral presentation ASCE conference. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Saint Louis District, Cincinnati, pp 1–23
Montz BE, Tobin GA (2008) Livin’ large with levees: lessons learned and lost. Nat Hazards Rev 9:150–157
National Committee on Levee Safety (2009) Recommendation for a National Levee Safety Program. http://www.nfrmp.us/ncls/docs/NCLS-Recommendation-Report_012009_DRAFT.pdf. Accessed 10 Oct 2010
National Wildlife Federation [NWF] (1998) Higher ground: a report on voluntary property buyouts in the nations’ floodplains. Conrad D, Stout M, McNitt B (eds) National Wildlife Federation, Vienna, pp 1–54
Pinter N (2005) One step forward, two steps back on U.S. floodplains. Science 308:207–208
Pinter N (2009) Non-stationary flood occurrence on the Upper Mississippi–Lower Missouri River systems: review and current status. In Criss RE, Kusky TM (eds) Finding the balance between floods, flood protection and river navigation. Center for Environmental Sciences at Saint Louis University, pp 34–40
Pinter N, Thomas R, Wlosinski JH (2000) Regional impacts of levee construction and channelization, Middle Mississippi River, USA. In Marsalek J, Ed Watt W, Zeman E, Sieker F (eds) Flood issues in contemporary water management. Kluwer, Boston, pp 351–361
Pinter N, Thomas R, Wlosinski JH (2001) Assessing flood hazards on dynamic rivers. Eos Trans Am Geophys Union 82(333):338–339
Pinter N, Jemberie AA, Remo JW, Heine RA, and Ickes BS (2008) Flood trends and river engineering on the Mississippi River system, USA. Geophys Res Lett 35. doi:10.1029/2008GL035987
Pinter N, Jemberie AA, Remo JWF, Heine RA, Ickes BA (2010) Empirical modeling of hydrologic response to river engineering, Mississippi and Lower Missouri Rivers. Riv Res Appl 26:546–571. doi:10.1002/rra.1269
Remo JWF, Pinter N (2007) Retro-modeling the Middle Mississippi River. J Hydrol 337:421–435. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2007.02.008
Remo JWF, Pinter N, Ickes BS, Heine H (2008) New databases reveal 200 years of change on the Mississippi River System. Eos: Trans Am Geophysical Union 89(14):134–135
Remo JWF, Pinter N, Heine R (2009) The use of retro- and scenario-modeling to assess effects of 100 + years river of engineering and land-cover change on Middle and Lower Mississippi River flood stages. J Hydrol 376:403–416. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2009.07.049
Rogers J (2009) Overview of post-flood surveys of the Upper Mississippi River Valley in the summer of 2008. Review and current status. In Criss RE, Kusky TM (eds) Finding the balance between floods, flood protection and river navigation. Center for Environmental Sciences at Saint Louis University, pp 11–46
Schneider PJ, Schauer BA (2006) HAZUS-its development and its future. Nat Hazard Rev 7:40–44. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)1527-6988(2006)7:2(40)
Scientific Assessment and Strategy Team [SAST] (1995) Metadata for levee coverage: Upper Mississippi/Missouri River Basin levees. http://www.umesc.usgs.gov/data_library/gis_data/umrs_floodplain/metadata/levees.html. Accessed 5 May 2010
Silva W, Klijn F, Dijkman J (2001) Room for the Rhine Branches in The Netherlands. Rijksinstituut voor Integraal Zoetwaterbeheer en Afvalwaterbehandeling, Lelystad
Stevens MA, Simons DB, Schumm SA (1975) Man-induced changes of Middle Mississippi River. J Waterw Harb Coast Eng Div 101:119–133
Tobin GA (1995) The levee love affair: a stormy relationship? Water Resour Bull 31:359–367
U.S. Geological Survey [USGS] (2010a) USGS surface-water data for the nation. http://waterdata.usgs.gov/nwis/sw/. Accessed 9 April 2010
United States Geological Survey [USGS] (2010b) The national map seamless server. http://seamless.usgs.gov/. Accessed 9 Oct 2010
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (1972) Improvement of the Lower Mississippi River and tributaries. Mississippi River Commission. Vicksburg Mississippi, pp 241
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (2004a) Upper Mississippi River System Flow Frequency Study [UMRSFFS]: hydrologic and hydraulics appendix D St. Louis District. St. Louis: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers St. Louis District
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (2004b) Upper Mississippi River Floodway Computation [UMRFC]. USACE St. Paul District, Rock Island District, St. Louis District
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (2006) Environmental design handbook. Rock Island District. August 2006. pp 462. http://www.mvr.usace.army.mil/EMP/designhandbook.htm. Accessed 16 August 2011
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (2008) Upper Mississippi River comprehensive plan: main report. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Rock Island District, St. Louis District, and St. Paul District
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (2010a) River Gages.com, water levels of rivers and lakes. http://www2.mvr.usace.army.mil/WaterControl/new/layout.cfm. Accessed 1 May 2010
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] St. Louis District (2010b) River engineering structures and floods. http://www.mvs.usace.army.mil/CurrentCorpsTopics/RiverControl/index.html. Accessed 5 May 2010
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (2010c) Project implementation report with integrated environmental assessment: navigation and ecosystem sustainability program, Herculaneum side channel restoration. Draft report, August 2010
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (2011a) Bendway Weirs. Coastal and Hydraulics Laboratory, Engineer Research and Development Center Waterways Experiment Station. http://chl.erdc.usace.army.mil/chl.aspx?p=s&a=RD_Applications;2. Accessed 16 August 2011
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] (2011b) Completed construction projects: mosenthien project. Applied River Engineering Center, St. Louis District. http://www.mvs.usace.army.mil/arec/completed.html. Accessed 16 August 2011
Yen BC (1995) Hydraulics and effectiveness of levees for flood control. Paper presented: U.S.–Italy research workshop on the hydrometeorology, impacts, and management of extreme floods, November 1995
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Remo, J.W.F., Carlson, M. & Pinter, N. Hydraulic and flood-loss modeling of levee, floodplain, and river management strategies, Middle Mississippi River, USA. Nat Hazards 61, 551–575 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-011-9938-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-011-9938-x