Language Policy

, Volume 4, Issue 4, pp 371–394 | Cite as

Raising English Language Standards in Hong Kong

  • Vivien Berry
  • Arthur McNeill


Despite the return of sovereignty to China in 1997, the Hong Kong government acknowledges that a high level of English language ability is still required among the workforce in order to maintain Hong Kong’s position as an international commercial centre. Although there is no shortage of willingness on the part of the government to introduce measures to improve worrying English language standards, implementing such innovations has proved difficult. After briefly outlining several measures introduced over the past 20 years, we examine two specific language policy innovations: the introduction of a public examination format designed to have a beneficial washback effect on teaching and the employment of hundreds of native English speakers to teach English in the primary and secondary sectors. We conclude that although both measures are potentially valuable means of bringing about improvements in language learning, they need to be handled with caution if they are to form part of strategic language policy.


English language enhancement English language standards examination washback Hong Kong native English speaker teachers 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Alderson, J. Charles, Hamp-Lyons, Liz 1996TOEFL preparation course: a study of washbackLanguage Testing13280297Google Scholar
  2. Alderson, J. Charles, Wall, Dianne 1992The Sri Lankan O-Level English language, valuation project, fourth and final reportLancaster UniversityLancasterGoogle Scholar
  3. Alderson, J. Charles, Wall, Dianne 1993Does washback exist?Applied Linguistics14115129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Andrews, Stephen, Fullilove, John 1994Assessing spoken English in public examinations – why and how?Boyle, JosephFalvey, Peter eds. English language testing in Hong KongThe Chinese University PressHong Kong5785Google Scholar
  5. Andrews, Stephen, Fullilove, John, Wong, Yama 2002Targeting washback – a case studySystem30207223CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Andrews, Stephen, McNeill, Arthur 2005Knowledge about language and the “good language teacher”Bartels, Nat eds. Applied linguistics in language teacher educationSpringerBoston, MA159178Google Scholar
  7. Bachman, Lyle F. 1988Problems in examining the validity of the ACTFL oral proficiency interviewStudies in Second Language Acquisition10149164CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bartels, Nat eds. 2005Applied linguistics in language teacher educationSpringerBoston, MAGoogle Scholar
  9. Berry, Vivien 2004A study of the interaction between individual personality differences and oral performance test facetsKing’s College: University of LondonLondonUnpublished Ph.D dissertation.Google Scholar
  10. Berry, Vivien, Lewkowicz, Jo 2000Exit tests: Is there an alternative?Berry, VivienLewkowicz, Jo eds. Assessment in Chinese contexts: Special Issue of the Hong Kong Journal of Applied LinguisticsThe English Centre, The University of Hong KongHong Kong1949Google Scholar
  11. Berry, Vivien, Lewkowicz, Jo 2004European solutions to non-European problemsMilanovic, M.Weir, C. eds. Studies in language testing 18. European language testing in a global context. Proceedings of the ALTE Barcelona conference july 2001Cambridge University PressCambridge7392Google Scholar
  12. Bonk, William J., Ockey, Gary 2003A many-facet rasch analysis of the second language group discussion taskLanguage Testing20125CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Boyle, Joseph 1997Native-speaker teachers of English in Hong KongLanguage and Education11163181Google Scholar
  14. Cheng, Liying 1997How does washback influence teaching? Implications for Hong KongLanguage and Education113854CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Cheng, Liying 1998Impact of a public English examination change on students’ perceptions and attitudes toward their English learningStudies in Educational Evaluation24279301Google Scholar
  16. Clark, John L, Scarino, Angela, Brownell, John A. 1994Improving the quality of learning: A framework for Target-Oriented Curriculum renewal in Hong KongHong Kong Bank Language Development Fund/Institute of Language in EducationHong KongGoogle Scholar
  17. Cook, Vivian 1999Going beyond the native speaker in language teachingTESOL Quarterly33185209Google Scholar
