‘‘The strange Story of the Concept which inaugurated Modern Theoretical Physics’’ is the title of a lecture which I delivered on the invitation of Professor Franco Selleri at the University of Bari about 20 years ago. Since Professor Selleri himself has written several interesting papers on this concept and since the centennial of the birth of modern theoretical physics will be celebrated soon, I found it appropriate to dedicate this essay, containing so far unpublished critical and historical comments on this concept, to Professor Selleri on the occasion of his 70th birthday. It should be emphasized that the critical comments in this essay are not intended to question the validity of the theory initiated by this concept, a theory which in the realm of its applicability is daily corroborated by numerous experiments in high-energy laboratories all over the world. Although these critical remarks refer almost exclusively to the first publication of this theory, a publication which has been hailed as ‘‘the most important paper written in the 20th century,’’ they discuss profound problems of general importance for the study of the foundations of physics.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
The term ‘‘simultaneity of spatially separated events’’ is often abbreviated to ‘‘distant simultaneity’’. Unfortunately no monograph has yet been published on the conceptual history of this concept, which played an important role in the philosophy of physics from antiquity until the present.
A. Einstein, Ann. Physik 17, 891--921 (1905). English translations in The Principle of Relativity (Dover, New York, 1952), pp. 37--65; The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein, Vol. 2 (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1989), pp. 147--171.
A. Sommerfeld, Atombau und Spektrallinien (Vieweg, Braunschweig, 1919, 1931), p. 39.
M. von Laue, Physikalische Abhandlungen und Vortärge Vol. 1 (Vieweg, Braunschweig, 1958), p. 618.
M. Planck, Verhandlungen der Deutschen Physikalischen Gesellschaft 2, 237 (1900).
M. Jammer (Eds) (1966) The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics McGraw-Hill New York 22
Interview with F. Reiche, Archives for the History of Quantum Physics (Niels Bohr Institute, Copenhagen, 1961), p. XVII.
W. Heisenberg (Eds) (1958) Physics and Philosophy Harper & Row New York
W. Heisenberg, Die Naturwissenschaften 22, 669 (1934). Because of this article, amongst others, in which Heisenberg defended Einstein’s theory under the Nazi regime, he was called ‘‘ein weisser Jude’’ and threatened to be transported to a concentration camp, had it not been for the intervention of Himmler, whose mother was befriended with Heisenberg’s mother. For details see P. L. Rose, Heisenberg and the Nazi Atomic Bomb Project (Berkeley, University of California Press, 1998), p. 262.
A. Einstein (1907) ArticleTitleRelativitätsprinzip und die aus demselben gezogenen Folgerungen Jahrbuch der Radioaktivität und Elektronik 4 411–462 Occurrence Handle1908JRE.....4..411E
A. Einstein (1982) ArticleTitleHow I created the theory of relativity Phys. Today 35 45 Occurrence Handle10.1063/1.2915203
H. Reichenbach: ‘‘The philosophical significance of the theory of relativity’’, in Albert Einstein: Philosopher – Scientist P. A. Schilpp, ed., (Open Court, LaSalle, IL, 1949), pp. 287–311; quotation on p. 294.
The priniple of relativity in mechanics has been stated already by Newton in Corollary 5 of his Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica (Streater, London, 1687) as follows: ‘‘Corporum dato spatio inclusorum ijdem sunt motus, interse, sive spatium illus quiescat, sive moveatur idem uniformiter in directium absque motu circulari’’. [‘‘The motions of bodies included in a given space are the same among themselves, whether that space is at rest, or moves uniformly in a right line without any circular motion’’.].
Ref. 2, p. 895.
R. W. Clark (Eds) (1971) Einstein – The Life and Times The World Publishing Company, Avon Books New York 116
A. I. Miller (Eds) (1981) Albert Einstein’s Special Theory of Relativity Addison-Wesley, Reading MA xiii
Ref. 2, p. 892.
Cf. in this context R. Torretti, Relativity and Geometry (Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1983), Chap. 1.
