Abstract
This paper proposes a new explanation for the oddness of presuppositional and negative islands, as well as the puzzling observation that these islands can be obviated by certain quantificational elements. The proposal rests on two independently motivated assumptions: (i) the idea that the domain of manners contains contraries and (ii) the notion that degree expressions range over intervals. It is argued that, given these natural assumptions, presuppositional and negative islands are predicted to lead to a presupposition failure in any context.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abels, K. 2004. Why “surprise”–predicates do not embed polar interrogatives. In Linguistische Arbeitsberichte 79, 203–222. Leipzig: University of Leipzig.
Abrusán, M. 2007a. Even and free choice any in Hungarian. In Proceedings of Sinn und Bedeutung 11, ed. Estela Puig-Waldmüller, 1–15. Barcelona: Universitat Pompeu Fabra.
Abrusán, M. 2007b. Contradiction and grammar: The case of weak islands. PhD diss., MIT.
Abrusán, M. and B. Spector. 2010. An interval-based semantics for degree questions: Negative islands and their obviation. Journal of Semantics. Advance access under doi:10.1093/jos/ffq013.
Abusch, D. 2002. Lexical alternatives as a source of pragmatic presuppositions. In Proceedings of SALT 12, ed. B Jackson, 1–19. Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications.
Atlas J. (1993) The importance of being only: Testing the neo-Gricean vs. neo-entailment paradigms. Journal of Semantics 10: 301–318
Atlas J. (1996) Only noun phrases, pseudo-negative generalized quantifiers, negative polarity items and monotonicity. Journal of Semantics 13: 265–328
Barwise J., Cooper R. (1981) Generalized quantifiers and natural language. Linguistics and Philosophy 4: 159–219
Beaver D. (2001) Presupposition and assertion in dynamic semantics. CSLI Publications, Stanford
Beaver D. (2004) Five ‘only’ pieces. Theoretical Linguistics 30: 45–64
Beck, S. 1996. Wh-constructions and transparent logical form. PhD diss., University of Tübingen.
Beck S. (2001) Reciprocals are definites. Natural Language Semantics 9: 69–138
Beck S. (2006) Intervention effects follow from focus interpretation. Natural Language Semantics 14: 1–56
Beck S., Rullmann H. (1999) A flexible approach to exhaustivity in questions. Natural Language Semantics 7: 249–298
Cattell R. (1978) On the source of interrogative adverbs. Language 54: 61–77
Chemla, E. 2008. Similarity: Towards a unified account of scalar implicatures, free choice permission and presupposition projection. Manuscript, École normale supérieure.
Chemla, E. 2009. An experimental approach to adverbial modification. In Semantics and pragmatics: from experiment to theory, ed. U. Sauerland and K. Yatsushiro, 249–263. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Chierchia, G. 1984. Topics in the syntax and semantics of infinitives and gerunds. PhD diss., University of Massachusetts at Amherst.
Chomsky N. (1995) The minimalist program. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Cinque G. (1990) Types of A-dependencies. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Comorovski, I. 1989. Discourse and the syntax of multiple constituent questions. PhD diss., Cornell University.
Cresti D. (1995) Extraction and reconstruction. Natural Language Semantics 3: 79–122
Dayal V. (1996) Locality in WH quantification. Kluwer, Dordrecht
de Cuba, C.F. 2007. On (non)factivity, clausal complementation and the CP-field. PhD diss., Stony Brook University.
de Swart, H. 1992. Intervention effects, monotonicity and scope. In Proceedings of SALT 2, ed. C. Barker and D. Dowty, 387–406. Columbus: The Ohio State University.
den Dikken M., Giannakidou A. (2002) From hell to polarity: “aggressively non-D-linked” wh-phrases as polarity items. Linguistic Inquiry 33: 31–61
den Dikken, M., and A. Szabolcsi. 2002. Islands. In The second state of the article book, ed. L. Cheng and R. Sybesma, 213–240. Berlin: de Gruyter.
Dowty D. (1979) Word meaning and Montague grammar: The semantics of verbs and times in generative semantics and in Montague’s PTQ. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Dukes, M. 1992. Factives, “stance” predicates and weak islandhood. Manuscript, UCLA.
Egré, P. 2008. Question-embedding and factivity. Grazer Philosophische Studien 77, ed. F. Lihoreau, 85–125. University of Graz.