  18. Curriculum Development Council. (1999). CDC syllabus for English language (Secondary 1–5) Retrieved from Content_2801/sec-lang.pdf
  19. Crystal, David 1997English as a global languageCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  20. Davies, Alan 1991The native speaker in applied linguisticsEdinburgh University PressEdinburghGoogle Scholar
  21. Education Commission1996Education Commission Report Number 6. Enhancing language proficiency: A comprehensive strategy (ECR6)Government PrinterHong KongGoogle Scholar
  22. Education Commission (2005). Review of medium of instruction for secondary schools and secondary school places allocation. Retrieved from, February 2005
  23. Education and Manpower Bureau Press Release (2000). Information and news. Press releases: Arrangements on medium of instruction continue till 2003/04. Retrieved from, 25 November 2003
  24. Eysenck, Sybil B. G., Chan, Jimmy 1982A comparative study of personality in adults and children: Hong Kong vs. EnglandPersonality and Individual Differences3153160Google Scholar
  25. Gaies, Stephen 1977The nature of linguistic input in formal second language learning: Linguistic and communication strategies in ESL teacher’s classroom languageDouglas Brown, H.Yorio, Carlos A.Crymes, Ruth eds. On TESOL’77. Teaching and learning English as a second language: Trends in research and practiceTESOLWashington, DC204212Google Scholar
  26. Gaies, Stephen 1982Native-speaker non-native speaker interaction among academic peersStudies in Second Language Acquisition57481Google Scholar
  27. Goulden, Robin, Nation, Paul I. S., Read, John 1990How large can a receptive vocabulary be?Applied Linguistics11341363CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hamp-Lyons, Liz 1999Implications of the “examination culture” for (English language) education in Hong KongCrew, VernonBerry, VivienHung, Joseph eds. Exploring diversity in the language curriculumThe Hong Kong Institute of EducationHong KongGoogle Scholar
  29. He, An E. 2004Use of verbs in teacher talk: A comparison study between LETS and NETSHong Kong Journal of Applied Linguistics93854Google Scholar
  30. Henzl, Věra M. 1979Foreigner talk in the classroomIRAL17159167Google Scholar
  31. Hilsdon, Janet 1991The group oral exam: advantages and limitationsCharles Alderson,  J.North, Brian eds. Language testing in the 1990sModern English Publications and The British CouncilLondon189197Google Scholar
  32. Izawa, Hiroyuki 1993The English vocabulary of 21 Japanese adults on a high proficiency levelJALT Journal156378Google Scholar
  33. Johnson, R. Keith 1996Bilingual education policy and implementation in Hong Kong: Where are we, and where are we going?Storey, PeterBerry, VivienBunton, DavidHoare, Philip eds. Issues in language in educationThe Hong Long Institute of EducationHong Kong125143Google Scholar
  34. Johnson, R. Keith 1998Language and education in Hong KongPennington, Marthac eds. Language in Hong Kong at century’s endHong Kong University PressHong Kong265276Google Scholar
  35. King, Rex 1994Historical survey of English language testing in Hong KongBoyle, JosephFalvey, Peter eds. English language testing in Hong Kong The Chinese University PressHong Kong329Google Scholar
  36. Kramsch, Claire 1997The privilege of the non-native speakerPMLA112359369Google Scholar
  37. Kramsch, Claire 1998Between self and otherBerry, VivienMcNeill, Arthur eds. Policy and practice in language educationDepartment of Curriculum Studies, The University of Hong KongHong Kong4361Google Scholar
  38. Krashen, Stephen 1980The input hypothesisAlatis, James E. eds. Current issues in bilingual educationGeorgetown University PressWashington, DC168180Google Scholar
  39. Lee, Siu F. (1999). An investigation of teachers’ interpretations of target oriented assessment in English language. Unpublished MA dissertation. The English Centre, The University of Hong KongGoogle Scholar
  40. Li, Kenneth C. 1997The labyrinth of exit standard controlsHong Kong Journal of Applied Linguistics22338Google Scholar
  41. Lin, Angel M. Y. 1999Doing-English-lessons in the reproduction or transformation of social worlds?TESOL Quarterly33393412Google Scholar
  42. Long, Michael 1983aNative speaker/non-native speaker conversation and the negotiation of comprehensible inputApplied Linguistics4126141CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Long, Michael 1983bNative speaker/non-native speaker conversation in the second language classroomClarke, Mark A.Handscombe, Jean eds. On TESOL ‘82: Pacific perspectives on language learning and teachingTESOLWashington, DC207225Google Scholar
