Abstract
The form and function(s) of doctoral education continue to be a subject of much debate by stakeholders internal and external to the university. Notable concerns driving this debate derive from a seemingly discursive array of factors including increasing student numbers, increased understanding of the economic value of doctoral graduates, capitalisation of the academic market and a focus on allocating funding using ostensibly narrow, arbitrary measures of ‘program success’ such as completion rates/time to completion, all framed by a wider debate regarding precisely what constitutes valid knowledge in contemporary society. Within the university, the biomedical sciences are one area of scholarship undergoing rapid change in this respect. One of the salient outcomes of these internal and external dialogues is the apparent transition of biomedical doctoral education towards a ‘training model’ that places increasing emphasis on rapid completion and the generation of ‘industry ready graduates’; a transition that is, potentially, occurring at the expense of the edifying and transformative aspects of biomedical doctoral education. Focusing on the effects of academic capitalisation, this paper draws on data from Australia and Europe to examine the drivers and potential effect(s) of this shift on contemporary doctoral education in the biomedical sciences. This paper acknowledges the potential benefit of contemporary developments whilst simultaneously concluding that by progressing too far towards a quantitatively assessed, industry-driven training model we risk eliminating the intellectual and societal transforming aspects of biomedical doctoral education that make graduates increasingly valuable to our economy and, just as importantly, to our society as a whole.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Asteris, M. (2006). British Universities: The “coal exporters” of the 21st century. Journal of Studies in International Education, 10(3), 224–240.
Barnes, D. E., & Bero, L. A. (1998). Why review articles on the health effects of passive smoking reach different conclusions. Journal of the American Medical Association, 279(19), 1566–1570.
Barnett, R. (2000a). Supercomplexity and the curriculum. Studies in Higher Education, 25(3), 255–265.
Barnett, R. (2000b). University knowledge in an age of supercomplexity. Higher Education, 40(4), 409–422.
Barnett, R. (2009). Knowing and becoming in the higher education curriculum. Studies in Higher Education, 34(4), 429–440.
Barnett, R. (2011). Learning about learning: A conundrum and a possible resolution. London Review of Education, 9(1), 5–13.
Bekelman, J. E., Li, Y., & Gross, C. P. (2003). Scope and impact of financial conflicts of interest in biomedical research: A systematic review. Journal of the American Medical Association, 289(4), 454–465.
Brandt, A. M. (1978). Racism and research: The case of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. The Hastings Center report, 8(6), 21–29.
Breimer, L. H., & Mikhailidis, D. P. (1993). Towards a doctoral thesis through published works. Biomedicine and Pharmacotherapy, 47(9), 403–407.
Bridges, D. (2006). The practice of higher education: in pursuit of excellence and of equity. Educational Theory, 56(4), 371–386.
Brien, D. L. (2008). Publish or Perish?: Investigating the doctorate by publication in writing. Retrieved 20 June, 2011, from http://www.aawp.org.au/files/Brien.pdf.
Callaghan, J. (1976). A rational debate based on the facts. Retrieved 20 June, 2011, from http://www.educationengland.org.uk/documents/speeches/1976ruskin.html.
Campbell, T., & Slaughter, S. (1999). Faculty and administrators attitudes toward potential conflicts of interest, commitment, and equity in university–industry relationships. Journal of Higher Education, 70(3), 309–352.
Check, E. (2007). More biologists but tenure stays static. Nature, 448(7156), 848–849.
Coggeshall, P. E., Norvell, J. C., Bogorad, L., & Bock, R. M. (1978). Changing postdoctoral career patterns for biomedical scientists. Science, 202(4367), 487–493.
Cumming, J. (2009). The doctoral experience in science: Challenging the current orthodoxy. British Educational Research Journal, 35(6), 877–890.
Dobson, I. R. (2001). How has massification changed the shape of Australian universities? Tertiary Education and Management, 7(4), 295–310.
Dobson, I. R. (2006). Science at the crossroads? The decline of science in Australian higher education. Tertiary Education and Management, 12(2), 183–195.
Downie, J., & Herder, M. (2007). Reflections on the commercialisation of Research conducted in public institutions in Canada. McGill Health Law Publication, 23–44.
Edwards, D., & Smith, T. F. (2010). Supply issues for science academics in Australia: Now and in the future. Higher Education, 60(1), 19–32.
Entwistle, N. (2008). Taking stock: Teaching and learning research in higher education. Paper presented at the International Symposium on Teaching and Learning Research in Higher Education.
Gatfield, T. (2005). An investigation into PhD supervisory management styles: Development of a dynamic conceptual model and its managerial implications. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 27(3), 311–325.
