Marine reserves: the need for systems
Highly protected marine reserves are areas of the sea in which human disturbances are minimised so that the full natural biological diversity is maintained or, more often, allowed to recover to a more natural state. Europe has very few marine reserves; they are very small and almost all are in the Mediterranean. There are at present no official plans to create effective systems of marine reserves. Europe has many so-called Marine Protected Areas (MPAs). These are marine areas with some extra regulations or planning procedures. MPAs aim to make human activities more efficient and more sustainable. MPAs are user-orientated, knowledge-based, locality-dependent, problem-solving extensions of standard marine planning and management. Marine reserves are quite different. All extractive and potentially disturbing human activities are prohibited. The burden of proof is reversed; no evidence of damage or danger to particular species or habitats is required; all marine life is protected on principle. The concept of marine reserves is simple and practical, but because it is new, different and additional to existing marine management, the idea is seen by many as revolutionary. Basic biological principles and practical experience in many countries make it clear that marine reserves are important to science and education, essential for conservation and useful in resource management. These features apply in all regions and ecosystems. They are independent of climate, biogeography, current human activities and the present management. Representative and viable systems of marine reserves are needed in all regions. Fishing and other human disturbances have been widespread and intensive for so long that it is very difficult to predict the stages of recovery that occur in marine reserves. Furthermore, while some features change rapidly (e.g. numbers of previously targeted species), recovery continues for a long time (e.g. fourth- and fifth-order trophic and structural changes after >25 years). None of this alters the fact that, in scientific terms, marine reserves are controls not manipulations. Such controls are required if scientists are to understand the intrinsic processes and obtain data that are not confounded by human activities (e.g. separating natural variation from fishing effects). No significant progress will be made to establish marine reserves in Europe until scientists speak out strongly and clearly on the issue. We consider it is part of our professional duty as marine biologists to state publicly and frequently the need for a representative, replicated, networked and sustainable system of highly protected marine reserves. We doubt if our grandchildren will accept any excuses if we fail.
KeywordsMarine reserves Systems Scientific benefits Professional duty
This review covers more than 30 years of investigations by a large number of workers. We wish to thank them all—especially (in alphabetical order) Tony Ayling, Russ Babcock, Chris Battershill, Howard Choat, Bob Creese, Chris Denny, Debbie Freeman, Roger Grace, Dennis Gordon, Tim Haggitt, Geoff Jones, Shane Kelly, Vince Kerr, Mike Kingsford, Allie MacDiarmid, John Morton, Darren Parsons, Emma Rushcombe, Nick Shears, Sue Thompson, Natalie Usmar, Jarrod Walker, Kathy Walls, John Walsby, Kim Westerskov and Trevor Willis.
- Ayling, A. M., A. Cumming & W. J. Ballantine, 1981. Map of Shore and Sub-tidal Habitats of Cape Rodney to Okakari Point Marine Reserve, North Island, New Zealand in 3 Sheets, Scale 1: 2000. Department of Lands and Survey, Wellington.Google Scholar
- Babcock, R. C., 2003. The New Zealand marine reserve experience: the science behind the politics. In Hutchings. P. & S. D. Lunney (eds) Conserving Marine Environments: Out of Sight, out of mind. Royal Zoological Society of New South Wales, Mossman: 105–119.Google Scholar
- Ballantine, W. J. (ed.), 1982. Sea Surface Temperatures. Leigh Laboratory Bulletin No 5. University of Auckland: 43 pp.Google Scholar
- Ballantine, W. J., 1993. Marine reserves for New Zealand. Leigh Marine Laboratory, University of Auckland. 20 minute video.Google Scholar
- Ballantine, W. J., 1999. Marine reserves in New Zealand: The development of the concept and the principles. Proceedings of an International Workshop on Marine Conservation for the New Millenium. Korean Ocean Research and Development Institute, Cheju Island, Korea: 3–38 [available at www.marine-reserves.org.nz].
- Ballantine, W. J., 2001. Marine Reserves. Paper presented to the first meeting of UN experts on marine biodiversity (AHTEG). 10 pp [available at www.marine-reserves.org.nz].
- Ballantine, W. J., 2003a. Scientific principles for marine reserve systems. MPA News 4(9): 5.Google Scholar
- Ballantine, W. J., 2003b. Practical action with marine reserve systems. MPA News 4(10): 5.Google Scholar
- CBD (Convention on Biological Diversity), 2004. Technical advice on the establishment and management of a national system of marine and coastal protected areas. Secretariat of the Convention of Biological Diversity. CBD Technical series 13: 40 pp.Google Scholar
- Defra, 2006. A Marine Bill: A Consultation Document. Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London: 309 pp.Google Scholar
- Enderby, J. & T. Enderby, 2006. A guide to New Zealand’s marine reserves. New Holland Publishers, Auckland: 176 pp.Google Scholar
- Ludwig, D., R. Hilbron & C. Walters, 1993. Uncertainty, resource exploitation and conservation: lessons from history. Science 260: 17, 35.Google Scholar
- Rhodes, L. L., A. J. Haywood, W. J. Ballantine & A. L. MacKenzie, 1993. Algal blooms and climate anomalies in north-east New Zealand August-December 1992. New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 27: 419–430.Google Scholar
- Roberts, C. M. & J. P. Hawkins, 2000. Fully Protected Marine Reserves: A Guide. WWF Endangered Sea Campaign, Washington D.C.Google Scholar
- Sobel, J. & C. Dahlgren, 2004. Marine Reserves: A guide to Science, Design and Use. Island Press, Washington D.C.: 383 pp.Google Scholar
- Thompson, S., 1981. Fish of the Marine Reserve: A Guide to the Identification and Biology of the Common Coastal Fish of North-eastern New Zealand. Leigh Laboratory Bulletin No 3. University of Auckland.Google Scholar
- Walsby, J. R., 2001. Cape Rodney—Okakari Point Marine Reserve: The Underwater World. A3 pamphlet. Department of Conservation, Auckland.Google Scholar
- Walsby, J. R., 2003. Marine Reserves Education Kit, 3rd edn. Department of Conservation, Auckland: 158 pp.Google Scholar
- Warne, K., 2006. Poor Knights—rich seas. New Zealand Geographic 78: 52–75.Google Scholar
- Whitley, J. & W. J. Ballantine, 1995. Marine Reserves: An Education Resource Kit. Leigh Marine Laboratory, University of Auckland: 86 pp.Google Scholar
- Willis, T. J., R. B. Millar & R. C. Babcock, 2003. Protection of exploited fish in temperate regions. Journal of Applied Ecology 40: 214–227.Google Scholar