The self-fulfilling prophecy in intensive care
- 702 Downloads
Predictions of poor prognosis for critically ill patients may become self-fulfilling if life-sustaining treatment or resuscitation is subsequently withheld on the basis of that prediction. This paper outlines the epistemic and normative problems raised by self-fulfilling prophecies (SFPs) in intensive care. Where predictions affect outcome, it can be extremely difficult to ascertain the mortality rate for patients if all treatment were provided. SFPs may lead to an increase in mortality for cohorts of patients predicted to have poor prognosis, they may lead doctors to feel causally responsible for the deaths of their patients, and they may compromise honest communication with patients and families about prognosis. However, I argue that the self-fulfilling prophecy is inevitable when life-sustaining treatment is withheld or withdrawn in the face of uncertainty. SFPs do not necessarily make treatment limitation decisions problematic. To minimize the effects of SFPs, it is essential to carefully collect and appraise evidence about prognosis. Doctors need to be honest with themselves and with patients and their families about uncertainty and the limits of knowledge.
KeywordsPrognosis Futility Withdrawing treatment Intensive care Clinical ethics Resuscitation orders
I am grateful to Tony Hope, Julian Savulescu, Tom Douglas and two anonymous reviewers for very helpful comments on earlier drafts of this paper. Dominic Wilkinson is supported by an Oxford Nuffield Medical Fellowship, Eric Burnard Fellowship, and Royal Australasian College of Physicians Astra-Zeneca Medical Fellowship. The funders had no involvement in this work.
- 1.Merton, Robert King. 1968. Social theory and social structure. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
- 2.Popper, Karl R. 2002. Unended quest: An intellectual autobiography. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- 3.Christakis, N.A. 2001. Prognostication and bioethics. Daedalus 128: 197–214.Google Scholar
- 7.Becker, K.J., A.B. Baxter, W.A. Cohen, H.M. Bybee, D.L. Tirschwell, D.W. Newell, et al. 2001. Withdrawal of support in intracerebral hemorrhage may lead to self-fulfilling prophecies. Neurology 56: 766–772.Google Scholar
- 13.Christakis, Nicholas A. 1999. Death foretold: Prophecy and prognosis in medical care. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- 23.Parfit, D. 2008. On what matters (unpublished manuscript) http://users.ox.ac.uk/~ball2568/parfit/bibliography.htm. Accessed 28 July 2009.