Commentary on Allen & Kinght’s Response to the Löwdin Challenge
- 49 Downloads
This commentary provides a critical examination of a recent article by Allen and Knight in which the authors claim to provide the long-sought explanation for the Madelung, or n + ℓ, n rule for the order of orbital filling in many-electron atoms. It is concluded that the explanation is inadequate for several reasons.
KeywordsScandium Periodic Table Nodal Structure Block Element Perturbation Operator
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
I thank the reviewers for their comments and suggestions on this paper.
- Kragh H. (1977) Chemical Aspects of Bohr’s Theory. Journal of Chemical Education 54: 208–210Google Scholar
- Scerri E.R. (2003) Löwdin’s Remarks on the Aufbau Principle and a Philosopher’s View of Ab Initio Quantum Chemistry. In: Brandas E., Kryachko E. (eds) Fundamental World of Quantum Chemistry vol. II, A Tribute Volume to the Memory of Per-Olov Löwdin. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, Holland, pp. 675–694Google Scholar
- W.J. Wiswesser, Journal of Chemical Education, 22: 314–322, 370–379, 418–426, 1945Google Scholar