Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy

, Volume 13, Issue 4, pp 371–381 | Cite as

Doctor-cared dying instead of physician-assisted suicide: a perspective from Germany

  • Fuat S. Oduncu
  • Stephan Sahm
Scientific Contribution


The current article deals with the ethics and practice of physician-assisted suicide (PAS) and dying. The debate about PAS must take the important legal and ethical context of medical acts at the end of life into consideration, and cannot be examined independently from physicians’ duties with respect to care for the terminally ill and dying. The discussion in Germany about active euthanasia, limiting medical intervention at the end of life, patient autonomy, advanced directives, and PAS is not fundamentally different in content and arguments from discussions led in other European countries and the United States. This must be emphasized, since it is occasionally claimed that in Germany a thorough discussion could not be held with the same openness as in other countries due to Germany’s recent history. Still, it is worthwhile to portray the debate, which has been held intensively both among experts and the German public, from the German perspective. In general, it can be stated that in Germany debates about questions of medical ethics and bioethics are taking place with relatively large participation of an interested public, as shown, for instance, by the intense recent discussions about the legalisation of advanced directives on June 18 2009, the generation and use of embryonic stem cells in research or the highly difficult challenges for the prioritizing and rationing of scarce resources within the German health care system. Hence, the current article provides some insights into central medical and legal documents and the controversial public debate on the regulation of end-of-life medical care. In conclusion, euthanasia and PAS as practices of direct medical killing or medically assisted killing of vulnerable persons as “due care” is to be strictly rejected. Instead, we propose a more holistically-oriented palliative concept of a compassionate and virtuous doctor-cared dying that is embedded in an ethics of care.


Advanced directives Autonomy Doctor-cared dying End-of-life care Euthanasia German medical association Physician-assisted suicide PAS 



The authors are indebted to Mrs. Bernadette Fisher who helped to prepare the manuscript, and to Mrs. Kathy Muller-Schertler for native language correction of the manuscript.


