Advertisement

Metascience

, Volume 20, Issue 2, pp 339–341 | Cite as

Against species essentialism

John S. Wilkins: Species: A history of the idea. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2009. xiv+320 pp, $49.95 HB
  • Olivier Rieppel
Book Review

What is a species? Darwin, with Sir John Herschel, called it the ‘mystery of mysteries’. John Wilkins traces the history of this question from Plato and Aristotle via Locke and Darwin to Mayr, Hennig, and into contemporary debates about species concepts. Before he begins, Wilkins justifies the writing of a history of ideas, something that he notes is out of fashion with professional historians. Indeed, it may be difficult to accept Wilkins’s comparison of the topology of Porphyry’s treewith a contemporary cladogram (29 & 205), the idea that Pierre Belon (1517–1564) was occupied with the study of homology (54), that Darwin came close to being a cladist (153; Wilkins concedes the anachronism here implied in a footnote), or that Trémaux delivered a punctuated equilibrium theory in 1865. Τhis is the treatment of ideas as “free-floating objects” (viii) which historians tend to object to. In the case of ideas about species, Wilkins finds philosophers and historians better equipped to write...

References

  1. Bonnet, C. 1768. Considération sur les Corps Organisés, 2nd Ed., Vol. II, Amsterdam.Google Scholar
  2. Bonnet, C. 1769. La Palingénésie Philosophique, Vol. I, Genève.Google Scholar
  3. Schlee D. 1971. Die Rekonstruktion der Phylogenese mit Hennig’s Prinzip. Aufsätze und Reden der Senckenbergischen Naturforschenden Gesellschaft. Waldemar Kramer, Frankfurt a.M.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of GeologyThe Field MuseumChicagoUSA

Personalised recommendations