Gumport, P. J. (2002). The future of the city of intellect. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Guri-Rosenblit, S., Sebkova, H., & Teichler, U. (2007). Massification and diversity of higher education systems: Interplay of complex dimensions. Higher Education Policy, 20(4), 373–389.
Hakala, J. (2009a). The future of the academic calling? Junior researchers in the entrepreneurial university. Higher Education, 57(2), 173–190.
Hakala, J. (2009b). Socialization of junior researchers in new academic research environments: Two case studies from Finland. Studies in Higher Education, 34(5), 501–516.
Halse, C., & Malfroy, J. (2010). Retheorizing doctoral supervision as professional work. Studies in Higher Education, 35(1), 79–92.
Harman, K. (2004). Producing ‘industry-ready’ doctorates: Australian cooperative research centre approaches to doctoral education. Studies in Continuing Education, 26(3), 387–404.
Hegel, G. W. F. (2008). Outlines of the philosophy of right. Oxford: Oxford University Pres.
Holley, K. (2009). Animal research practices and doctoral student identity development in a scientific community. Studies in Higher Education, 34(5), 577–591.
Holligan, C. (2005). Fact and fiction: A case history of doctoral supervision. Educational Research, 47(3), 267–278.
Hopwood, N. (2010). A sociocultural view of doctoral students’ relationships and agency. Studies in Continuing Education, 32(2), 103–117.
Howell, L. P., Chen, C. Y., Joad, J. P., Green, R., Callahan, E. J., & Bonham, A. C. (2010). Issues and challenges of non-tenure-track research faculty: The UC Davis school of medicine experience. Academic Medicine, 85(6), 1041–1047.
Hugo, G. (2005). Some emerging demographic issues on Australia’s teaching academic workforce. Higher Education Policy, 18(3), 207–229.
Insight Economics. (2006). Economic impact study of the CRC programme. Melbourne, Australia.
Jaspers, K. (1953). The idea of The Unviersity. Boston: Beacon Press.
Kemp, D. A. (1999). Knowledge and innovation: A policy statement on research and research training. Retrieved 2011, from http://www.deewr.gov.au/Pages/default.aspx.
Kwan, B. S. C. (2009). An investigation of instruction in research publishing offered in doctoral programs: The Hong Kong case. Higher Education, 59(1), 55–68.
Lee, A., & Kamler, B. (2008). Bringing pedagogy to doctoral publishing. Teaching in Higher Education, 13(5), 511–523.
Leonard, D., Metcalfe, J., Becker, R., & Evans, J. (2006). Review of literature on the impact of working context and support on the postgraduate research student learning experience. York, UK: The Higher Education Academy.
Lexchin, J., Bero, L. A., Djulbegovic, B., & Clark, O. (2003). Pharmaceutical industry sponsorship and research outcome and quality: Systematic review. British Medical Journal, 326(7400), 1167–1170.
Marton, F. (1981). Phenomenography—Describing conceptions of the world around us. Instructional Science, 10(2), 177–200.
Marton, F., & Svensson, L. (1979). Conceptions of research in student learning. Higher Education, 8(4), 471–486.
Marx, K., & Engels, F. (2004). The communist manifesto. London: Penguin.
McLean, M. (2006). Pedagogy and the university: Critical theory and practice. London: Continuum International Publishing Group.
Mendoza, P. (2007). Academic capitalism and doctoral student socialization: A case study. Journal of Higher Education, 78(1), 71–96.
Mill, J. S. (2008). On liberty and other essays. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Neumann, R. (2001). Disciplinary differences and university teaching. Studies in Higher Education, 26(2), 135–146.
Neumann, R. (2007). Policy and practice in doctoral education. Studies in Higher Education, 32(4), 459–473.
Neumann, R., & Guthrie, J. (2002). The corporatization of research in Australian higher education. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 13(5–6), 721–741.
Newman, A., & Jones, R. (2006). Authorship of research papers: Ethical and professional issues for short-term researchers. Journal of Medical Ethics, 32(7), 420–423.
Ngok, K. (2008). Massification, bureaucratization and questing for “world-class” status: Higher education in China since the mid-1990s. International Journal of Educational Management, 22(6), 547–564.
Nowotny, H., Scott, P., & Gibbons, M. (2003). Introduction: ‘Mode 2’ revisited: The new production of knowledge. Minerva, 41(3), 179–194.
Park, C. (2006). The end of the secret garden: Reframing postgraduate supervision. Retrieved June 17, 2011, from http://www.lancs.ac.uk/celt/celtweb/files/ChrisPark.pdf.
Park, C. (2007). Redefining the doctorate. York, UK: The Higher Education Academy.
Prosser, M., Martin, E., Trigwell, K., Ramsden, P., & Middleton, H. (2008). University academics’ experience of research and its relationship to their experience of teaching. Instructional Science, 36(1), 3–16.
