Advertisement

Towards a Confucian Virtue Bioethics: Reframing Chinese Medical Ethics in a Market Economy

  • Ruiping Fan
Article

Abstract

This essay addresses a moral and cultural challenge facing health care in the People’s Republic of China: the need to create an understanding of medical professionalism that recognizes the new economic realities of China and that can maintain the integrity of the medical profession. It examines the rich Confucian resources for bioethics and health care policy by focusing on the Confucian tradition’s account of how virtue and human flourishing are compatible with the pursuit of profit. It offers the Confucian account of the division of labor and the financial inequalities this produces with special attention to China’s socialist project of creating the profession of barefoot doctors as egalitarian peasant physicians and why this project failed. It then further develops the Confucian acknowledgement of the unequal value of different services and products and how this conflicts with the current system of payment to physicians which has led to the corruption of medical professionalism through illegal supplementary payments. It further gives an account the oblique intentionality of Confucian moral psychology that shows how virtuous persons can pursue benevolent actions while both foreseeing profit and avoiding defining their character by greed. This account of Confucian virtue offers the basis for a medical professionalism that can function morally within a robustly profit-oriented market economy. The paper concludes with a summary of the characteristics of Confucian medical professionalism and of how it places the profit motive within its account of virtue ethics.

Keywords

Medical professinalism Confucianism virtue profit corruption 

Notes

Acknowledgements

The author is grateful to Professor H. T. Engelhardt, Jr., Professor Yongfu Cao and Professor Yali Cong for their generous assistance in the development of the argument presented in this essay. He also wishes to thank Editor-in-Chief Daniel P. Sulmasy, editorial assistant Ann Young, and the two anonymous reviewers of this journal for their useful comments and suggestions for finalizing the essay.

