Influence of post-thaw culture on the developmental potential of human frozen embryos
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Rato, M.L., Gouveia-Oliveira, A. & Plancha, C.E. J Assist Reprod Genet (2012) 29: 789. doi:10.1007/s10815-012-9793-z
Apart from freezing/thawing related cryodamage, several additional factors have been identified as major players in the reduction of success rates after frozen embryo transfers. The post-thaw culture is particularly relevant as it may amplify environmental influences over a stressed embryo. In the present study the influence of the post-thaw culture duration on the implantation and developmental potential of cleavage stage embryos was evaluated.
In this retrospective evaluation, that spanned an 8-year period, 631 frozen-thawed embryos were allocated to one of two study groups, depending on their post-thaw culture period: 1) the long (18–24 h), or 2) the short (2–5 h) culture group. Groups were compared regarding implantation rate and live birth rate per embryo transferred. This comparison was corrected for the most common confounding factors such as maternal age at oocyte pick-up, number of transferred embryos, developmental day at freezing, blastomere survival after thawing, catheter used for transfer and year of procedure.
Implantation and live birth rate per embryo transferred were inversely related to the duration of the post-thaw culture, as diminishing this period significantly increased both rates. Moreover, no advantage could be found for a long post-thaw culture period, even for embryos with observed mitotic activity.
This retrospective analysis indicates that a short post-thaw culture period is associated with higher implantation and live birth rates per embryo. This study supports selection of frozen-thawed embryos strictly based on blastomere cryosurvival and raises the hypothesis that environmental factors may have an important role on embryo implantation and developmental potential during post-thaw culture.
KeywordsEmbryo cryopreservation Blastomere proliferation Culture environment Implantation rate Developmental competence
Currently, the two most common procedures to select embryos for frozen embryo transfer (FET) differ in the duration of the post-thaw culture: one relies upon the observation of blastomere proliferation, requiring a longer culture, generally overnight; the other relies upon the observation of blastomere survival after thawing, requiring a shorter culture. The effectiveness of one strategy over another is still not clear as few studies have compared large series of embryos over a long time period. Additionally, all published results are influenced by biasing factors relating to the population demographics and to events described as modulators of FET outcome [2, 5, 6, 14, 18, 20, 22].
Although FET is generally considered a well established technique, a large number of studies concentrate on the reasons for its lower success rate when compared to fresh embryo transfers [1, 2]. Major contributors to such divergence have been extensively discussed and, as an attempt to elevate frozen embryo transfer (FET) outcome, the post-thaw assessment of mitotic resumption became a widely employed strategy for embryo grading and selection [5, 6, 14, 18, 20, 22]. As a consequence, the specific effect of post-thaw culture duration has remained neglected by most FET studies. In our centre, until 2005, post-thaw embryo selection was preferentially based on mitotic resumption. However, FETs were most frequently non-elective and embryos surviving the thawing process were generally the same embryos selected for transfer the following day, irrespective of subsequent mitotic resumption. Interestingly, after an internal evaluation of our FET program, a tendency towards a better outcome following transfer of embryos thawed on the same day as transfer was identified. In light of such observation, thawing began to preferentially be performed on the same day as transfer and embryo post-thaw selection based on mitotic activity was no longer a priority.
The current understanding that available embryo culture systems, although aiming to mimic the physiological environment, do not replace it completely , supported the modification of our post-thaw culture protocol. It additionally raised the hypothesis that frozen-thawed embryos may be particularly sensible to sub-optimal environmental influences during post-thaw culture, possibly interfering with potential to implant and development to a live birth. In order to explore the specific effect of post-thaw culture duration upon implantation and live birth rates, we conducted a retrospective evaluation spanning an 8-year period. Specifically, we compared the influence of two distinct post-thaw culture lengths, 2–5 h versus 18–24 h, on embryo implantation and full term developmental potential using a statistical approach designed to control for the influence of common biasing factors.
