Prisoners’ competence to die: hunger strike and cognitive competence
- 86 Downloads
Several bioethicists have recently advocated the force-feeding of prisoners, based on the assumption that prisoners have reduced or no autonomy. This assumed lack of autonomy follows from a decrease in cognitive competence, which, in turn, supposedly derives from imprisonment and/or being on hunger strike. In brief, causal links are made between imprisonment or voluntary total fasting (VTF) and mental disorders and between mental disorders and lack of cognitive competence. I engage the bioethicists that support force-feeding by severing both of these causal links. Specifically, I refute the claims that VTF automatically and necessarily causes mental disorders such as depression, and that these mental disorders necessarily or commonly entail cognitive impairment. Instead, I critically review more nuanced approaches to assessing mental competence in hunger strikes, urging that a diagnosis of incompetence be made on a case-by-case basis—a position that is widely shared by the medical community.
KeywordsAutonomy Hunger strike Force-feeding Mental competence Mental disorder
Dr. Michael Weingarten passed away while this manuscript was being reviewed. I mourn his passing. I thank Mayli Mertens, Voo Teck Chuan, Marcus Labude, and Owen Schaefer for their constructive comments.
- 2.Reyes, Hernán. 1998. Medical and ethical aspects of hunger strikes in custody and the issue of torture. Geneva: International Committee of the Red Cross. https://www.icrc.org/eng/resources/documents/article/other/health-article-010198.htm. Reprinted from Maltreatment and torture, 291–210, ed. Manfred Oehmichen, 1998, Lübeck: Verlag Schmidt-Römhild.
- 3.Reyes, Hernán, Scott A. Allen, and George J. Annas. 2013. Physicians and hunger strikes in prison: Confrontation, manipulation, medicalization and medical ethics. World Medical Journal 59: 27–101.Google Scholar
- 5.Wei, Marlynn, and Rebecca W. Brendel. 2010. Psychiatry and hunger strikes. Harvard Human Rights Journal 23: 75–109.Google Scholar
- 6.Beauchamp, Tom L., and James F. Childress. 2013. Principles of biomedical ethics, 7th ed. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- 9.Kahn, Yael B., and Adi Harbel. 2015. The Institute for Zionist Strategies: Force feeding of political prisoners who hunger strike—the least of evils. http://izs.org.il/papers/hazana.pdf.
- 11.Barilan, Yechiel Michael. 2015. Force-feeding: Some myths that are important to shatter. Israel Hayom, October 8. http://www.israelhayom.co.il/article/305135.
- 14.Reyes, Hernán. 2007. Force-feeding and coercion: No physician complicity. American Medical Association Journal of Ethics 9: 703–708.Google Scholar
- 15.Kerndt, Peter R., James L. Naughton, Charles E. Driscoll, and David A. Loxterkamp. 1982. Fasting: The history, pathophysiology and complications. Western Journal of Medicine 137: 379–399.Google Scholar
- 18.Donnal, John F., E. Ralph Heinz, and Peter C. Burger. 1990. MR of reversible thalamic lesions in Wernicke syndrome. American Journal of Neuroradiology 11: 893–894.Google Scholar
- 25.Gross, Michael L. 2006. Bioethics and armed conflict: Moral dilemmas of medicine and war. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- 27.World Health Organization. 2018. Depression. http://www.who.int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/depression.
- 29.Kalk, W. John, Michael Felix, Eric R. Snoey, and Yosuf Veriawa. 1993. Voluntary total fasting in political prisoners—clinical and biochemical observations. South African Medical Journal 83: 391–394.Google Scholar
- 31.Childress, James F., Ruth R. Faden, Ruth D. Gaare, Lawrence O. Gostin, Jeffrey Kahn, Richard J. Bonnie, Nancy E. Kass, Anna C. Mastroianni, Jonathan D. Moreno, and Phillip Nieburg. 2002. Public health ethics: Mapping the terrain. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 30: 170–178.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 36.Kahneman, Daniel. 2005. Rationality, fairness, happiness: Selected writings. Jerusalem: Haifa University Press.Google Scholar
- 38.Winter, Eyal. 2014. Feeling smart: Why our emotions are more rational than we think. New York: PublicAffairs.Google Scholar
- 39.Nussbaum, Moshe. 2017. Initiative: Doctors from abroad will feed prisoners on hunger strike by force. Mako, April 5. http://www.mako.co.il/news-military/security-q2_2017/Article-31df8449054db51004.htm.