  44. Lumley, Tom, Qian, David 2003Assessing English for employment in Hong KongCoombe, Christine A.Hubley, Nancy J. eds. Assessment practicesTESOLAlexandria, VA135147Google Scholar
  45. Lurda, Enric eds. 2005Non-native language teachers: Perceptions, challenges, and contributions to the professionSpringerBoston, MAGoogle Scholar
  46. McNeill, Arthur 1996Vocabulary knowledge profiles: Evidence from Chinese-speaking ESL teachersHong Kong Journal of Applied Linguistics13963Google Scholar
  47. McNeill, Arthur (1998). Teachers’ awareness of lexical difficulty in ESL reading texts. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of WalesGoogle Scholar
  48. Madaus, George F. 1988The influence of testing on the curriculumTanner, Laurel N. eds. Critical issues in the curriculum: 87th yearbook of the national society for the study of education, Part 1University of Chicago PressChicago83121Google Scholar
  49. Medgyes, Peter 1992Native or non-native: Who’s worth more?English Language Teaching Journal46340349Google Scholar
  50. Medgyes, Peter 1994The non-native teacherMacmillanLondonGoogle Scholar
  51. Messick, Samuel J. 1996Validity and washback in language testingLanguage Testing13241256Google Scholar
  52. Morris, Paul 1999Target oriented curriculum: Feedback and assessment in Hong Kong primary schoolsEducation DepartmentHong KongGoogle Scholar
  53. Paikeday, Thomas M. 1985The native speaker is deadPaikeday Publishing IncTorontoGoogle Scholar
  54. Poon, Anita Y.K. 1998Bilingualism and monolingualism: A shift in Hong Kong’s language in education policyBerry, VivienMcNeill, Arthur eds. Policy and practice in language educationDepartment of Curriculum Studies, The University of Hong KongHong Kong89104Google Scholar
  55. Shepard, Lorrie A. 1993Evaluating test validityReview of Research in Education19405450Google Scholar
  56. Shohamy, Elana 2001The power of tests: A critical perspective on the uses of language testsPearson Education LtdNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  57. Shohamy, Elana, Reves, Thea, Bejarano, Yael 1986Introducing a new comprehensive test of oral proficiencyELT Journal40489508CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Spolsky, Bernard 1990Social aspects of individual assessmentJong, John H. A. L.Stevenson, Douglas K. eds. Individualizing the assessment of language abilitiesMultilingual MattersClevedon, PA315Google Scholar
  59. Storey, Peter, Luk, Jasmine, Gray, Jeremy, Wang-Kho, Elena, Lin, Angel, Berry, Rita S. Y. 2001Monitoring and evaluation of the native-speaking English teacher scheme: Technical reportHong Kong Institute of EducationHong KongGoogle Scholar
  60. Tsui, Amy B.M. 1993Challenges in education and continuous teacher developmentTsui, Amy B.M.Ivor Johnson,  eds. Teacher education and development. Education paper 18Faculty of Education, The University of Hong KongHong Kong1328Google Scholar
  61. Visiting Panel1982A perspective on education in Hong Kong: Report by a visiting panelGovernment PrinterHong KongGoogle Scholar
  62. Wagner-Gough, Judy, Hatch, Evelyn 1975The importance of input data in second language acquisition studiesLanguage Learning25297308Google Scholar
  63. Wall, Dianne 1994Measuring examination ‘washback’: The Sri Lankan evaluation projectFlavell, Roger H. eds. ELT Policy and its impact: A case studyModern English Publications and The British CouncilLondon103122Google Scholar
  64. Wall, Dianne, Alderson, J. Charles 1993Examining washback: The Sri Lankan impact studyLanguage Testing104169Google Scholar
  65. Watanabe, Yoshinori 1996Investigating washback in Japanese EFL classrooms; problems of methodologyWigglesworth, GillianCatherine, Elder eds. The language testing cycle: From inception to washbackAustralian National University/Applied Linguistics Association of AustraliaCanberra208239Google Scholar
  66. Williams, Ray, Dallas, Don 1984Aspects of vocabulary in the readability of content area L2 educational textbooks: A case studyCharles Alderson, J.Urquhart, Alexander H. eds. Reading in a foreign languageLongmanLondon199210Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.The English CentreThe University of Hong Kong Hong Kong SAR, PRC
  2. 2.English Language Teaching UnitChinese University of Hong KongShatinHong Kong SAR PRC

Personalised recommendations