Abstract
Recent quantitative site-based monitoring and qualitative aerial and ground traverses provide contrasting assessments of the health of much of the arid shrublands of Western Australia extensively grazed by livestock (‘rangelands’). Although these results seem incompatible, we explain the apparent contradictions based on landscape succession processes operating at multiple levels of ecological organisation. Specifically, we suggest that the intact areas in which site-based monitoring is conducted are contracting as catchment canalisation and desiccation increase. However, the impacts of these processes have not yet become manifest at the site scale. The site-based system addresses important regional questions. These relate to the large, relatively intact areas away from most active surface flows, which should be a focus for resource conservation, given practical limits to repairing widespread degradation with low management inputs. We provide a complementary set of questions to provide a more comprehensive audit of rangeland dynamics in the context of underlying hierarchical landscape patterns and processes that might threaten intact areas. We recognise the need to match questions and levels of ecological organisation and the implications these have for sampling. We also recognise the difficulty in producing concise statements of change for clients when reporting on complex ecological issues and processes. Without a clearly articulated, and well understood, hierarchical model of pattern and process within which apparently contradictory findings can be reported meaningfully, policy makers may be confused by the results, with the consequent risk of policy inaction.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
T.F.H. Allen T.W. Hoekstra (1992) Toward a Unified Ecology Columbia University Press New York, USA
Allen T.F.H., O’Neill R.V.O. and Hoekstra T.W. 1984. Interlevel relations in ecological research and management: some working principles from hierarchy theory. General Technical Report RM-110, USDA Forest Service.
T.F.H. Allen T.B. Starr (1982) Hierarchy Perspective for Ecological Complexity University of Chicago Press Chicago, USA
Anon (1998) Gascoyne–Murchison Western Australia Climatic survey Bureau of Meteorology, Department of the Environment and Heritage Canberra, ACT, Australia 113
G.N. Bastin J.A. Ludwig R.W. Eager V.H. Chewings A.C. Liedloff (2002) ArticleTitleIndicators of landscape function: comparing patchiness metrics using remotely-sensed data from rangelands Ecol. Indicat. 1 247–260 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1470-160X(02)00009-2
G. Bergkamp (1995) ArticleTitleA hierarchical approach for desertification assessment Environ. Monit. Assess. 37 59–78 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00546880
D.D. Briske S.D. Fuhlendorf F.E. Smiens (2003) ArticleTitleVegetation dynamics on rangelands: A critique of the current paradigms J. Appl. Ecol. 40 601–614 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1365-2664.2003.00837.x
D.D. Briske S.D. Fuhlendorf F.E. Smiens (2005) ArticleTitleState-and-transition models, thresholds and rangeland health: a synthesis of ecological models and perspectives Range Ecol. Manage. 58 1–10 Occurrence Handle10.2111/1551-5028(2005)58<1:SMTARH>2.0.CO;2
C.S. Christian G.A. Stewart (1953) General Report on Survey of Katherine–Darwin region, 1946. CSIRO Australian Land Research Series, Number 1 CSIRO Melbourne, Australia
M.B. Coughenour J.E. Ellis (1993) ArticleTitleLandscape and climate control of woody vegetation in a dry tropical ecosystem: Turkana District, Kenya J. Biogeogr. 20 383–398 Occurrence Handle10.2307/2845587
P.J. Curry A.L. Payne K.A. Leighton P. Hennig D. Blood (1994) An Inventory and Condition Survey of the Murchison River Catchment and Surrounds, Western Australia Department of Agriculture Western Australia Perth, Western Australia 430
D.L. DeAngelis J.C. Waterhouse (1987) ArticleTitleEquilibrium and nonequilibrium concepts in ecological models Ecol. Monogr. 57 1–21 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1942636
M.D. Eve W.G. Whitford K.M. Havstadt (1999) ArticleTitleApplying satellite imagery to triage assessment of ecosystem health Environ. Monit. Assess. 54 205–227 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1005876220078
M.H. Friedel (1994) ArticleTitleHow spatial and temporal scale affect the perception of change in rangelands The Rangeland J. 16 16–25 Occurrence Handle10.1071/RJ9940016