Fox D. (2000) Economy and semantic interpretation. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Fox, D. 2007. Too many alternatives: Density, symmetry and other predicaments. In Proceedings of SALT 17, ed. M. Gibson and T. Friedman, 89–111. Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications.
Fox, D. 2010. Negative islands and maximization failure. Manuscript, MIT.
Fox D., Hackl M. (2007) The universal density of measurement. Linguistics and Philosophy 29: 537–586
Gajewski, J. 2002. L-analyticity in natural language. Manuscript, MIT
Gajewski, J. 2005. Neg-raising: Polarity and presupposition. PhD diss., MIT.
Geurts B., van der Sandt R. (2004) Interpreting focus. Theoretical Linguistics 30: 1–44
Guerzoni, E. 2003. Why even ask? On the pragmatics of questions and the semantics of answers. PhD diss., MIT.
Hacquard, V. 2006. Aspects of modality. PhD diss., MIT.
Haegeman L. (2006) Conditionals, factives and the left periphery. Lingua 116: 1651–1669
Hamblin C. (1973) Questions in Montague English. Foundations of Language 10: 41–53
Hegarty, M. 1992. Adjunct extraction without traces. In Proceedings of WCCFL 10, 209–223. Stanford: CSLI Publications.
Heim, I. 1983. On the projection problem for presuppositions. In Proceedings of WCCFL 2, 114–125. Stanford: CSLI Publications.
Heim, I. 1984. A note on negative polarity and downward entailingness. In Proceedings of NELS 14, 98–107. Amherst, MA: GLSA.
Heim, I. 2006. Remarks on comparative clauses as generalized quantifiers. Manuscript. MIT.
Heim I., Kratzer A. (1998) Semantics in generative grammar. Blackwell, Malden
Honcoop M. (1998) Dynamic excursions on weak islands. Holland Academic Graphics, The Hague
Horn, L. 1969. A presuppositional approach to only and even. In Proceedings of the Chicago Linguistic Society 5, 98–107. Chicago: Chicago Linguistic Society.
Horn L. (1989) A natural history of negation. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Horn L. (1996) Exclusive company: Only and the dynamics of vertical inference. Journal of Semantics 13: 1
Ippolito, M. 2006. Remarks on only. In Proceedings of SALT 16, 77–87. Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications.
Jacobson, P. 1995. On the quantificational force of English free relatives. In Quantification in natural languages, ed. E. Bach et al., 451–486. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Karttunen L. (1977) Syntax and semantics of questions. Linguistics and Philosophy 1: 3–44
Kiss K. (1993) Wh-movement and specificity. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 11: 85–120
Kiparsky, P., and C. Kiparsky. 1971. Fact. In Semantics. An interdisciplinary reader in philosophy, linguistics and psychology, ed. D.D. Steinberg and L.A. Jacobovits, 345–369. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Klein, E. 1975. Two sorts of factive predicate. Pragmatics Microfiche it 1.1. frames B5-C14.
Ko Heejeong (2005) Syntax of why-in-situ: Merge into [Spec,CP] in the overt syntax. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 23: 867–916
Krifka M. (1995) The semantics and pragmatics of polarity items. Linguistic Analysis 25: 209–257
Kroch, A. 1989. Amount quantification, referentiality, and long wh-movement. Manuscript, University of Pennsylvania.
Kuno S., Takami K. (1997) Remarks on negative islands. Linguistic Inquiry 28: 553–576
Ladusaw, W. 1986. Principles of semantic filtering. Papers from the 5th Western Conference on Formal Linguistics, 129–141. Stanford: Stanford Linguistics Association.
Lahiri U. (1998) Focus and negative polarity in Hindi. Natural Language Semantics 6: 57–123
Landman F. (1989) Groups, I. Linguistics and Philosophy 12: 559–605
Linebarger M. (1981) The grammar of negative polarity. Indiana University Linguistics Club, Bloomington
Link, G. 1983. The logical analysis of plurals and mass terms: a lattice-theoretical approach. In Meaning, use, and interpretation of language, ed. R. Bäuerle et al., 302–232. Berlin: de Gruyter.