A. S. Eddington (Eds) (1929) The Nature of the Physical World Macmillan, Cambridge University Press New York, Cambridge 124 Occurrence HandleJFM 54.0060.01
O. Blumenthal (1913) Das Relativitätsprinzip. eine Sammlung von Abhandlungen Teubner Leipzig Occurrence HandleJFM 44.0770.01
I. McCausland (1984) Brit. J. Philos. Sci. 35 60 Occurrence Handle0553.01013
Although in German the ‘‘law of inertia’’ was generally called ‘‘Beharrungsgesetz’’, a ‘‘system of inertia’’ was usually called ‘‘Inertialsystem’’. See, e.g., L. Lange, Die geschichtliche Entwicklung des Bewegungsbegriffs und ihr voraussichtliches Endergebnis (Engelmann, Leipzig, 1886), p. 56, or F. L. Frege, ‘‘Über das Trägheitsgesetz’’, Zeitschrift für Philosophie und philosophische Kritik 98, 145–161, especially p. 149 (1891).
It is interesting to note that, in contrast to Lange, Frege and other German philosophers of space and time, Einstein avoided the term ‘‘Inertialsystem’’ until about 1920 and used instead the expression ‘‘beschleunigungsfrei bewegtes System’’ as on page 414 of his paper ‘‘Über das Relativitätsprinzip und die aus demselben gezogenen Folgerungen’’, Jahrbuch der Radioaktivität 4, 411–462 (1907). Still in 1917 he wrote: ‘‘ Ein Koordinatensystem, dessen Bewegungszustand ein solcher ist, dass relativ zu ihm das Trägheitsgesetz gilt, nennen wir ein ‘Galileisches Koordinatensystem’’’. [‘‘A system of coordinates of which the state of motion is such that the law of inertia holds relative to it is called a ‘Galileian system of co-ordinates’’’.] See his Über die spezielle und die allgemeine Relativitätstheorie, Gemeinverständlich (Vieweg, Braunschweig, 1917), p. 8.
M. von Laue (Eds) (1952) Die Relativitatstheorie Vieweg Braunschweig 1
L. Lange (1885) ArticleTitleUeber das Beharrungsgesetz Leipziger Berichte 37 333
F. I. G. Frege, Ref. 22, p. 145.
M. von Laue (Eds) (1911) Das Relativitätsprinzip Vieweg Braunschweig 3 Occurrence HandleJFM 42.0718.04
M. von Laue (1913) ArticleTitleDas Relativitätsprinzip Jahresberichte der Philosophie 1 243
P. Janich. ‘‘Die Protophysik der Zeit und das Relativitätsprinzip’’, Zeitschrift für allgemeine Wissenshaftstheorie 9, 347 (1978); reprinted in J. Pfarr, Protophysik und Relativitätstheorie (BI Wissenschaftsverlag, Mannheim, 1981 ), p. 179.
M. Strauss, ‘‘Zur Logik der Begriffe ‘Inertialsystem’ und ‘Masse’, in Symposium aus Anlass des 50. Todestages von Ernst Mach (Ernst-Mach-Institut, Freiburg i. Br., 1966); ‘‘On the logic of ‘Inertial Frame’ and ‘Mass’’’, in Modern Physics and its Philosophy M. Strauss, ed. (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1972), p. 121.
W. H. McCrea (1952) Sci. Proc. R. Dublin Soc. 26 27 Occurrence Handle55842
J. Earman (Eds) (1989) World Enough and space–time MIT Press Cambridge, MA 98–101
H. Poincaré (1898) ArticleTitleLa Mesure du Temps Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale 6 1–13
J. Cohn (1968) ArticleTitleSpecial relativity in the quantum domain Am. J. Phys. 36 749–751 Occurrence Handle1968AmJPh..36..749C
Aristotle, The Physics, Book iv 218 a.
