Anne Phillips. Multiculturalism Without Culture
- 235 Downloads
Anne Phillips’ Multiculturalism without culture is a fascinating book which grapples with the dilemmas of multiculturalism whilst staying true to an “unashamed normative commitment to the principle of equality” (p. 1).
For Phillips, the problem with attempts at multicultural theorising is twofold. Firstly, the increasing trend towards cultural relativism negates any efforts to engage meaningfully with issues of gender inequalities and oppression. Drawing upon criticisms aimed at Susan Moller Okin’s “Is multiculturalism bad for women?” (Cohen et al. 1999) she illustrates how the fear of being pigeon-holed as culturally imperialistic has resulted in a ‘paralysis’ of feminist theorising which shies away from any worthwhile normative critique of problematic, gender-based cultural practices such as female genital cutting, child marriage and patriarchal rights of unilateral divorce (p. 2). Phillips’ second concern lies with the deployment of claims of gender inequality as a means by which...
- Cohen, Joshua, Matthew Howard, and Martha Nussbaum, eds. 1999. Is multiculturalism bad for women? Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar