Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics

, Volume 26, Issue 5, pp 397–425 | Cite as

Historical and Philosophical Perspectives on Experimental Practice in Medicine and the Life Sciences

  • Frank W. Stahnisch


The aim of this paper is to discuss a key question in the history and philosophy of medicine, namely how scholars should treat the practices and experimental hypotheses of modern life science laboratories. The paper seeks to introduce some prominent historiographical methods and theoretical approaches associated with biomedical research. Although medical scientists need no convincing that experimentation has a significant function in their laboratory work, historians, philosophers, and sociologists long neglected its importance when examining changes in medical theories or progress in scientific knowledge. The reason appears to have been the academic influence of the then dominant tradition in the history of ideas, but was also due to a misconception of what could usefully be termed the view on “historical ontology.” During the last two decades, there have been many books and research articles that have turned towards the subject, so that the study of experimental practice has become a major trend in the contemporary history and philosophy of medicine. A closer look at the issue of laboratory research shows that concepts in medicine and the life sciences cannot be understood as historically constant, free-standing ideas, but have to be regarded as dependent on local research settings. They often carry particular “social memories” with them and thus acquire important ethical implications.


experimental hypotheses historical ontology history of medicine medical epistemology social constructivism 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Ackermann, R. 1989“Review Article The New Experimentalism”The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science40185190Google Scholar
  2. Bernard, C 1957An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine, Translated by Henry Copley GreeneDoverNew York French ed. 1865Google Scholar
  3. Biagioli, M. eds. 1999The Science Studies ReaderRoutledgeNew York, LondonGoogle Scholar
  4. Bowden, M.E.Hahn, T.B.Williams, R.W. eds. 1998Proceedings of the 1998 Conference on the History and Heritage of Science Information SystemsMedfordNJGoogle Scholar
  5. Brandt, C 2004Metapher und Experiment. Von der Virusforschung zum Genetischen CodeWallsteinGoettingenGoogle Scholar
  6. Brazier, M 1988A History of Neurophysiology in the Nineteenth CenturySchuhmann’sNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  7. Burian, R.M. 1993“Task Definition, and the Transition from Genetics to Molecular Genetics: Aspects of the Work on Protein Synthesis in the Laboratories of J. Monod and P. Zamecnik”Journal of the History of Biology26387407CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Canguilhem, G 1966Le normal et le pathologiquePresses Universitaires de FranceParisGoogle Scholar
  9. Carruthers, P.Stich, S.P.Siegal, M. eds. 2002The Cognitive Basis of ScienceCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  10. Clarke, E. eds. 1971Modern Methods in the History of MedicineThe Athlone Press of the University of LondonLondonGoogle Scholar
  11. Cole, S 1992Making Science Between Nature and SocietyHarvard University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  12. Coleman, W. 1985“The Cognitive Basis of the Discipline: Claude Bernard on Physiology”Isis764970CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Coleman, W.Holmes, F.L. eds. 1988The Investigative Enterprise Experimental Physiology in Nineteenth-Century MedicineUniversity of California PressBerkeley, Los Angeles, LondonGoogle Scholar
  14. Chadarevian, S 2002Designs for Life Molecular Biology after World War IICambridge University PressCambridge, New York, MelbourneGoogle Scholar
  15. Dierig, S.Schmidgen, H. eds. 1999Physiologische und psychologische Praktiken im 19 Jahrhundert: Ihre Beziehungen zu Literatur, Kunst und TechnikMax-Planck-Institute for the History of ScienceBerlin (Preprint 120)Google Scholar
  16. Franklin, A 1986The Neglect of ExperimentCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  17. Franklin, A 1990Experiment – Right or WrongCambridge University PressCambridge, New York, Port ChesterGoogle Scholar
  18. Fujimura, J.H 1996Crafting Science A Sociohistory of the Quest for the Genetics of CancerHarvard University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  19. Galison, P 1987How Experiments EndUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  20. Giere, R.N.Westfall, and R.S. eds. 1973Foundations of Scientific Method: The Nineteenth CenturyIndiana University PressBloomingtonGoogle Scholar
  21. Gieryn, T.F 1999Cultural Boundaries of ScienceThe University of Chicago PressChicago, LondonGoogle Scholar
  22. Gimmler, A.Lenk, C.Aumueller, G. eds. 2003Health and Quality of Life. Philosophical, Medical, and Cultural AspectsLIT-VerlagMuensterGoogle Scholar
  23. Goodfield, G.J 1960The Growth of Scientific PhysiologyHutchinsonLondonGoogle Scholar
  24. Gooding, D.Pinch, T.Schaffer, S. eds. 1989The Uses of Experiment – Strategies in the Natural SciencesCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  25. Gradmann, C. 2000“Money and Microbes. Robert Koch, Tuberculin and the Foundation of the Institute for Infectious Diseases in Berlin in 1891”History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences225979PubMedGoogle Scholar
  26. Grmek, M.D. eds. 1965Claude Bernard Cahier De Notes 1850–1860GallimardParisGoogle Scholar
  27. Guenther, N 1951Ernst Abbé Schoepfer der Zeiss-StiftungWissenschaftliche VerlagsgesellschaftStuttgartGoogle Scholar
  28. Hacking, I 2002Historical OntologyHarvard University PressCambridge, MA, LondonGoogle Scholar
  29. Hacking, I 1983Representing and Intervening. Introductory Topics in the Philosophy of Natural ScienceCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  30. Haigh, E 1984Xavier Bichat and the Medical Theory of the Eighteenth CenturyWellcome Institute for the History of MedicineLondonGoogle Scholar
  31. Haraway, D. 1988“Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective”Feminist Studies14575599Google Scholar
  32. Hess, V 2000Der wohltemperierte Mensch. Wissenschaft und Alltag des Fiebermessens (1850–1900)CampusFrankfurt/M., New YorkGoogle Scholar
  33. Hess, V. 1998Medical Semiotics in the 18th Century: A Theory of PracticeTheoretical Medicine19203219CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hill, A.V 1970First and Last Experiments in Muscle MechanicsCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  35. Holmes, F.L. 1992Do We Understand Historically How Experimental Knowledge is Acquired?History of Science30119136Google Scholar
  36. Honnefelder, L. eds. 2003Das genetische Wissen und die Zukunft des MenschenSpringerBerlinGoogle Scholar
  37. Jacob, F 1988The Statue Within: An AutobiographyBasic BooksNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  38. Jordanova, L. 1995The Social Construction of Medical KnowledgeSocial History of Medicine8361380PubMedGoogle Scholar
  39. Keller, E.F.Loyd, E. eds. 1992Keywords in Evolutionary BiologyCambridge University PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  40. Knorr-Cetina, K 1981The Manufacture of Knowledge: An Essay on the Constructivist and the Contextual Nature of SciencePergamon PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  41. Knorr-Cetina, K 1999Epistemic Cultures. How the Sciences Make KnowledgeHarvard University PressCambridge, MA, London, EnglandGoogle Scholar
  42. Labisch, A. 2000“Medizin als Wissenschaft – Medizin als Kunst”Medizin, Gesellschaft, Geschichte19932Google Scholar
  43. Labisch, A.Paul, and N.W. eds. 2004Historizitaet. Erfahrung und Handeln – Geschichte und MedizinFranz Steiner VerlagStuttgartGoogle Scholar
  44. Latour, B 1999Politics of Nature How to Bring the Sciences into DemocracyHarvard University PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  45. Latour, B 1987Science in Action How to Follow Scientists and Engineers Through SocietyHarvard University PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  46. Latour, B.Woolgar, S. eds. 1979Laboratory Life. The Social Construction of Scientific FactsSAGE PublicationsBeverly Hills, LondonGoogle Scholar
  47. Le Grand, H.E. eds. 1980Experimental Inquiries – Historical, Philosophical and Social Studies of Experimentation in ScienceKluwerDordrechtGoogle Scholar
  48. Lenoir, T 1992Politik im Tempel der Wissenschaft. Forschung und Machtausübung im deutschen Kaiserreich, German translator Horst BruehmannCampusFrankfurt/M., New YorkGoogle Scholar
  49. Lenoir, T. 1988“A Magic Bullett: Research for Profit and the Growth of Knowledge in Germany” Around 1900Minerva266688CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Lesky, E. 1964Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis und die Wiener Medizinische SchuleH. Boehlaus NachfolgerViennaGoogle Scholar
  51. Loewy, I. 1992The Strength of Loose ConceptsHistory of Science30371396Google Scholar
  52. Loewy, I. 1988Ludwik Fleck on the Social Construction of Medical KnowledgeSociology of Health and Illness19133155Google Scholar
  53. Machaner, P.K.Grush, R.McLaughlin, and P. eds. 2001Theory and Method in the NeurosciencesPittsburgh University PressPittsburghGoogle Scholar