Prosser, M., Ramsden, P., Trigwell, K., & Martin, E. (2003). Dissonance in experience of teaching and its relation to the quality of student learning. Studies in Higher Education, 28(1), 37–48.
Prosser, M., Trigwell, K., & Taylor, P. (1994). A phenomenographic study of academics’ conceptions of science learning and teaching. Learning and Instruction, 4(3), 217–231.
Roberts, P. (1999). The future of the university: Reflections from New Zealand. International Review of Education, 45(1), 65–85.
Robins, L., & Kanowski, P. (2008). PhD by publication: A student’s perspective. Journal of Research Practice, 4(2), 1–20.
Säljo, R. (1979). Learning about learning. Higher Education, 8(4), 443–451.
Sinclair, M. (2004). The pedagogy of ‘Good’ PhD supervision: A national cross-disciplinary investigation of PhD supervision. Retrieved from http://www.dest.gov.au/sectors/higher_education/publications_resources/summaries_brochures/the_pedagogy_of_good_phd_supervision.htm. Accessed June 2011.
The Australian Federal Government. (2009). Award course completion 2009: Selected higher education statistics. Retrieved 2011, from http://www.deewr.gov.au/HigherEducation/Publications/HEStatistics/Publications/Pages/Students.aspx.
The Australian National University. (2009). PhD by publication. Retrieved 20 June, 2011, from http://science.anu.edu.au/study/higher-degree-research/Policies/PhD_by_Publication_Guidelines.pdf.
The National Health and Medical Research Council. (2011a). NHMRC 2010 project grant round highlights. Canberra, Australia: The National Health and Medical Research Council.
The National Health and Medical Research Council. (2011b). NHMRC Project grants funding policy for funding commencing in 2012. Canberra, Australia: The National Health and Medical Research Council.
The National Health and Medical Research Council. (2011c). Scholarships. Retrieved March, 2011, from http://www.nhmrc.gov.au/fellows/types/granttype/scholars/index.htm.
The New Zealand Government. (2010). Student loan scheme bill. Retrieved from http://legislation.govt.nz/bill/government/2010/0198/latest/DLM3179928.html.
The University of Melbourne. (2011). PhD thesis. Retrieved March, 2011, from http://www.gradresearch.unimelb.edu.au/current/phdhbk/thesis.html.
The University of Oxford. (2008). Education committee. Policy and guidance on research degrees. Retrieved March 2011, from http://www.admin.ox.ac.uk/epsc/guidance/index.shtml.
The University of Sydney. (2008). Postgraduate: Degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Retrieved March, 2011, from http://fmweb01.ucc.usyd.edu.au/FMPro?-db=POL_Main.fp5&-lay=www&-format=/pol/pol_summary.html&-RecID=65&-find.
The University of Western Australia. (2010a). Higher degrees by research (by thesis). Retrieved March 2011, from http://rules.handbooks.uwa.edu.au/rules/GeneralRules/Part3?childfx=on.
The University of Western Australia. (2010b). Thesis as a series of papers. Retrieved 20 June, 2011, from http://www.postgraduate.uwa.edu.au/students/thesis/series.
The Wellcome Trust. (2000a). Review of Wellcome Trust PhD research training: The student perspective. London, UK: Wellcome Trust.
The Wellcome Trust. (2000b). Review of Wellcome Trust PhD training: The supervisor perspective. London, UK: Wellcome Trust.
Thune, T. (2009). Doctoral students on the university-industry interface: A review of the literature. Higher Education, 58, 637–651.
Trigwell, K. (2005). Teaching-research relations, cross-disciplinary collegiality and student learning. Higher Education, 49(3), 235–254.
Trigwell, K., & Prosser, M. (1996). Changing approaches to teaching: A relational perspective. Studies in Higher Education, 21(3), 275–284.
Ulku-Steiner, B., Kurtz-Costes, B., & Kinlaw, C. R. (2000). Doctoral student experiences in gender-balanced and male-dominated graduate programs. Journal of Educational Psychology, 92(2), 296–307.
University College London. (2011). Academic regulations and guidelines for research degree students. Retrieved March 2011, from http://www.ucl.ac.uk/registry/acd_regs.
Williams, P. J. (2007). Valid knowledge: The economy and the academy. Higher Education, 54(4), 511–523.
Acknowledgments
MWK wishes to acknowledge the support of the Women and Infant Research Foundation (Western Australia). The authors wish to thank C. Trevitt for stimulating discussions in the course of editing this paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kemp, M.W., Newnham, J.P. & Chapman, E. The biomedical doctorate in the contemporary university: education or training and why it matters. High Educ 63, 631–644 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-011-9464-5
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-011-9464-5