Materials and methods
Embryo inclusion and study period
This retrospective study evaluated all frozen-thawed embryos derived from FET cycles initiated at Centro Médico de Assistência à Reprodução (CEMEARE) in Lisbon, Portugal, during an 8-year period. FETs included in this study resulted from the cryopreservation of supernumerary embryos generated in the course of IVF/ICSI cycles. Irrespective of the number of FET cycles derived from each ovarian pick-up (OPU), only embryos derived from the first FET were eligible for the study. Only viable embryos were considered—defined as having retained ≥50 % of their initial number of blastomeres intact upon thawing.
Concerning the time span of the study, two main periods reflecting two different post-thaw methodologies were traversed. The first period extended mainly from May 2001 to June 2005 and coincided with the established tendency to perform an overnight post-thaw culture and select embryos for transfer based on their mitotic activity. The second period extended mainly from July 2005 to December 2008 and significantly represented our new tendency to reduce the culture period between thaw and transfer, relying only on post-thaw survival for embryo selection.
Patients undergoing IVF/ICSI cycles were subjected to controlled ovarian stimulation using a GnRH agonist (Decapetyl, Ipsen Pharma Biotech, Signes, France) or antagonist (Orgalutran, Organon/Schering-Plough, UK; or Cetrotide, Serono, London, UK) for hypolalamic down-regulation; human menopausal (Menopur, Ferring GmbH, Kiel, Germany) or recombinant FSH (Gonal-F, Serono, UK; or Puregon, Organon/Schering-Plough, UK) for ovarian stimulation; and hCG (Pregnyl, Organon/Schering-Plough, Oss, Holand; or Ovitrelle, Serono, London, UK) for induction of oocyte maturation. After ovarian puncture COCs were incubated in IVF medium (all culture media from MediCult/Origio, Jyllinge, Denmark). Zygotes and day 2 embryos were cultured in ISM1 medium and transferred to ISM2 medium at day 3. Cleaving embryos were scored every day for blastomere number, cleavage plane and degree of fragmentation and graded accordingly. Higher grade embryos were selected for fresh embryo transfer. Surplus embryos presenting an adequate relation between blastomere number and developmental day, a correct cleavage plan and a maximum of 20 % fragmentation were cryopreserved.
Cleavage stage embryo slow freezing and rapid thawing
The freezing-thawing procedures and media remained unchanged during the complete study period. According to the slow freezing protocol, embryos were sequentially equilibrated at room temperature in a HEPES-buffered medium containing cryoprotectants up to a final concentration of 1.5 M 1,2-propanediol (PROH) and 0.1 M sucrose (Medicult/Origio embryo freezing pack). Embryos were loaded into ministraws (CryoBioSystems, France) and cooled using a programmable freezer (MiniCool, AirLiquid, France). The cooling program started at 20°C and ran as follows: temperature was taken to −7°C at a rate of 2°C/min and manual seeding was performed by touching the extremes of the straw with a nitrogen-cooled forceps. From that point on, the temperature was slowly decreased at 0.3°C/min to −30°C. A final and very fast drop to −150°C was accomplished decreasing the temperature at a rate of 50°C/min. Straws were then plunged into liquid nitrogen and stored until thawing.
Rapid thawing was achieved by quickly placing the straws on hand for a minimum of 30 s. Embryos were then discharged to a 4-well dish and washed from the cryoprotectants at room temperature, using sequential thawing media (Medicult/Origio embryo thawing pack). According to their developmental day upon freezing, embryos were placed in appropriate medium, checked for blastomere survival under an inverted microscope and incubated until transfer. Long post-thaw incubation consisted of an overnight culture for an 18–24 h period before transfer. Short post-thaw incubation consisted of a culture for a 2–5 h period before transfer.
