The rising interest, in the late 20th century, in the foundations of quantum physics, a subject in which Franco Selleri has excelled, has suggested the fair question: how did it become so? The current answer says that experiments have allowed to bring into the laboratories some previous gedanken experiments, beginning with those about EPR and related to Bell’s inequalities. I want to explore an alternative view, by which there would have been, before Bell’s inequalities experimental tests, a change in the views shared by physicists concerning the intellectual status of that issue. I will take three cases which will serve as the threads of our story: the connections between Bohm’s causal interpretation and Bell’s inequalities; Wigner’s ideas on the measurement problem; and finally Everett’s relative states formulation. In the end, I will discuss how those threads were gathered together by creating foundations of quantum physics as a field of research.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
D. Greenberger (ed), New Techniques and Ideas in Quantum Measurement Theory (Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 480, 1986). [Preface].
S. Haroche (2002) Leçon inaugurale –- Chaire de physique quantique Collège de France Paris
D. Wick (1995) The Infamous Boundary: Seven Decades of Controversy in Quantum Physics Birkhaüser Boston
A. Aczel (2002) Entanglement: The Greatest Mystery in Physics Four Walls Eight Windows New York
J. L. Bromberg, ‘‘The micromaser as a philosophic instrument’’, 2004 (unpublished).
O. Freire Jr., ‘‘Marxism and quantum controversy: responding to Max Jammer’s question’’, paper to the conference ‘‘Intelligentsia: Russian and Soviet Science on the World Stage, 1860–1960’’, University of Georgia, Athens GA, 29–31 October 2004 (unpublished).
M. Jammer (1974) The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics –- The Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective John Wiley New York
J. Heilbron (2001) The earliest missionaries of the Copenhagen spirit P. Galison M. Gordin D. Kaiser (Eds) In Science and Society – The History of Modern Physical Science in the Twentieth Century. Vol. 4 –- Quantum Histories. Routledge New York 295–330
S. Schweber (1986) ArticleTitleThe empiricist temper regnant: theoretical physics in the United States 1920--1950 HSPS Part 1 55–98
J. Mehra H. Rechenberg (Eds) (2001) The Historical Development of Quantum Theory Springer New York Occurrence Handle1039.81004
H. Kragh (Eds) (1999) Quantum Generations –- A History of Physics in the Twentieth Century Princeton University Press Princeton 211 Occurrence Handle0938.01021
T. S. Kuhn The Structure of the Scientific Revolutions (1970) 2nd edn. Chicago University Press Chicago
J. Clauster (2002) Early history of Bell’s theorem R. A. Bertlmann A. Zeilinger (Eds) Quantum [Un] speakables – From Bell to Quantum Information Springer Berlin 61–98
J. L. Bromberg, ‘‘The rise of ‘experimental metaphysics’ in late twentieth century physics’’, 2004 (unpublished).
O. Freire SuffixJr. M. Paty A. L. R. Barros (2002) Physique quantique et causalité selon Bohm –- Analyse d’un cas d’accueil défavorable H. Kragh P. Marage G. Vanpaemel (Eds) History of Modern Physics Brepols Turnhout 261–273
J. Cushing (1994) Quantum Mechanics –- Historical Contingency and the Copenhagen Hegemony The University of Chicago Press Chicago Occurrence Handle0828.00005
T. Pinch, ‘‘What does a proof do if it does not prove? A study of the social conditions and metaphysical divisions leading to David Bohm and John von Neumann failing to communicate in quantum physics’’, In The Social Production of Scientific Knowledge (Sociology of Science, 1), Mendelsohn et al. (eds), (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1977) pp. 171–216.
D. Bohm (1952) ‘‘A suggested interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of ‘hidden’ variables, I and II’’, Phys. Rev. 85(2) 166–179 180–193 Occurrence Handle1952PhRv...85..166B Occurrence Handle46288
L. Rosenfeld (1958) L’évidence de la complementaritè A. George (Eds) Louis de Broglie –- Physicien et Penseur Albin Michel Paris 43–65
W. Heisenberg (Eds) (1958) Physics and Philosophy Harper New York 133
A. Messiah (1964) Quantum Mechanics North-Holland Amsterdam 48
S. Körner (Eds) (1957) Observation and Interpretation in the Philosophy of Physics –- With Special Reference to Quantum Mechanics Dover New York
O. Freire Jr., ‘‘Science and exile –- David Bohm, the hot times of the cold war, and his lasting struggle for a new interpretation of quantum mechanics’’, Paper presented at the conference ‘‘Migrant Scientists in the Twentieth Century’’, Milan, 2003 (unpublished).
J. S. Bell (1982) ArticleTitleOn the impossible pilot wave Found. Phys. 12 989–999 Occurrence Handle1982FoPh...12..989B Occurrence Handle683020
W. Pauli (1999) Scientific Correspondence, Vol. IV, part II – 1953–1954 Springer Berlin
J. Bernstein (1991) Quantum Profiles Princeton University Press Princeton
J. M. Jauch C. Piron (1963) ArticleTitleCan Hidden Variables be Excluded in Quantum Mechanics? Helv. Phys. Acta 36 827–837 Occurrence Handle0129.41902 Occurrence Handle171511
J. S. Bell (1964) ArticleTitleOn the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paradox Physics 1 IssueID3 195–200 Occurrence Handle0899.03019
J. S. Bell (1966) ArticleTitle“On the problem of hidden variables in quantum mechanics” Rev. Mod. Phys. 38 447–452 Occurrence Handle0152.23605 Occurrence Handle1966RvMP...38..447B
J. Clauser M. Horne A. Shimony R. Holt (1969) ArticleTitleProposed experiment to test local hidden-variable theories Phys. Rev. Lett. 23 880–884 Occurrence Handle1969PhRvL..23..880C
E. P. Wigner (1961) “Remarks on the mind body” I. J. Good (Eds) The Scientist Speculates. W. Heinemann London
E. P. Wigner (1963) ArticleTitle“The problem of measurement” Am. J. Phys. 31 6–15 Occurrence Handle0173.29603 Occurrence Handle1963AmJPh..31....6W Occurrence Handle151126
T. S. Kuhn et al. (1967) Sources for the History of Quantum Physics –- an inventory and report American Philosophical Society Philadelphia