M.H. Friedel G. Pickup D.J. Nelson (1993) ArticleTitleThe interpretation of vegetation change in a spatially and temporally diverse Australian landscape J. Arid Environ. 24 241–260 Occurrence Handle10.1006/jare.1993.1022
S.D. Fuhlendorf F.E. Smiens (1998) ArticleTitleThe influence of soil depth on plant species response to grazing within a semi-arid savanna Plant Ecol. 138 89–96 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1009704723526
S.D. Fuhlendorf F.E. Smiens (1999) ArticleTitleScaling effects of grazing in a semi-arid savanna J. Veget. Sci. 10 731–738 Occurrence Handle10.2307/3237088
J.W. Green (1985) Census of Vascular Plants of Western Australia Department of Agriculture Western Australia Perth, Australia
R.B. Hacker (1984) ArticleTitleVegetation dynamics in a grazed mulga shrubland community. I the mid-storey shrubs Aust. J. Bot. 32 239–249 Occurrence Handle10.1071/BT9840239
R.B. Hacker (1987) ArticleTitleSpecies responses to grazing and environmental factors in an arid halophytic shrubland community Aust. J. Bot. 35 135–150 Occurrence Handle10.1071/BT9870135
A.M. Holm D.G. Burnside A.A. Mitchell (1987) ArticleTitleThe development of a system for monitoring trend in range condition in the arid shrublands of Western Australia Austr. Rangeland J. 9 14–20 Occurrence Handle10.1071/RJ9870014
A.W. Illius T.G. O’Connor (1999) ArticleTitleOn the relevance of non-equilibrium to arid and semi-arid grazing systems Ecol. Appl. 9 798–813
A.W. Illius T.G. O’Connor (2000) ArticleTitleResource heterogeneity and ungulate population dynamics Oikos 89 283–294 Occurrence Handle10.1034/j.1600-0706.2000.890209.x
L.C. King (1963) South African Scenery. A Textbook of Geomorphology EditionNumber3 Oliver and Boyd Ltd Edinburgh, UK
S.A. Levin (1992) ArticleTitleThe problem of pattern and scale in ecology Ecology 73 1943–1967 Occurrence Handle10.2307/1941447
J.A. Ludwig G.N. Bastin R.W. Eager R. Karfs P. Ketner G. Pearce (2000) ArticleTitleMonitoring Australian rangeland sites using landscape function indicators and ground and remote-based techniques Environ. Monit. Assess. 64 164–178 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1006475825546
J.A. Ludwig D.J. Tongway (1995) ArticleTitleDesertification in Australiaan eye to grass roots and landscapes Environ. Monit. Assess. 37 231–237 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00546891
S.R. Morton D.M. Stafford Smith M.H. Friedel G.F. Griffin G. Pickup (1995) ArticleTitleThe stewardship of arid Australia: ecology and landscape management J. Environ. Manage. 43 195–217 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0301-4797(95)90402-6
InstitutionalAuthorNameMurchison Land Conservation District Committee and the Ecosystem Management Unit (2002) The Murchison River Project: Pastoralists restoring health to the Murchison River catchment S. Nicolson D.G. Wilcox (Eds) Shifting Camp: Proceedings of the 12th Biennial Australian Rangeland Society Conference Australian Rangeland Society Perth Australia 312–313
A.O. Nicholls J.F. Wallace (2003) Appendix G: Principles for monitoring Biodiversity monitoring in the rangelands A. Smyth C. James G. Whiteman (Eds) A Way Forwardvol. 1 CSIRO Sustainable Ecosystems, Alice Springs Northern Territory, Australia 49–50
R.O. O’Neill D.L. DeAngelis J.B. Waide T.F.H. Allen (1986) A Hierarchical Concept of Ecosystems Princeton University Press Princeton, New Jersey, USA
S.T.A. Pickett J. Wu M.L. Cadenasso (1999) Patch dynamics and the ecology of disturbed ground L.R. Walker (Eds) Ecosystems of the World 16 Elsevier Amsterdam 707–722
G. Pickup (1985) ArticleTitleThe erosion cell – a geomorphic approach to landscape classification in range assessment Austr. Rangeland J. 7 114–121 Occurrence Handle10.1071/RJ9850114
G. Pickup (1989) ArticleTitleNew land degradation survey techniques for arid Australia - problems and prospects Austr. Rangeland J. 11 74–82 Occurrence Handle10.1071/RJ9890074
H.J.R. Pringle A.J.M. Hopkins (2004) Biodiversity monitoring or biodiversity management systems: which is the cart and which is the horse? G. Bastin D. Walsh S. Nicolson (Eds) Living in the Outback. Conference Papers of the Australian Rangeland Society 13th Biennial Conference Australian Rangeland Society Alice Springs July 2004 Australian Rangeland Society Australia 195–200
H.J.R. Pringle J. Landsberg (2004) ArticleTitlePredicting the distribution of livestock grazing pressure in rangelands Austral Ecol. 29 31–39 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1442-9993.2004.01363.x