  1. Deutscher Juristentag. 2006. Beschlüsse des 66. Deutschen Juristentages. Available on Accessed 7 July 2009.
  2. Bundesärztekammer und Kassenärztliche Bundesvereinigung. 2008. Sterben in Würde. Grundsätze und Empfehlungen für Ärztinnen und Ärzte. Available on
  3. Deutscher Bundestag. 2009. Drucksache 16/8442. 16. Wahlperiode. Available on
  4. Dignitate Deutschland. 2009. Available on Accessed 6 July 2009.
  5. Oregon Death with Dignity Annual Reports. 2009. Available on:
  6. Akechi, T., T. Nakano, N. Akizuki, T. Nakanishi, E. Yoshikawa, H. Okamura, and Y. Uchitomi. 2002. Clinical factors associated with suicidality in cancer patients. Journal of Clinical Oncology 32: 506–511.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Barilan, Y.M. 2003. Of doctor-patient sex and assisted suicide. Israel Medical Association Journal 5(6): 460–463.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Battin, M.P. 1992. Assisted suicide: Can we learn from Germany? Hastings Center Report 22(2): 45–51.Google Scholar
  9. Bobbert, M. 2003. Sterbehilfe als medizinisch assistierte Tötung auf Verlangen: Argumente gegen eine rechtliche Zulassung. In Bioethik. Eine einführung, ed. M. Düwell, and K. Steigleder, 314–322. Frankfurt a.M: Suhrkamp.Google Scholar
  10. Boer, T.A. 2003. After the slippery slope: Dutch experiences on regulating active euthanasia. Journal of the Society of Christian Ethics 23: 225–242.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  11. Breitbart, W., and B.D. Rosendfeld. 1999. Physician-assisted suicide: The influence of psychosocial issues. Cancer Control 6: 146–161.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  12. Breitbart, W., B.D. Rosenfeld, and S.D. Passik. 1996. Interest in physician-assisted suicide among ambulatory HIV-infected patients. American Journal of Psychiatry 153: 238–242.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Bundesärztekammer. 1997. Entwurf der Richtlinie der Bundesärztekammer zur ärztlichen Sterbebegleitung und den Grenzen zumutbarer Behandlung. Deutsches Ärzteblatt 94: A1342–A1344.Google Scholar
  14. Bundesärztekammer. 1998. Grundsätze der Bundesärztekammer zur Ärztlichen sterbebegleitung. Deutsches Ärzteblatt 95: A-2365–A-2366.Google Scholar
  15. Bundesärztekammer. 1999. Symposium der Bundesärztekammer Ärztliche sterbebegleitung. Köln: Deutscher Ärzte.Google Scholar
  16. Bundesärztekammer. 2004. Grundsätze der Bundesärztekammer zur ärztlichen sterbebegleitung. Deutsches Ärzteblatt 101: A1298–A1299.Google Scholar
  17. Bundesgerichtshof. 2006. BGH- Beschluß vom 17. März 2003, XII. Zivilsenat: XII ZB 2/03.Google Scholar
  18. Callan, D. 2008. Organized obfuscation: Advocacy for physician-assisted suicide. Hastings Center Report 38(5): 30–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Clark, D. 1999. Total pain. Disciplinary power, the body in the work of Ciceley Saunders, 1958–1967. Social Science and Medicine 49: 727–736.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Covinski, K.E., C.S. Landefeld, J. Teno, A.F. Connors, N. Dawson, S. Youngner, N. Desbiens, J. Lynn, W. Fulkerson, D. Reding, R. Oye, and R.S. Phillips. 1996. Is economic hardship on the families of the seriously ill associated with patient and surrogate care preference? Archives of Internal Medicine 156: 1737–1741.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Cullen, R.M. 1999. Arguments for zero tolerance of sexual contact between doctors and patients. Journal of Medical Ethics 25(6): 482–486.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  22. Emanuel, E.J., D.L. Fairclough, and L. Emanuel. 2000. Attitudes and desires related to euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide among terminally ill patients and their caregivers. Journal of the American Medical Association 284: 2460–2468.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  23. Fagerlin, A., and C.E. Schneider. 2004. Enough. The failure of the living will. Hastings Center Report 34(2): 30–42.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  24. Fenner, D. 2007. Ist die Institutionalisierung und Legalisierung der Suizidbeihilfe gefährlich? Ethik in der Medizin 19: 200–214.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Fischer, C. 2001. Gibt es den Suizid aus freier Entscheidung? In Vom Recht zu sterben, zur Pflicht zu sterben? ed. Schwank, A., and Spöndlin, R, 19–28. Zürich: Edition 8.Google Scholar
  26. Ganzini, L., E.R. Goy, and S.K. Dobscha SK. 2008. Prevalence of depression and anxiety in patients requesting physicians’ aid in dying: Cross sectional survey. British Medical Journal 337: a1682.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  27. Hefty, G. 2009. Stichwort Patientenautonomie. Eine Tagung blickt über die Grenzen Deutschlands und der passiven Sterbehilfe hinaus. Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung 26th of June 2009.Google Scholar