Uterine transfer of frozen-thawed embryos
Embryo replacement to the uterus was performed following endometrium preparation using Leucoprolide (Decapetyl depot 0,1 mg/ml, Ipsen Pharma Biotech, Signes, France)—a GnRH agonist, for hypothalamic suppression and 17β-estradiol (Estrophem, Novo NordisK, Novo Allé, Denmark) in order to mimic the natural occurring estrogens until the endometrium reached 8 mm thick and the serum estradiol levels reached ≥150 mg/dl. From this stage on, progesterone (Utrogestan, Jaba Recordati, Sintra, Portugal) was added to the previous therapeutic scheme for endometrium support and embryo transfer was scheduled
Clinical pregnancy was defined by the presence of a gestational sac with a fetal heartbeat on ultrasound examination at 6 weeks of gestation.
The primary efficacy endpoints were the implantation rate (IR—the number of gestational sacs per number of embryos transferred) and the live birth rate per embryo (LBR/E—the number of newborns per number of embryos transferred). Secondary efficacy endpoints were pregnancy, multiple pregnancy, gestational sac involution and delivery rates. In addition, we looked into the relevance of observing mitotic activity to implantation rate and the live birth rate per embryo.
Differences between groups were tested with multiple linear regression for interval-measured endpoints and logistic regression for binary endpoints. Whenever endpoints referred to episodes, analyses were clustered by subject and robust “Sandwich” (Huber-White) standard errors were used to account for non-independence within subjects. In order to control for systematic differences between groups, all analyses were adjusted for the following potential confounding factors: maternal age at OPU, number of embryos transferred, day of embryonic development at freezing, blastomere cryosurvival after thawing, catheter used for transfer and procedure year. All tests are two-tailed. Results are reported as adjusted odds-ratios (AOR) with 95 % confidence intervals (95 % CI). Differences were considered significant if p < 0.05. Statistical analysis was performed using STATA 11 (Stata Corporation, College Station, Texas). Whenever appropriate, writing and analysis followed the STROBE .
Demographic, clinical and embryological characteristics of FETs in the two different post-thaw culture groups
Short culture group (2–5 h)
Long culture group (18–24 h)
Maternal age at OPU, mean (SD)
Developmental day at freezing, n (%)
Post-thaw surviving embryos, %
No. Transferred embryos, mean (SD)
Catheter used for transfer, n (%)
Year of procedure, n (%)
Outcome of FETs following distinct post-thaw culture periods in the short to the long culture group
95 % CI
Live birth rate per embryo
Multiple pregnancy rate
Gestational sac involution rate
Relevance of observing mitotic activity. Comparison of the outcomes of embryos transferred after observed mitotic resumption in the long culture group (n = 61) to embryos without mitotic activity in the short and in the long culture groups
95 % CI
Short culture (n = 455)
Live birth rate per embryo
Long culture (n = 29)
Live birth rate per embryo
The results of this retrospective study indicate that a short post-thaw culture period is associated with higher implantation and live birth rate per embryo. To our knowledge, this is the first study to identify a long post-thaw culture period as being responsible for loss of embryo implantation and developmental potential. Additionally, this study reinforces the advantages of a frozen-thawed embryo selection approach strictly based on blastomere cryosurvival [3, 19].
The observed differences between study groups rely on a strong statistical plan and are independent of common biasing factors
Although the conclusions from this study are based on retrospective data and have the inherent limitations of retrospective studies, there are strengths in its design that afford strong confidence on the results. First, the study was based on a large sample of transferred embryos spanning a period of 8 years. Second, the quality of data is high, without missing data or a single case lost to follow up. Third, to overcome the lack of randomization between groups, the analysis accounted for a number of possible confounding factors of FET outcomes such as maternal age at OPU, number of embryos transferred, day of embryonic development at freezing, blastomere cryosurvival after thawing, catheter used for transfer and year of procedure. The latter two variables are often neglected but importantly reflect increasing operator (embryologist and clinician) experience and the continuous improvement of equipments and devices, such as embryo transfer catheters. Particularly, adjusting the analysis for the year of procedure was essential as the superiority of one culture duration (long or short), could be biased by the preferential association with a time period (from 2001 to 2004 and from 2005 to 2008). In addition, the analysis accounted for the clustering of episodes (transfers) within subjects (couples) and adjusted standard errors for possible non-independence of episodes within subjects. Therefore, conclusions arising from this work are adequately supported by the statistical analysis plan. Finally, although pregnancy and live birth rates are commonly used outcomes, the first is still an intermediate measure and does not discriminate between implantation of one or more embryos, while the second returns a result in terms of oocyte pick-up or embryo transfer procedures and not in relation to each transferred embryo. As this study aims to center on individual embryo developmental potential following two different post-thaw culture durations and not on live birth per woman, implantation rate and live birth rate per embryo were considered to be more accurate and informative outcome measures. In fact, more important than the actual, unadjusted, values observed for implantation and live birth rate per embryo represented in Fig. 2 are the adjusted differences between groups (Fig. 3), which estimate the independent effect of distinct post-thaw culture periods after controlling for six potential confounding factors.
