Representation or Reason: Consulting the Public on the Ethics of Health Policy
- 122 Downloads
Consulting the public about the ethical approaches underlying health policies can seem an appealing means of addressing concerns about limited public participation in development of health policy. However ambiguity surrounds questions of whether, or how consultation can really contribute to more defensible decisions about ethical aspects of policy. This paper clarifies the role and limits of public consultation on ethics, beginning by separating different senses of defensibility in decisions on ethics. Defensibility of ethical decisions could be understood either in the sense of legitimacy in virtue of reflecting the opinions of the public whose interests are affected, or in the sense of being able to withstand and respond to challenges presented in ethical debate. The question then is whether there are forms of consultation which have the potential to realise more defensible decisions in either of these senses. Problems of adequately accounting for the views of those affected by policy decisions casts doubt on the plausibility of using consultation as a means of determining the opinions of the public. Consultation can have a role by bringing new ideas and challenges to debate, although it is uncertain whether this will increase the defensibility of any decision on ethics.
KeywordsConsultation Democracy Ethics Moral argument Health policy Public participation
- 1.Anscombe, G. E. M. (1967). Who is Wronged? The Oxford Review, 5, 16–17.Google Scholar
- 2.Culyer, A. J. (1997). The rationing debate: Maximising the health of the whole community. British Medical Journal, 314, (7081). (Available at http://www.bmj.com/archive/7081ed2.htm, Accessed 09/06/2007).
- 5.Farrington-Douglas, J., & Allen, J. (2005). Equitable choices for health. IPPR (Available at http://www.ippr.org.uk/publicationsandreports/publication.asp?id=321, Accessed 08.06.2007).
- 6.Harris, J. (1988). More and better justice. In J. M. Bell & S. Mendus (Eds.), Philosophy and medical welfare (1st ed., pp. 75–96). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- 11.National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, Patient and public involvement policy. (Available at http://www.nice.org.uk/page.aspx?o=14, Accessed 31 May 2007).
- 12.Parfit, D. (1978). Innumerate ethics. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 7(4), 285–301.Google Scholar
- 13.Press Association (26 December 2006) Blair plan to consult people panels. BBC News Online (Available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/6209163.stm, Accessed 31 May 2007).
- 15.Wakeford , T. (2002). Citizen’s Juries: A radical alternative for social research. In Social Research Update, 37 (Available at http://sru.soc.surrey.ac.uk/SRU37.html, Accessed 31 May 2007).