  28. Hibbeler, B. 2005. Aktive sterbehilfe: Je nachdem, wie man fragt. Deutsches Ärzteblatt 102(43): A-2897.Google Scholar
  29. Holtug, N. 1993. Human gene therapy: Down the slippery slope? Bioethics 7: 405–419.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Lorenz, K. 2003. Moral and practical challenges of physician-assisted suicide. Journal of the American Medical Association 289: 2282.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  31. Materstvedt, L.J., D. Clark, J. Ellershaw, R. Forde, A.M. Gravgaard, H.C. Müller-Busch, J. Porta i Sales, and C.H. Rapin; EAPC Ethics Task Force. 2003. Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: A view from an EAPC ethics task force. Palliative Medicine 17(2): 97–101.Google Scholar
  32. Meier, D.E., C.A. Emmons, S. Wallenstein, T. Quill, S. Morrison, and C.K. Cassel. 1998. A national survey of physician assisted-suicide and euthanasia in the United States. New England Journal of Medicine 338: 1193–1201.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  33. Möller, H.-J. 1996. Psychiatrie. Hippokrates 367. Stuttgart.Google Scholar
  34. Müller-Busch, H.C., E. Klaschik, F.S. Oduncu, T. Schindler, and S. Woskanjan. 2003. Euthanasie bei unerträglichem Leid? Eine Studie der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Palliativmedizin zum Thema Sterbehilfe im Jahre 2002. Zeitschrift für Palliativmedizin 4: 75–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Müller-Busch, H.C., F.S. Oduncu, S. Woskanjan, and E. Klaschik. 2004. Attitudes on euthanasia, physician-assisted suicide and terminal sedation - A survey of the members of the German Association for Palliative Medicine. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 7: 333–339.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Oduncu, F. 1999. Sterbebegleitung und Sterbehilfe. Stimmen der Zeit 217: 541–554.Google Scholar
  37. Oduncu, F.S. 2001. Begleiten statt töten! Stimmen der Zeit 219 (8): 520–532.Google Scholar
  38. Oduncu, F.S. 2002. Belgien verabschiedet Euthanasie-Gesetz. Zeitschrift für medizinische Ethik 48: 310–312.Google Scholar
  39. Oduncu, F.S. 2003a. Euthanasie bei unheilbarem Leid? Stimmen der Zeit 221(2): 121–130.Google Scholar
  40. Oduncu, F.S. 2003b. Euthanasia: Killing as due care? Wiener Medizinische Wochenschrift 153: 387–391.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  41. Oduncu, F.S. 2005a. Ärztliche Sterbehilfe im Spannungsfeld von Medizin, Ethik und Recht. Teil 1: Medizinische und rechtliche Aspekte. Medizinrecht 23: 437–445.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Oduncu, F.S. 2005b. Ärztliche Sterbehilfe im Spannungsfeld von Medizin, Ethik und Recht. Teil 2: Palliativmedizinische und medizinethische Aspekte. Medizinrecht 23: 516–524.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Oduncu, F.S. 2006a. Medizin am Ende des Lebens aus der Sicht des Palliativmediziners. Sterben in Würde ist eine Gemeinschaftsaufgabe. Münchener Medizinische WochenschriftFortschritte Medizin 20: 35–38.Google Scholar
  44. Oduncu, F.S. 2006b. Freiheit zum Tod oder Unfreiheit zum Leben? Stimmen der Zeit 224: 597–610.Google Scholar
  45. Oduncu, F.S. 2007a. Sterbebegleitung und sterbehilfe. Medizinethische aspekte. Gynäkologe 40: 947–953.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Oduncu, F.S. 2007b. Würde sterben. Medizinische, ethische und rechtliche Aspekte der Sterbehilfe, Sterbebegleitung und Patientenverfügung. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht.Google Scholar
  47. Oduncu, F.S., and W. Eisenmenger. 2002. Euthanasie, sterbehilfe, sterbebegleitung. Eine kritische Bestandsaufnahme im internationalen Vergleich. Medizinrecht 20(7): 327–337.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, B.D., A. Heide van der, D. Koper, I. Keij-Deerenbert, J.A.C. Rietjens, M.L. Rurup, A.M. Vrakking, J.J. Georges, M.T. Muller, G. van der Wal, and P.J. van der Maas. 2003. Euthanasia and other end-of-life decisions in the Netherlands in 1990, 1995, and 2001. Lancet 362: 395–399.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  49. Ramsey, P. 1970. The patient as person: Explorations in medical ethics. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  50. Reich, W.T. 1978. The encyclopedia of bioethics, ed. Reich, W.T., vol. I, 219. Washington: Macmillan PublishingGoogle Scholar
  51. Sahm, S.W. 2000. Palliative care versus euthanasia. The German position: the German General Medical Council’s principles for medical care of the terminally ill. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 25: 195–219.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  52. Sahm, S.W. 2005. Imperfekte Autonomie und die Grenzen des Instrumentes Patientenverfügung. Zeitschrift für medizinische Ethik 51: 265–275.Google Scholar
  53. Sahm, S.W. 2006. Sterbebegleitung und Patientenverfügung. Frankfurt: Campus.Google Scholar