L. Rosenfeld, ‘‘The measuring process in quantum mechanics’’, Prog. Theor. Phys. Supplement. 222–235 (1965).
A. Daneri A. Loinger G. M. Prosperi (1962) ArticleTitle“Quantum theory of measurement and ergodicity conditions” Nucl. Phys. 33 297–319 Occurrence Handle0105.21701 Occurrence Handle143488
B. d’Espagnat (Eds) (1971) Foundations of Quantum Mechanics –- Proceedings of the Int. School of Physics ‘Enrico Fermi’ Academic Press New York
O. R. Frisch (1971) “The conceptual problem of quantum theory from the experimentalist’s point of view” T. Bastin (Eds) Quantum Theory and Beyond Cambridge University Press Cambridge 13–21
L. E. Ballentine (1970) ArticleTitle“The statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics” Rev. Mod. Phys. 42 IssueID4 358–381 Occurrence Handle0203.27801 Occurrence Handle1970RvMP...42..358B
D. Home W. A. B. Whitaker (1992) ArticleTitle“Ensemble interpretations of quantum mechanics. A modern perspective” Phys. Rep. 210 IssueID4 223–317 Occurrence Handle1992PhR...210..223H Occurrence Handle1147158
A. Shimony, ‘‘Wigner on foundations of quantum mechanics’’, In The Collected Works of Eugene Paul Wigner, Part A - Vol III, Particles and Fields; Foundations of Quantum Mechanics (Springer, Berlin, 1997), pp. 401–414.
A. Aspect (2004) Introduction J. S. Bell (Eds) Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Letter from J. A. Wheeler to H. Everett, 22 May, 1956. [Dictated from Holland]. Wheeler Papers. Series I --- Box Di-Fermi #1, folder Everett. Wheeler Papers are at American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia.
H. Everett SuffixIII (1957) ArticleTitleRelative states’ formulation of quantum mechanics Rev. Mod. Phys. 29 454–462 Occurrence Handle1957RvMP...29..454E Occurrence Handle94159
J. A. Wheeler (1957) ArticleTitleAssessment of Everett’s ‘relative state’ formulation of quantum theory Rev. Mod. Phys. 29 463–465 Occurrence Handle1957RvMP...29..463W Occurrence Handle94160
Hugh Everett, interviewed by C. Misner, May 1977. Tape transcribed by E. Shikhotsev. Everett Papers, series I-3, [CHP-AIP].
F. H. A. Freitas O. Freire SuffixJr. (2003) ArticleTitleSobre o uso da Web of Science como fonte para a história da ciencia Revista da SBHC 1 IssueID2 129–147
B. S. DeWitt (1967) ArticleTitleQuantum Theory of Gravitation, I. The Canonical Theory Phys. Rev. 160 IssueID5 1113–1148 Occurrence Handle0158.46504 Occurrence Handle1967PhRv..160.1113D
Letter from B. DeWitt to J. A. Wheeler, 7 May 1957. Wheeler Papers. Series I --- Box Di-Fermi Award #1, Folder Everett.
B. S. DeWitt and N. Graham (eds), The many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics. A fundamental exposition by Hugh Everett, III, with papers by J. A. Wheeler [and others], (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1973).
B. S. DeWitt N. Graham (1971) ArticleTitle“Resource letter IQM-1 on the interpretation of quantum mechanics” Am. J. Phys. 39 724–738 Occurrence Handle1971AmJPh..39..724D
Letter from Bryce DeWitt to R. Hobart Ellis, Jr, 21 October, 1969. Physics Today Division, Records, 1948–1970, American Institute of Physics, College Park, MD.
Letter from R. Hobart Ellis, Jr. to Bryce Dewitt, 24 October, 1969. Idem.
B. S. DeWitt (1970) ArticleTitle“Quantum mechanics and reality” Phys. Today 23 IssueID9 155–165 Occurrence Handle10.1063/1.3022331
‘‘Quantum-mechanics debate’’, Phys. Today 24(4), 36–44 (1971).
‘‘Still more quantum mechanics’’. [Letters by G.L. Trigg, M. Hammerton, R. Hobart Ellis Jr., R. Goldston, H. Schmidt]. Phys. Today 24(10), 11–13 (1971).
Found. Phys. 1, 1970, Editorial Preface.
B. d’Espagnat, Interviewed by O. Freire, 2001, available at American Institute of Physics.
P. Forman (1987) ArticleTitle“Behind quantum electronics: national security as basis for physical research in the United States” HSPS 1 149–229
D. Kevles (1979) The Physicists –- The History of a Scientific Community in Modern America Vintage Books New York
H. Stevens (2003) ArticleTitleFundamental physics and its justifications, 1945--1993 HSPS Part 1 151–197 Occurrence Handle2051877
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Freire, O. The Historical Roots of ‘‘Foundations of Quantum Physics’’ as a Field of Research (1950–1970). Found Phys 34, 1741–1760 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-004-1314-1
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-004-1314-1