Abstract
In accordance with an old suggestion of Asher Peres (1962), we consider the electromagnetic field as fundamental and the metric as a subsidiary field. In following up this thought, we formulate Maxwell’s theory in a diffeomorphism invariant and metric-independent way. The electromagnetic field is then given in terms of the excitation \(H = ({\cal H}, {\cal D})\) and the field strength F = (E,B). Additionally, a local and linear “spacetime relation” is assumed between H and F, namely H ~ κ F, with the constitutive tensor κ. The propagation is studied of electromagnetic wave fronts (surfaces of discontinuity) with a method of Hadamard. We find a generalized Fresnel equation that is quartic in the wave covector of the wave front. We discuss under which conditions the waves propagate along the light cone. Thereby we derive the metric of spacetime, up to a conformal factor, by purely electromagnetic methods.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A. Peres (1962) Ann Phys (NY) 19 279–286 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0003-4916(62)90220-8 Occurrence Handle0105.41302 Occurrence Handle26 #7415
A. Einstein, Sitzungsber. Königl. Preuss. Akad. Wiss. Berlin (1916) pp. 184–188; see also The collected papers of Albert Einstein. Vol. 6, A. J. Kox et al., eds. (1996) pp. 263–269.
F. Kottler (1922) Sitzungsber. Akad Wien IIa. 131 119–146 Occurrence Handle48.1034
C. Truesdell and R. A. Toupin, in Handbuch der Physik Vol. III/1, S. Flügge, ed. (Springer, Berlin, 1960), pp. 226–793.
Post, Formal Structure of Electromagnetics – General Covariance and Electromagnetics (North Holland, Amsterdam, 1962, and Dover, Mineola, NY, 1997).
R. A. Toupin, in Non-Linear Continuum Theories, C.I.M.E. Conference, Bressanone, Italy 1965. C. Truesdell and G. Grioli, coordinators, pp. 203–342.
A. Kovetz (2000) Electromagnetic Theory Oxford University Press Oxford
F.W. Hehl Yu.N. Obukhov (2003) Foundations of Classical Electrodynamics: Charge Flux, and Metric Birkhäuser Boston, MA
G.F. Rubilar, Thesis (University of Cologne, June 2002); see Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 11, 717–782 (2002).
M. Schönberg (1971) Rivista Brasileira de Fisica. 1 91–122
Y. Itin F.W. Hehl (2004) Ann Phys (NY) 312 60–83 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.aop.2004.01.009 Occurrence Handle2004AnPhy.312...60I Occurrence Handle2005d:83060
A. Sommerfeld, Elektrodynamik. Vorlesungen über Theoretische Physik, Band 3 (Dieterich’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Wiesbaden, 1948). English translation: A. Sommerfeld, Electrodynamics, Lectures in Theoretical Physics, Vol. 3 (Academic Press, New York, 1952).
F. Scheck (2004) Theoretische Physik 3 Klassische Feldtheorie. Von der Elektrodynamik zu den Eichtheorien Springer Springer Berlin
F.W. Hehl Yu. N. Obukhov (2004) Phys Lett. A323 169–175 Occurrence Handle2004PhLA..323..169H
G.J Kaiser (2004) J Phys. A37 7163–7168 Occurrence Handle2004JPhA...37.7163K Occurrence Handle2005d:78004
C. Lämmerzahl M.P. Haugan (2001) Phys Lett. A282 223–229 Occurrence Handle2001PhLA..282..223L
C. Lämmerzahl I. Ciufolini H. Dittus et al. (2004) Gen Relativ Grav. 36 2373–2416
C. Lämmerzahl A. Macias H. Müller (2005) Phys Rev. D71 025007 Occurrence Handle2005PhRvD..71b5007L
A. Peres, arXiv.org: gr-qc/0210066 (3 pages) (2002).
A. Peres (2003) Int J Mod Phys. D12 1751–1754 Occurrence Handle2003IJMPD..12.1751P Occurrence Handle2036007
M. Born L. Infeld (1934) Proc Roy Soc (London) A144 425–451 Occurrence Handle1934RSPSA.144..425B
W. Heisenberg H. Euler (1936) Z Phys. 98 714–732
S.M. Carroll G.B. Field R. Jackiw (1990) Phys Rev. D41 1231–1240 Occurrence Handle1990PhRvD..41.1231C
Y. Itin (2004) Phys Rev. D70 025012 Occurrence Handle2004PhRvD..70b5012I
Schouten J.A. Tensor Analysis for Physicists. 2nd edn. reprinted (Dover, Mineola, New York, 1989).
I.V. Lindell A.H. Sihvola S.A. Tretyakov A.J. Viitanen (1994) Electromagnetic Waves in Chiral and Bi-Isotropic Media Artech House Boston
T.G. Mackay A. Lakhtakia (2004) Phys Rev E 69 026602 Occurrence Handle10.1103/PhysRevE.69.026602 Occurrence Handle2004PhRvE..69b6602M
A. Lakhtakia (2004) Optik 115 151–158 Occurrence Handle000223332200002
C. Schaefer (1932) Einführung in die theoretische Physik: Dritter Band erster Teil—Elektrodynamik und Optik de Gruyter Berlin
G.F. Rubilar Yu. N. Obukhov F.W. Hehl (2002) Int J Mod Phys D 11 1227–1242 Occurrence Handle2002IJMPD..11.1227R Occurrence Handle2003i:83035
R.M. Kiehn G.P. Kiehn J.B. Roberds (1991) Phys Rev A 43 5665–5671 Occurrence Handle10.1103/PhysRevA.43.5665 Occurrence Handle1991PhRvA..43.5665K Occurrence Handle92d:78005
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hehl, F.W., Obukhov, Y.N. To Consider the Electromagnetic Field as Fundamental, and the Metric Only as a Subsidiary Field. Found Phys 35, 2007–2025 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-005-8659-y
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-005-8659-y