  54. Sahm, S.W. 2009. Biopolitik: Medizinische ethik und medien. In Diener vieler Herren? Ethische Herausforderungen an den Arzt. Festschrift für helmut siefert, ed. G. Bockenheimer-Lucius, and A, Bell, 161–171. Münster: Lit-Verlag.Google Scholar
  55. Sahm, S.W., R. Will, and G. Hommel. 2005a. What are cancer patients’ preferences about treatment at the end of life? A comparison with healthy people and medical staff. Supportive Care in Cancer 13: 206–214.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  56. Sahm, S.W., R. Will, and G. Hommel. 2005b. Attitudes towards and barriers to write advance directives amongst tumour patients, healthy controls and medical staff. Journal of Medical Ethics 31: 437–440.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  57. Sahm, S.W., R. Will, and G. Hommel. 2005c. Would they follow what has been laid down? Cancer patients` and healthy controls’ views on adherence to advance directives compared to medical staff. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 8: 297–305.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Sartre, J.P. 1943. L’Etre et le Néant. Paris: Gallimard.Google Scholar
  59. Schotsmans, P. 1999. Personalism in medical ethics. Ethical Perspectives 6: 10–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Schreiber, H.L. 1999. Zum Entwurf der Bundesärztekammer für einer Richtlinie zur Sterbehilfe. In Ärztliche Sterbebegleitung. Symposium der Bundesärztekammer, ed. Bundesärztekammer, 20–37. Köln: Deutscher Ärzte.Google Scholar
  61. Spaemann, R. 1997. Es gibt kein gutes Töten. In Töten oder sterben lassen? Worum es in der Euthanasiedebatte geht, ed. R. Spaemann, and T. Fuchs, 12–30. Freiburg i.Br: Herder.Google Scholar
  62. Steinhauser, K.E., N.A. Christakis, E.C. Clipp, M. McNeilly, L. McIntyre, and J.A. Tulsky. 2000. Factors considered important at the end of life by patients, family, physicians, and other care providers. Journal of the American Medical Association 284: 2476–2482.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  63. Suarez-Almazor, M.E., C. Newman, J. Hanson, and E. Bruera. 2002. Attitudes of terminally ill cancer patients about euthanasia and assisted suicide: predominance of psychosocial determinants and beliefs over symptom distress and subsequent survival. Journal of Clinical Oncology 20: 2134–2141.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  64. Tonelli, M.R. 1996. Pulling the plug on living wills. A critical analysis of advance directives. Chest 110: 816–822.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  65. van der Heide, A., B.D. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, M.L. Rurup, H.M. Buiting, J.J. van Delden, J.E. Hanssen-de Wolf, A.G. Janssen, H.R. Pasman, J.A. Rietjens, C.J. Prins, I.M. Deerenberg, J.K. Gevers, P.J. van der Maas, and G. van der Wal. 2007. End-of-life practices in the Netherlands under the Euthanasia act. New England Journal of Medicine 356(19): 1957–1965.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  66. van der Maas, P.J., G. van der Wal, I. Haverkate, C.L.M. de Graaff, J.G. Kester, B.D. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, A. van der Heide, J.M. Bosma, and D.L. Willems. 1996. Euthanasia, physician assisted suicide, and other medical practices involving the end of life in the Netherlands, 1990–1995. New England Journal of Medicine 335: 1699–1705.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  67. van der Wal, G., P.J. van der Maas, J.M. Bosma, B.D. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, D.L. Willems, I. Havertake, and P.J. Kostense. 1996. Evaluation of the notification procedure for physician assisted death in the Netherlands. New England Journal of Medicine 335: 1706–1711.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  68. Verwaltungsgericht Hamburg (Administration Court). 2009. Untersagung kommerzieller Suizidbegleitung. Zeitschrift für Lebensrecht: 48–57.Google Scholar
  69. Wilson, K.G., J.F. Scott, I.D. Graham, J.F. Kozak, S. Chater, R.A. Viola, B.J. de Faye, L.A. Weaver, and D. Curran. 2000. Attitudes of terminally ill patients toward euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. Archives of Internal Medicine 160: 2454–2460.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  70. World Health Organisation. 1990. Cancer pain relief and palliative care. Geneva: World Health Organisation.Google Scholar
  71. World Medical Association. 1987. The World Medical Association resolution on Euthanasia. Available on Accessed 30 June 2009.

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Medizinische Klinik, Campus InnenstadtKlinikum der Universität MünchenMunichGermany
  2. 2.Medizinische Klinik I, Ketteler-KrankenhausOffenbachGermany
  3. 3.Institute for History and Ethics in MedicineGoethe-UniversityFrankfurtGermany

Personalised recommendations