References

  1. Alora Angeles Tan., Lumitao Josephine M. Lumito (2001). Beyond a Western Bioethics: Voices from the Developing World. Washington, DC, Georgetown University PressGoogle Scholar
  2. Bayertz Kurt (1996). Sanctity of Life and Human Dignity. Kluwer, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  3. Beauchamp Tom L., Childress James F. (2001) Principles of Biomedical Medical Ethics 2nd Ed. Oxford University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  4. Chen Xiaoyang, Cao Yongfu (2002). Medical Ethics. Shandong University Press, JinanGoogle Scholar
  5. Confucian Analects, The Great Learning & The Doctrine of the Mean. Translated by James Legge. New York: Dover Publications, 1971Google Scholar
  6. Dahl Jacob, Kemp Peter (2000) Basic Ethical Principles in European Bioethics and Biolaw: 2 Volumes. Rhodos International Science & Art, CopenhagenGoogle Scholar
  7. Department of Health. A Collection of Health Care Documents for the Countryside 1951–2000. Beijing, 2001Google Scholar
  8. Engelhardt H.T. Jr. (2002). The Ordination of Bioethicists as Secular Moral Experts. Social Philosophy & Policy 19:59–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Fan Ruiping (2002). Reconstructioninst Confucianism in Health Care: An Asian Moral Account of Health Care Resource Allocation. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 27(6):675–682CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Fan Ruiping, Li Benfu (2004). Truthtelling in Medicine: The Confucian View. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 29(2):179–193CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Hoshino Kazumasa (1997). Japanese and Western Bioethics. Kluwer, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  12. Hottois, Gilbert. “Dignity of the Human Body—A Philosophical and Critical Approach.” In Bioethics and Biolaw, vol. 2, Four Ethical Principles. Edited by P. Kemp, J. Rendtorff, and N. M. Johansen. 87–102. (Copenhagen: Rhodos International Science and Art Publishers, 2000)Google Scholar
  13. Ivanhoe P.J. (1999). The Concept of de (Virtue) in the Laozi.#x201D; In: M., Ivanhoe P.J. (eds), Religious Philosophical Aspects of the Laozi. Csikszentmihalyi. State University of New York Press, Albany, pp. 239–257Google Scholar
  14. Huntington Samuel P. (2004). Who Are We: The Challenges to America’s National Identity. Simon & Schuster, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  15. Jiang Qing (2003). Political Confucianism. Sanlian Book House, BeijingGoogle Scholar
  16. Kang Xiaoguang (2005). Benevolent Government. Global Publishing Company, SingaporeGoogle Scholar
  17. Krause E.A. (1996). Death of the Guilds. Yale University Press, New HavenGoogle Scholar
  18. Kunming Medical School Institute of Health. (2002). From Barefoot Doctors to Village Doctors. Kunming, Yunnan People’s PressGoogle Scholar
  19. Lu’s Commentary on the Spring and Autumn Annals, vol. 2. Edited by Z. Yuchun. Haerbin: Helunjiang Renmin Press, 2003Google Scholar
  20. \({\hbox{L}\check{\ddot{\hbox{u}}}}\), Kuanhou “From the Growth of ‘Barefoot Doctors’ to See the Direction of Revolution in Medical Education: A Survey Report on Shanghai.” Red Flag 3 (Sept. 10, 1968): 20-6Google Scholar
  21. MacIntyre Alasdair (1990). Three Rival Versions of Moral Enquiry. Notre Dame University Press, Notre DameGoogle Scholar
  22. Mencius. The Works of Mencius. Translated by J. Legge. New York: Dover Publications, 1970Google Scholar
  23. Meulen R., Arts W., Muffels R. (2001). Solidarity in Health and Social Care in Europe. Kluwer, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  24. Nivison David (1996). The Ways of Confucianism: Investigations in Chinese Philosophy. Open Court Press, La SalleGoogle Scholar
  25. Potter Van Rensselaer (1970a). ioethics, the Science of Survival. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 14:127–53Google Scholar
  26. Potter Van Rensselaer (1970b). Biocybernetics and Survival. Zygon 5:229–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Potter Van Rensselaer (1971). Bioethics, Bridge to the Future. Prentice-Hall, Englewood CliffsGoogle Scholar
  28. Qiu Ren-Zong (2004). Bioethics: Asian Perspectives, A Quest for Moral Diversity. Kluwer, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  29. Reich Warren (1994). “The Word ‘Bioethics’: Its Birth and the Legacies of Those who Shaped its Meaning.” Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 4:319–336Google Scholar
  30. Rendtorff Jacob (2000). The Second International Conference about Bioethics and Biolaw: European Principles in Bioethics and Biolaw. In: Kemp P., Rendtorff J., Johansen N.M. (eds), Bioethics and Biolaw, vol 2, Four Ethical Principles. Rhodos International Science and Art Publishers, Copenhagen, pp. 157–166Google Scholar
  31. Rouner L.S., Langford J. (1996). Philosophy, Religion, and Contemporary Life: Essays on Perennial Problems, Boston University Studies in Philosophy and Religion. Special Issue. Boston, University Press BostonGoogle Scholar
  32. Sachße, Christoph and H. T. Englehardt, Jr. Sicherheit und Freiheit: Zur Ethik des Wohlfahrtsstaates. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, 1990Google Scholar
  33. Sima, Qian Record of History (shi ji). Changsha: Yuelu Book House, 1994Google Scholar
  34. Tao J. (2002). Cross-Cultural Perspectives on the (Im)Possibility of Global Bioethics. Kluwer, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  35. Tao, Julia. Bioethics, Trust, and the Challenge of the Market. New York: Springer, forthcomingGoogle Scholar
  36. Unschuld Paul (1979). Medical Ethics in Imperial China. Berkeley, University of California PressGoogle Scholar
  37. Walter Jennifer K., Klein Eran P. (2003). The Story of Bioethics. Washington DC, Georgetown University PressGoogle Scholar
  38. Wilson John (1986). Common Religion in American Society. In: Rouner L. (eds), Civil Religion and Political Theology. Notre Dame, University of Notre Dame Press, pp. 11Google Scholar
  39. Wu, Zeng (Song). Informal Records of Nenguizai (Nengaizai Manlu). Shanghai: Shanghai Classics Press, 1984Google Scholar
  40. Xia Xinzheng (2003). A historical investigation on the cooperative medical care system in the countryside. Contemporary China History Studies 10(5):110–118Google Scholar
  41. Xunzi. Translated by J. Knoblock. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1988Google Scholar
  42. Yan, Lueshan “Was the Institution of Barefoot Doctors Really Beautiful?” South Daily, February 13, 2004Google Scholar
  43. Zhao Gang, Chen Zhongyi (1991). A History of Chinese Economic Systems (Zhongguo Jinji Zhidushi). Beijing, Chinese Economic PressGoogle Scholar
  44. Zhao G., Chen Z. (1996) A History of the Chinese System of Land (Zhongguo Tudi Zhidushi). Taipei, Lianjing Chuban Shiye GongsiGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Public and Social Administration CityUniversity of Hong KongKowloonChina

Personalised recommendations