  54. Mayr, E. 1990``When is Historiography Whiggish?''Journal of the History of Ideas51301309Google Scholar
  55. Millet, R 1944Claude Bernard ou l’aventure scientifiqueGallimardParisGoogle Scholar
  56. Monod, J 1998Of Flies, Mice, and MenHarvard University PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  57. Olesko, K. eds. 1989Science in Germany. The Intersection of Institutional and Intellectual IssuesCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  58. Paul, N.W. 1998Incurable Suffering from the ‘Hiatus Theoreticus’? Some Epistemological Problems in Modern Medicine and the Clinical Relevance of Philosophy of MedicineTheoretical Medicine19229251CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Paul, N.W. “Genes, Information, Morphing Bodies: On the Mutually Dependent Reinvention of Biomedicine and Humans.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine (in Press)Google Scholar
  60. Paul, N.W.Schlich, T. eds. 1998Medizingeschichte: Aufgaben, Probleme, PerspektivenCampusFrankfurt/M., New YorkGoogle Scholar
  61. Pickering, A. eds. 1992Science as Practice and CultureThe University of Chicago PressChicago, LondonGoogle Scholar
  62. Pickstone, J.V. 1981“Bureaucracy, Liberalism and the Body in Post-revolutionary France”History of Science19115142PubMedGoogle Scholar
  63. Polanyi, M 1967The Tacit DimensionKegan PaulLondon, RoutledgeGoogle Scholar
  64. Pruell, C.R. eds. 2003Traditions of Pathology in Western Europe. Theories, Institutions and their Cultural SettingCentaurusPfaffenweilerGoogle Scholar
  65. Rabinow, P 1996Making PCR: A Story of BiotechnologyChicago University PressChicacoGoogle Scholar
  66. Rather, L.J 1958Disease, Life and Man: Selected Essays by Rudolf VirchowStanford University PressStanfordGoogle Scholar
  67. Rheinberger, H.J. 2001“History of Science and the Practices of Experiment”History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences235163PubMedGoogle Scholar
  68. Rheinberger, H.J 1997Toward a History of Epistemic Things Synthesizing Proteins in the Test TubeStanford University PressStanfordGoogle Scholar
  69. Rheinberger, H.J. 1996“Comparing Experimental Systems: Protein synthesis in microbes and in animal tissue at Cambridge (Ernst F Gale) and at the Massachusetts General Hospital (Paul C Zamecnik), 1945–1960”Journal of the History of Biology29387416CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  70. Rosenberg, C.E.Golden, J. eds. 1992Framing Disease Studies in Cultural HistoryRutgers University PressNew Brunswick, NJGoogle Scholar
  71. Rothschuh, K.E 1973History of PhysiologyKriegerHuntington, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  72. Schaffner, K 1993Discovery and Explanation in Biology and MedicineThe University of Chicago PressChicago, LondonGoogle Scholar
  73. Schlich, T. 2000``Linking Cause and Disease in the Laboratory: Robert Koch’s Method of Superimposing Visual and Functional Representation of BacteriaHistory and Philosophy of the Life Sciences224358PubMedGoogle Scholar
  74. Shapin, S.Schaffer, S. eds. 1985Leviathan and the Air-Pump: Hobbes, Boyle, and the Experimental LifePrinceton University PressPrincetonGoogle Scholar
  75. Sober, E 1993Philosophy of BiologyOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  76. Stahnisch, F.W. 2005“Review Article. Ian Hacking, Historical Ontology”Journal of the History of the Neurosciences146468Google Scholar
  77. Stahnisch, F.W 2003Ideas in Action – Der Funktionsbegriff und seine methodologische Rolle im Forschungsprogramm des Experimentalphysiologen François Magendie (1783–1855)LIT-VerlagMuenster, Hamburg, LondonGoogle Scholar
  78. Belt, H. 2003How to Engage With Experimental Practices? Moderate Versus Radical ConstructivismJournal for General Philosophy of Science34201219CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Warner, J.H. 1995The History of Science and the Sciences of MedicineOsiris10164193CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  80. Winslow, C.E. eds. 1944The Conquest of Epidemic DiseasePrinceton University PressPrincetonGoogle Scholar
  81. Wolters, G.Lennox, J.McLaughlin, P. eds. 1995Concepts, Theories, and Rationality in the Biological SciencesUKV-Universitaetsverlag Konstanz and University of Pittsburgh PressKonstanz, PittsburghGoogle Scholar
  82. Wright, P.Treacher , A. eds. 1982The Problem of Medical Knowledge: Examining the Social Construction of MedicineEdinburgh University PressEdinburghGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Institute for History, Philosophy and Ethics of MedicineJohannes Gutenberg-University of MainzMainzGermany

Personalised recommendations