Shorter post-thaw culture periods allow embryos to maintain higher implantation and developmental potential
Our results indicate that the probability of frozen-thawed embryos to implant and develop to term is significantly increased if embryos are only briefly cultured after thawing. This observation highlights the environmental impact that post-thaw culture length has on embryo developmental potential. Negative influences of culture upon embryo development have been pointed out and, although embryo culture aims to mimic the fallopian tube and uterine environment, it always implies induction of some related stress [8, 9, 10, 17]. It thus seems reasonable to propose that frozen-thawed embryos may be less able to cope with, and adapt to, sub-optimal environments such as the currently available culture systems . By reducing the post-thaw culture duration, there will be a decrease of culture-related stress, better preserving embryonic developmental potential.
As previously reported, many factors have been pointed out as influencing post-thaw outcome, but their relative contributions are variably accepted . When comparing ART outcomes, maternal age at OPU and number of embryos transferred are usually accepted as the two most important causes of bias in intra- and inter-assay comparisons. At freezing, the two most referred embryological factors are embryo grading [2, 7] and embryo developmental day [13, 15], while after thawing, the two most discussed embryological factors are blastomere cryosurvival [5, 19] and the visualization of blastomere mitotic resumption [20, 22]. In the light of the present study, we suggest that “post-thaw culture duration” should be considered as another confounding factor, strongly influencing developmental potential and consequently FET outcome.
Is it useful to prolong culture after thawing in order to observe initial blastomere proliferation?
Although some previous reports seemed to demonstrate that post-thawed cleaving embryos with observed blastomere proliferation hold a higher developmental potential than non-cleaved ones [14, 20, 22], we found no evidence of increased implantation and live birth rates per embryo after transferring only embryos where blastomere proliferation had been observed after a long post-thaw culture. These results contrast with others reported for the same type of transfers, possibly due to the statistical analysis or to the non-elective approach of our FETs  and to the marked influence of common biasing factors, such as age and number of embryos transferred, in the most recently reported data . Finally, the negative influence that a prolonged post-thaw culture exerts on embryonic developmental potential reinforces the concept that the inability to develop in vitro is no evidence of developmental incompetence in vivo [4, 12]. Our results are in favor of such concept, as the outcome of post-thaw cleaved embryos and those selected based only upon survival is similar. This indicates that the developmental potential of non-cleaving embryos could be better preserved if they would only be briefly exposed to post-thaw in vitro conditions.
Final considerations and conclusion
We all agree that the best outcome achieved after embryo cryopreservation will result from embryos with a high score before freezing, that not only retain their initial blastomere number, but above all retain their developmental competence and that must end up resuming mitotic activity in the uterine cavity. Our results suggest that a prolonged post-thaw culture period can be causing a decrease in the implantation and developmental potential of thawed cleavage stage embryos. The present study raises the interesting proposal that it may not be desirable to actually see the resumption of mitotic activity in some blastomeres of thawed embryos, because that usually requires a long post-thaw culture period. This hypothesis now demands further validation through prospective randomized studies.
Conflict of interests
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.