Löbner S. (1985) Definites. Journal of Semantics 4: 279–326
Longobardi, G. 1987. Extraction from NP and the proper notion of head government. The syntax of noun phrases, ed. A. Giorgi and G. Longobardi, 57–112. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Magri G. (2009) A theory of individual-level predicates based on blind mandatory scalar implicatures. Natural Language Semantics 17: 245–297
Manzini R. (1998) A minimalist theory of weak islands. Syntax and Semantics 29: 185–209
McCawley J. (1993) Everything that linguists have always wanted to know about logic but were ashamed to ask. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Obenauer H. (1984) On the identification of empty categories. The Linguistic Review 4: 153–202
Oshima, D. 2006. On factive islands: Pragmatic anomaly vs. pragmatic infelicity. In New Frontiers in artificial intelligence: Joint JSAI 2006 Workshop Post-Proceedings, ed. Ken Saroh et al., 147–161. Berlin: Springer.
Pesetsky, D. 1987. Wh-in-situ: movement and unselective binding. The representation of (in)definiteness, ed. E. Reuland and A. ter Meulen, 98–129. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Rizzi L. (1990) Relativized minimality. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Roberts, C. 2006. Only, presupposition and implicature. Manuscript, The Ohio State University.
Romero, M. 1998. Focus and reconstruction effects in wh-phrases. PhD diss., University of Massachusetts at Amherst.
Rooth, M. 1985. Association with focus. PhD diss., University of Massachusetts at Amherst.
Rullmann, H. 1995. Maximality in the semantics of wh-constructions. PhD diss., University of Massachusetts at Amherst.
Sauerland, U. 2007. Intervals have holes. A note on comparatives with differentials. Manuscript, ZAS Berlin.
Schlenker, P. 2003. The lazy Frenchman’s approach to the subjunctive. In Proceedings of Romance Languages and Linguistic Theory, ed. T. Geerts et al., 269–309. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
Schlenker P. (2008) Be articulate: A pragmatic theory of presupposition projection. Theoretical Linguistics 34(3): 157–212
Schwarzschild R. (1994) Plurals, presuppositions and the sources of distributivity. Natural Language Semantics 2: 201–248
Schwarzschild, R. 2004. Scope-splitting in the comparative. Handout at MIT-colloquium.
Schwarzschild R., Wilkinson K. (2002) Quantifiers in comparatives: A semantics of degree based on intervals. Natural Language Semantics 10: 1–41
Simons, M. 2001. On the conversational basis of some presuppositions. Proceedings of SALT 21, ed. R. Hasting et al., 431–448. Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications.
Spector, B. 2003. Scalar implicatures: exhaustivity and Gricean reasoning? In Proceedings of the ESSLLI 2003, ed. B. ten Cate, Student Session, Vienna.
Spector, B. 2005. Aspects de la pragmatique des opérateurs logiques. PhD diss., Université de Paris 7.
Spector, B. 2007. Aspects of the pragmatics of plural morphology: On higher-order implicatures. Manuscript, École normale supérieure.
Starke, M. 2001. Move dissolves into merge: A theory of locality. PhD diss., University of Geneva.
Szabolcsi, A. 2006. Strong vs. weak islands. The Blackwell Companion to Syntax, Vol. 4, ed. M. Everaert and H. van Riemsdijk, 479–531. Malden: Blackwell.
Szabolcsi A., Haddican B. (2005) Conjunction meets negation: A study in crosslinguistic variation. Journal of Semantics 21: 219–249
Szabolcsi, A., and F. Zwarts. 1990. Semantic properties of composed functions and the distribution of whphrases. Proceedings of the Seventh Amsterdam Colloquium, ed. Stokhof, M. and L. Torenvliet, 529–555. Amsterdam: ILLI.
Szabolcsi A., Zwarts F. (1993) Weak islands and an algebraic semantics for scope taking. Natural Language Semantics 1: 235–284
Szabolcsi, A., and F. Zwarts. 1997. Weak Islands and an algebraic semantics for scope taking. In Ways of scope taking, ed. A Szabolcsi, 217–262. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
van Benthem J.F. (1989) Logical constants across types. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 30: 315–342
van Rooij, R., and K. Schulz. 2005. Only: Meaning and implicature. Manuscript, University of Amsterdam.
von Fintel K. (1993) Exceptive constructions. Natural Language Semantics 1: 123–148
von Stechow A. (1984) Comparing semantic theories of comparison. Journal of Semantics 3: 1–77
von Stechow A., Zimmermann T. (1984) Term answers and contextual change. Linguistics 22: 3–40
Zucchi A. (1995) The ingredients of definiteness and the definiteness effect. Natural Language Semantics 3: 33–78
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Abrusán, M. Presuppositional and negative islands: a semantic account. Nat Lang Semantics 19, 257–321 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11050-010-9064-4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11050-010-9064-4