Abstract
Obtaining accurate estimates of remanent creep life is of great importance to the power generating industry. The small punch creep test promises to be a useful way forward in this respect. However, a major concern with the test revolves around the ability to convert small punch test data into the required uniaxial equivalents. Experimental results within the literature have given contradictory results partly due to the large experimental scatter inherent within the test and so this article reports some results from a recently developed stochastic finite element model of the small creep punch test that provides guidance on this matter. The uniqueness of the model is based on its realistic creep deformations laws, including strain hardening, thermal softening and damage accumulation that enables it to produce life predictions for virgin material as well as for material with pre existing damage. It is shown that the model produces excellent life predictions for virgin 0.5Cr–0.5Mo–0.25V steel and for damaged 1.25Cr–1Mo steel over a wide range of test conditions. The model also predicts that the dependency of the time to failure on minimum displacement rates is such that small punch test data can be converted into uniaxial data using relatively simple analytical expressions.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- \(\dot {\xi}_{ij}\) :
-
Strain rate tensor
- ɛt :
-
Total creep strain at time t (%/100)
- ɛf :
-
Elongation at failure (%/100)
- ɛmin :
-
Minimum creep rate (s−1) from uniaxial tests
- ɛd,min :
-
Minimum displacement rate (mm(s−1)) from small punch test
- θj :
-
Theta parameter used to describe a creep curve (j = 1, 4)
- Θi :
-
Natural log of θj
- \(\bar{\Uptheta}_j\) :
-
Mean value for Θj
- \(\hat{\Uptheta}_{i,j}\) :
-
Randomly generated value for Θj
- \(\hat{\theta}_j\) :
-
Randomly generated value for θj
- \(\bar{\tau}\) :
-
Local Von Mises flow stress
- \(\tau_{ij}\) :
-
Cauchy stress tensor
- \({\tau}_{ij}^{\prime}\) :
-
Deviatoric stress
- τm :
-
Mean stress
- γj :
-
Variance of θj
- ρj :
-
Mean variance of Θj
- σ*:
-
Normalised stress
- σ:
-
Stress (MPa)
- a j,0, b j,0, c j,0, d j,0 :
-
Parameters of the theta interpolation/extrapolation function in the deterministic model
- a j,k, b j,k, c j,k, d j,k :
-
Parameters of the theta interpolation/extrapolation function for the kth run of the stochastic model
- a, b, c, d :
-
Parameters of the failure strain interpolation/extrapolation function in the deterministic model
- d :
-
Punch head displacement (mm)
- m k, f k :
-
Parameters of the critical damage interpolation/extrapolation function for the kth run of the punch test model
- r, z :
-
Disc point coordinates
- T :
-
Temperature (K)
- t f :
-
Time at failure
- U :
-
A randomly drawn number between 0 and 1
- Φ(U)−1 :
-
A standard normal variate
- u i :
-
Velocity field
- V :
-
Velocity
- W crit :
-
Continuum damage at failure (dimensionless)
- x 1 :
-
Punch hole diameter (mm)
- x 2 :
-
Disc diameter (mm)
- x 3 :
-
Disc thickness (mm)
- x 4 :
-
Punch head radius (mm)
- x 5 :
-
Friction coefficient (0 ≤ x 5 ≤ 1)
- x 6 :
-
Preexisting damage (dimensionless)
- x 7 :
-
Load (N)
References
Manahan MP, Argon AS, Harling OK (1981) J Nucl Mater 103–104:1545. North-Holland Publishing Company
Mao X, Takahashi H (1987) J Nucl Mater 150:42. North-Holland
Takahashi H, Shoji T, Mao X, Hamaguchi Y, Misawa T, Saito M, Oku T, Kodaira T, Fukaya K, Nishi H, Suzuki M (1988) Recommended practice for small punch (SP) testing of matallic materials. JAERI-M 88-172, Sept
Foulds JR, Jewitt CW, Bisbee LH, Whicker GA, Viswanathan R (1992) Miniature sample removal and small punch testing for in-service component FATT. Proceedings, Robert I. Jaffee memorial symposium on clean materials technology ASM, pp 101–109
Parker JD, Stratford GC, Shaw N, Spink G, Tate E (1995) Deformation and fracture processes in miniature disc tests of CrMoV rotor steel. Proceedings, third international Charles Parsons turbine conference, vol 2. Institute of Materials, pp 418–428
Bicego V, Lucon E, Crudeli R (1995) Integrated technologies for life assessment of primary power plant components. In: Bicego, Nitta, Viswanathan (eds) Proceedings of int. symp. on materials ageing and component life extension, vol I. EMAS, pp 295–305
Bulloch JH, Fairman A (1995) Some considerations regarding the small punch testing of important engineering components. In: Hietanen, Auerkari (eds) Proceedings of int. conf. Baltica III, Helsinki, Stockholm, 6–8 June 1995, pp 179–193
CEN Workshop Business Plan (2004) Small punch test method for metallic materials. CEN, Brussels, Belgium, Sept 2004
Bicego V, Rantala H, Klaput J, Stratford GC, Persio F, Hurst RC (2004) The small punch test method: results from a European creep testing round robin. Proceedings, EPRI conference on life assessment, Hilton Head Island
CEN Workshop Agreement (2006) CWA 15627:2006 E, Small punch test method for metallic materials. CEN, Brussels, Belgium, Dec 2006
Evans RW, Evans M (2006) J Mater Sci Technol 22(10):1155
Evans M, Wang D (2007) Mater Sci Technol 23:883
Evans RW (2000) Proc R Soc Lond A 456:835
Hankin GL, Toloczko MB, Johnson KI, Khaleel MA, Hamilton ML, Garner FA, Davies RW, Faulkner RG. An investigation into the origin and nature of the slope and the x-axis intercept of the shear punch-tensile yield strength correlation using finite element analysis. In: Hamilton ML et al (eds) Effect of Irradiation on material, 19th international symposium. ASTM 1366, p 1018
Evans M, Wang D (2007) J Strain Anal Eng Des 5:389
Stratford GC, Di Persio F, Klaput J (2005) Miniaturised creep testing using the small punch test technique. In: 11th international conference on fracture, Turin, Mar, p 4175
Aide Memoire (2006) Miniaturised testing: micro structural evaluation and residual lifetimes. In: The special interest group meeting. National Physical Laboratory, Teddington, 14 Feb 2006
Evans RW, Beden I, Wilshire B (1984) Creep life prediction for 0.5Cr 0.5 Mo 0.25 V ferretic steel. In: Wilshire B, Owen DRJ (eds) 2nd international conference on creep and fracture of engineering materials and structures. Pineridge Press, Swansea, p 1277
Stratford GC (1994) Type IV cracking in 1 1/4Cr-0.5Mo low alloy steel welds. Ph.D. thesis, University of Wales, Swansea
Evans RW, Wilshire B (1996) Constitutive laws for high temperature creep and fracture. In: Krausz AS, Krausz K (eds) Unified laws of plastic deformation. Academic Press, London, pp 107–152
Evans RW, Wilshire B (1993) An introduction to creep, 2nd edn. Institute of Materials, London
Evans RW (1989) Mater Sci Technol 5:699
Evans M, Wang D (2007) Mater Sci Technol 23(8):883
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Evans, M., Wang, D. The small punch creep test: some results from a numerical model. J Mater Sci 43, 1825–1835 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10853-007-2388-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10853-007-2388-x