H. Pringle K. Tinley (2001a) ArticleTitleEcological sustainability for pastoral management J. Agric. Western Austr. 42 30–35
H. Pringle K. Tinley (2001b) Landholders designing with nature: an approach to off-reserve conservation in the Gascoyne–Murchison Strategy area, Western Australia Kununurra Department of Agriculture Kununurra Western Australia 49–53
H.J.R. Pringle K.L. Tinley (2003) ArticleTitleAre we overlooking critical geomorphic determinants of landscape change in Australian rangelands? Ecol. Manage. Restor. 4 180–186 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1442-8903.2003.00154.x
H.J.R. Pringle K.L. Tinley T. Brandis A.J.M. Hopkins M. Lewis L. Taylor (2003) The Gascoyne–Murchison Strategy: A people-centred approach to conservation in arid Australia CD distributed by International Rangelands Congress Durban South Africa
J.R. Purvis (1986) ArticleTitleNurture the land: my philosophies of pastoral management in central Australia Austr. Rangeland J. 8 110–117 Occurrence Handle10.1071/RJ9860110
D.E. Ryerson R.R. Parmenter (2001) ArticleTitleVegetation change following removal of keystone herbivores from desert grasslands in New Mexico J. Veget. Sci. 12 167–180
A.K. Smyth C.D. James (2004) ArticleTitleCharacteristics of Australia’s rangelands and key design issues for monitoring biodiversity Austral Ecol. 29 3–15 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1442-9993.2004.01360.x
Tinley K.L. 1977. Framework of the Gorongoza ecosystem, Mozambique D.Sc. (Ecology) Thesis University of Pretoria, Pretoria South Africa, pp. 198
K.L. Tinley (1982) The influence of soil moisture balance on ecosystem patterns in southern Africa B.J. Huntley B.H. Walker (Eds) Ecological Studies, Volume 42: Ecology of Tropical Savannas Springer-Verlag New York, USA 175–192
K.L. Tinley (1987) Achieving a balance between long and short term research D.A. Saunders G.W. Saunders A.A. Burbidge A.J.M. Hopkins (Eds) Nature Conservation: The Role of Remnants of Native Vegetation Surrey Beatty and Sons Pty Ltd Sydney, NSW, Australia 347–350
K. Tinley (2001) Scrub encroachment of productive grasslands: soil moisture balance Kununurra, Department of Agriculture Kununurra, Western Australia 11–16
K.L. Tinley H.J.R. Pringle (2002) What is the EMU Exercise? S. Nicolson D.G. Wilcox (Eds) Shifting Camp Australian Rangeland Society Perth, Australia 349–350
D.J. Tongway N.L. Hindley (2004) Landscape function analysis manual Published on CD by CSIRO Sustainable Ecosystems Canberra Australia
I.W. Watson (1998) ArticleTitleMonitoring Western Australian shrublands; what are the expectations of change? Range Manage. Newslett. 1998 IssueID2 1–5
I.W. Watson M. Westoby A.McR. Holm (1997) ArticleTitleDemography of two shrub species from an arid grazed ecosystem in Western Australia, 1983–1993 J. Ecol. 85 815–832 Occurrence Handle10.2307/2960604
I. Watson P. Novelly (2004) ArticleTitleMaking the biodiversity monitoring system sustainable: design issues for large-scale monitoring systems Austral Ecol. 29 16–30 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1442-9993.2004.01350.x
I. Watson P. Thomas (2003) ArticleTitleMonitoring shows improvement in the Gascoyne–Murchison rangelands Range Manage. Newslett. 2003 IssueID1 11–14
D.G. Wilcox E.A. McKinnon (1972) A Report on the Condition of the Gascoyne Catchment, Western Australia Department of Agriculture, Western Australia Perth, Western Australia, Australia
J. Wu (1999) ArticleTitleHierachy and scaling: Extrapolating information along a scaling ladder Can. J. Remote Sensing 25 367–380
J. Wu J.L. David (2002) ArticleTitleA spatially explicit hierarchical approach to modeling complex ecological systems: theory and applications Ecol. Model. 153 7–26 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0304-3800(01)00499-9
J. Wu O.L. Loucks (1995) ArticleTitleFrom balance-of-nature to hierarchical patch dynamics: a paradigm shift in ecology Quart. Rev. Biol. 70 439–466 Occurrence Handle10.1086/419172
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pringle, H.J.R., Watson, I.W. & Tinley, K.L. Landscape improvement, or ongoing degradation – reconciling apparent contradictions from the arid rangelands of Western Australia. Landscape Ecol 21, 1267–1279 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10980-006-0015-x
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10980-006-0015-x