Journal of Bioeconomics

, 9:245 | Cite as

Improving Human Wellbeing and Ecosystem Health on BC’s Coast: The Challenge Posed by Historic Resource Extraction

  • Tom L. Green


Haida Gwaii and the Great Bear Rainforest (GBR) comprise the world’s largest intact coastal temperate rainforest. British Columbia has encouraged industrial logging of this region. As a result, ecological values have been eroded and natural capital has been drawn down. The logging industry has provided few local economic benefits. Colonization and industrial resource extraction have contributed to high levels of social distress in First Nations communities. Since 2001, logging companies, environmental organizations, and the provincial and First Nations governments have collaborated in developing an Ecosystem Based Management (EBM) approach. EBM is intended to maintain ecosystem integrity and improve human wellbeing. In 2006, the province began implementing EBM by setting aside one third of the GBR’s land base from logging and by proposing transitional EBM requirements. This paper draws on stumpage and forest cover data to analyze natural capital depletion. The analysis indicates that much of the GBR’s natural capital, as represented by timber, has been depleted. Industrial logging was already on the decline before the decision was taken to implement an EBM approach. Expectations for improved socio-economic outcomes under EBM may not be realistic given the constraints implied by past logging. If EBM performance is measured using conventional economic indicators without accounting for past depletion, it risks being found to have failed the goal of improving human wellbeing. This would create pressure to relax EBM provisions to allow more logging, an outcome that would fail both ecosystems and human communities in the long term. If much reduced extraction levels are to support local human wellbeing, a greater share of economic benefits must be retained locally.


old growth forests natural capital depletion ecosystem based management 

JEL Classification

Q23 Q24 Q57 Q58 

References cited

  1. Christensen Norman L., Ann M. Bartuska, James H. Brown, Stephen Carpenter, Carla D’Antonio, Rober Francis, Jerry F. Franklin, James A. MacMahon, Reed F. Noss, David J. Parsons, Charles H. Peterson, Monica G. Turner, Robert G. Woodmansee (1996). The report of the Ecological Society of America on the scientific basis for ecosystem management. Ecological Applications 6(3):665–691CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Clark Colin. W. (1975). Mathematical bioeconomics: the optimal management of renewable resources. John Wiley and Sons, TorontoGoogle Scholar
  3. Clapp Roger (1998). The resource cycle in forestry and fishing. The Canadian Geographer 42(2): 129–144CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Coast Information Team. 2004. Ecosystem-based Management Planning Handbook. [online] URL:
  5. Cortex Consultants & HiMark Forest Consultants. 2004. Second-growth timber opportunities on Haida Gwaii/QCI. Prepared for the British Columbia Ministry of Sustainable Resource Management. [online] URL:
  6. Costanza Robert, Herman E Daly (1992). Natural capital and sustainable development. Conservation Biology 6:37–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Daly Herman E., John Cobb (1989). For the common good: redirecting the economy towards community, the environment, and a sustainable future. Beacon Press, BostonGoogle Scholar
  8. Daly Herman E. (2005). Economics in a full world. Scientific American 293(3):100–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. El Serafy, Salah. 1989. The proper calculation of income from depletable natural resources. Pp. 10–18 in Y. Ahmad, S. El Serafy & E. Lutz (ed.) Environmental Accounting for Sustainable Development. The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, Washington DC.Google Scholar
  10. Green Thomas (2000). Confusing liquidation with income in British Columbia’s forests. Ecological Economics 34:33–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Green, Tom. 2002. Accounting for old forests: a methodology for assessing the economic benefits of retaining old forests in B.C. British Columbia Ministry of Water, Land and Air Protection. Victoria.Google Scholar
  12. Grumbine R. Edward (1997). Reflections on ‘what is ecosystem management?’. Conservation Biology 11:41–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Heliwell John (2003). How’s life? Combining individual and national variables to explain subjective well-being. Economics of Modelling 20(2):331–360CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Holman, Gary, Eliot Terry & Ministry of Competition, Science and Enterprise. 2001. Central coast land and coastal resource management plan phase 1 framework agreement—socio-economic and environmental assessment: final report. [online] URL:
  15. Holt, Rachel F. & Glenn Sutherland. 2004. Central coast coarse filter ecosystem trends risk assessment – base case. Coast Information Team. [online] URL:
  16. Holt, Rachel. 2006. Haida Gwaii/QCI land use viewpoints: ecological risk assessment. Prepared for the integrated land management bureau. [online] URL:
  17. Iverson David C., Richard M Alston (1993). Ecosystem-based forestry requires a broader economic focus. Journal of Sustainable Forestry 1(2):97–106CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Kant Shashi (2003). Extending the boundaries of forest economics. Forest Policy and Economics 5:39–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Kozak, Robert & Thomas C. Maness. 2005. Towards a value focused forest sector in British Columbia. Issue brief 05-01. BC forum on forest economics and policy, Vancouver.Google Scholar
  20. Kozak Robert A., Thomas C. Maness, Tim Caldecott (2003). Solid wood supply impediments for secondary wood producers in British Columbia. The Forestry Chronicle 79(6):1107–1120Google Scholar
  21. Ludwig Donald, Ray Hilbourn, Carl Walters (1993). Uncertainty, resource exploitation, and conservation: lessons from history. Science 260:17–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Maness Thomas. C., Ross Farrell (2004). A multi-objective scenario evaluation model for sustainable forest management using criteria and indicators. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 34:2002–2017CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. M’Gonigle Michael (1997). Behind the green curtain. Alternatives 23(4):16–21Google Scholar
  24. Prescott-Allen, Robert. 2005. Coast Information Team Review Report. [online] URL:
  25. Power, Thomas M. 1996. Lost landscapes and failed economies: the search for an economics of place. Island Press, Washington DC.Google Scholar
  26. Rumsey, Chuck, Jeff Ardron, Kristine Ciruna, Tim Curtis, Zach Ferdaña, Tony Hamilton, Kim Heinemeyer, Pierre Iachetti, Richard Jeo, Gary Kaiser, Debbie Narver, Reed Noss, Dennis Sizemore, Art Tautz, Rick Tingey & Ken Vance-Borland, 2004. An ecosystem spatial analysis for Haida Gwaii, central coast, and north coast British olumbia. Coast Information Team, Victoria BC. [online] URL:
  27. Slocombe D. Scott (1993). Implementing ecosystem-based management. Bioscience 43:612–622CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Swanson Fredrick J., Jerry Franklin (1992). New forestry principles from ecosystem analysis of Pacific Northwest forests. Ecological Applications 2:262–274CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Utzig, Greg & Colin Rankin. 2000. Environmental risk assessment (ERA): an approach for assessing and reporting environmental concerns. Habitat Branch of the Ministry of Environment, Lands and Parks, Government of British Columbia.Google Scholar
  30. Victor Peter A. (1991). Indicators of sustainable development: some lessons from capital theory. Ecological Economics 4:191–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Walter Gerald R. (2002). Economics, ecology-based communities, and sustainability. Ecological Economics 42:81–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Waring Marilyn (1988). If women counted. Macmillan, LondonGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC. 2007

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.VancouverCanada

Personalised recommendations