H. Minkowski, ‘‘Raum und Zeit’’, Phys. Z. 10, 104–111 ( ).
I. Kant, ‘‘De mundi sensibilis atque intelligibilis forma et principiis,’’ (1770) in Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2 (Reimer, Berlin, 1910), pp. 385--419.
I. Kant (Eds) (1781) Kritik der Reinen Vernunft Hartknoch Riga 182
N. K. Smith (Eds) (1923) A Commentary to Kant’s ‘Critique of Pure Reason Macmillan London 135
See J. Grimm and W. Grimm, Deutsches Wörterbuch, Vol. 41 (Hirzel, Leipzig, 1912, 1967), pp. 8277–8281.
See, e.g.,παυτɛζ,αμα (all together), Iliad, Book 8, 64. Cf. also Aristotle, Categories 7 b 15, 14 b 27.
‘‘Tempus absolutum verum et Mathematicum, in se et natura sua absque relatione ad extemum quodvis aequabiliter fluit’’, Ref. 13, p. 5.
I. Kant, Ref 35, ‘‘Der transzendentalen “Ästhetik – 2. Abschnitt: Von der Zeit’’.
G. W. Leibniz, Initium rerum Mathematicarum metaphysica, in Leibnizens Mathematische Schriften, I. C. Gerhardt, ed. Vol. 7, (Weidmann, Halle, 1855; Olms, Hildesheim, 1960), pp. 17–29.
Ibid., p. 18.
J. B. Barbour (1989) Absolute or Relative Motion Cambridge University Press Cambridge 676 Occurrence Handle0672.01001
G. Nerlich, ‘‘Simultaneity and convention in special relativity’’, in What? Where? When? Why/? R. McLaughlin, ed. (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1982), p. 130.
G. Sagnac, ‘‘L’ether lumineux démontré par l’effet du vent relatif d’éther dans un interférométre en rotation unifonne,’’ C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 157, 708–710 (1913). A. Anderson, H. R. Bilger, and G. E. Steman, ‘‘Sagnac Effect: A century of Earth-rotated interferometers,’’ Am. J Phys. 62, 975–985 (1994).
A. Einstein (1917) Über die spezielle und die allgemeine Relativitätstheorie, Gemeinverständlich Vieweg Braunschweig
A. Einstein (1919) Relativity, The Special and the General Theory: A Popular Exposition Methuen London
M. Wertheimer (1945) Productive Thinking Harper & Brothers New York
For further details see A. I. Miller, ‘‘Albert Einstein and Max Wertheimer: A Gestalt Psychologist’s View of the Genesis of Special Relativity Theory,’’ Hist. Sci. 13, 75–103 (1975).
Ref. 50, p. 23.
Sextus Empiricus, Adversus Physicos I, 232–233 (Heinemann, London, 1960), p. 117.
St. Augustine, Confessions (Heinemann, London, 1979), Book 7, Chap. 2.
H. Reichenbach (1958) The Philosophy of Space and Time Dover New York Occurrence Handle0084.00307
A. Grünbaum (1973) Philosophical Problems of Space and Time Reidel Dordrecht 349–355
L. Sklar (1974) Space, Time and Spacetime University of California Press Berkeley 287–294
Ref. 10, p. 461
A. Einstein (1911) ArticleTitle‘‘Einfluss der Schwerkraft auf die Ausbreitung des Lichtes’‘ Ann. Physik 35 898–908 Occurrence Handle1911AnP....35..898E
J. D. Norton (2004) ArticleTitle‘‘Einstein’s Investigations of Galilean Covariant Electrodynamics Prior to 1905’‘ Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 59 45–105 Occurrence Handle2004AHES...59...45N Occurrence Handle2104139
M. Born, ‘‘Physics and Relativity’’, Lecture delivered on 15. July 1955 at the ‘‘50 Year Jubilee of Relativity,’’ Helvetica Physica Acta, Supplementum IV, (Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel, 1956), 244–260; quotation on p. 259.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jammer, M. The Strange Story of the Concept which Inaugurated Modern Theoretical Physics. Found Phys 34, 1617–1641 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-004-1307-0
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-004-1307-0