Engaging Earth- and Environmental-Science Undergraduates Through Weather Discussions and an eLearning Weather Forecasting Contest
- 448 Downloads
For students who major in meteorology, engaging in weather forecasting can motivate learning, develop critical-thinking skills, improve their written communication, and yield better forecasts. Whether such advances apply to students who are not meteorology majors has been less demonstrated. To test this idea, a weather discussion and an eLearning weather forecasting contest were devised for a meteorology course taken by third-year undergraduate earth- and environmental-science students. The discussion consisted of using the recent, present, and future weather to amplify the topics of the week’s lectures. Then, students forecasted the next day’s high temperature and the probability of precipitation for Woodford, the closest official observing site to Manchester, UK. The contest ran for 10 weeks, and the students received credit for participation. The top students at the end of the contest received bonus points on their final grade. A Web-based forecast contest application was developed to register the students, receive their forecasts, and calculate weekly standings. Students who were successful in the forecast contest were not necessarily those who achieved the highest scores on the tests, demonstrating that the contest was possibly testing different skills than traditional learning. Student evaluations indicate that the weather discussion and contest were reasonably successful in engaging students to learn about the weather outside of the classroom, synthesize their knowledge from the lectures, and improve their practical understanding of the weather. Therefore, students taking a meteorology class, but not majoring in meteorology, can derive academic benefits from weather discussions and forecast contests. Nevertheless, student evaluations also indicate that better integration of the lectures, weather discussions, and the forecasting contests is necessary.
KeywordsMeteorology Forecasting Education Contest Evaluation
We thank Prof. Dan Keyser of the State University of New York at Albany for the inspiration to hold a weather forecasting contest for non-meteorology majors, the students for their participation in the contest and their feedback, eLearning Manager Alison Hamilton for her support of this project, and the anonymous reviewer for prompt and constructive feedback that improved the manuscript.
- Bosart LF (1983) An update on trends in skill of daily forecasts of temperature and precipitation at the State University of New York at Albany. Bull Am Meteor Soc 64:346–354Google Scholar
- Constabile MF, De Marsico M, Lanzilotti R, Plantamura VL, Roselli T (2005) On the usability evaluation of e-Learning applications. In: Proceedings of 38th Hawaii international conference on system sciences, 3–6 January 2005, IEEE, pp 1–10Google Scholar
- Decker SG (2012) Experiences with a probabilistic forecasting game for meteorology students. Preprints, 21st symposium on education, New Orleans, LA, Am Meteor Soc 3.4Google Scholar
- Gedzelman SD (1978) Forecasting skill of beginners. Bull Am Meteor Soc 59:1305–1309Google Scholar
- Hilliker J (2008) Assessment of a weather forecasting contest in multi-leveled meteorology classes. J Geoscience Educ 56(2):160–165Google Scholar
- Sanders F (1986) Trends in skill of Boston forecasts made at MIT, 1966–84. Bull Am Meteor Soc 67:170–176Google Scholar
- Seuss EJ, Cervato C, Gallus WA, Jr, Hobbs J (2011) Weather forecasting as a learning tool in a large service course: does practice make perfect? Preprints, 20th symposium on education, American Meteorological Society, 6 pp. Available online at http://ams.confex.com/ams/91Annual/webprogram/Manuscript/Paper179788/Suess et al. 2010 extended abstract.pdf