Advertisement

Ethical Theory and Moral Practice

, Volume 17, Issue 5, pp 971–985 | Cite as

The Case for the Moral Permissibility of Amnesties: An Argument from Social Moral Epistemology

  • Juan Espindola
Article
  • 186 Downloads

Abstract

This paper makes the case for the permissibility of post-conflict amnesties, although not on prudential grounds. It argues that amnesties of a certain scope, targeted to certain categories of perpetrators, and offered in certain contexts are morally permissible because they are an acknowledgment of the difficulty of attributing criminal responsibility in mass violence contexts. Based on this idea, the paper develops the further claim that deciding which amnesties are permissible and which ones are not should be decided on a case-by-case basis. Against what seems to be an increasingly popular assumption of some international actors, just as "blanket" amnesties (i.e. very broad and general amnesties that foreclose criminal prosecution for all kinds of perpetrators and all kinds of wrongdoing) are impermissible, so is an absolutist rejection of all types of amnesties.

Keywords

Amnesty Social moral epistemology Moral and criminal responsibility 

Notes

Acknowledgments

I would like to thank Allen Buchanan, Rainer Forst, Stephan Gosepath, Jesse Tomalty, Moises Vaca, and two anonymous reviewers for their comments on previous version of this paper. This paper was completed thanks to the generous support of the Justitia Amplificata Centre for Advanced Studies, at the University of Frankfurt; and of the Postdoctoral Fellowship program at the Institute for Social Research in the National University of Mexico.

References

  1. Appleman B (1996) Hate speech: a comparison of the approaches taken by the United States and Germany. Wis Int Law J 14:422Google Scholar
  2. Arendt H (1977) Eichmann in Jerusalem: a report on the banality of evil. Penguin, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  3. Aukerman M (2002) Extraordinary evil, ordinary crime: a framework for understanding transitional justice. Harv Hum Rights J 15:39–97Google Scholar
  4. Buchanan A (1996) Judging the past: the case of the human radiation experiments. Hast Cent Rep 26(3):25–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Buchanan A (2002) Social moral epistemology. Soc Philos Policy 19(2):126–152CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Buchanan A (2004) Political liberalism and social epistemology. Philos Public Aff 32(2):95–130CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Buchanan A (2010) Social moral epistemology and the tasks of ethics. In: Ethics and humanity: themes from the philosophy of Jonathan Glover. Oxford University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  8. Crawford N (2007) Individual and collective moral responsibility for systemic military atrocity. J Polit Philos 15(2):187–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Dworkin R (1996) Freedom’s law: the moral reading of the American constitution. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  10. Elster J (2004) Retribution. In: Retribution and reparation in the transition to democracy. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 33–56Google Scholar
  11. Estlund D (2007) On following orders in an unjust war. J Polit Philos 15(2):213–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Fitz PW (2008) Moral responsibility and normative ignorance: answering a new skeptical challenge. Ethics 118(4):589–613CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Freeman M (2009) Necessary evils: amnesties and the search for justice. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Freeman M, Pensky M (2009b) Amnesties and DDR Programs. In Disarming the Past: Transitional Justice and Ex-CombatantsGoogle Scholar
  15. Freeman M, Pensky M (2012) The amnesty controversy in international law. In: Lessa F, Payne L (eds) Amnesty in the age of human rights accountability. Comparative and international perspectives. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  16. Herman B (1993) The practice of moral judgment. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  17. Hill T Jr (2010) Moral responsibility of bystanders. J Soc Philos 41(1):28–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Holtermann J (2010) The End of ‘the end of impunity’? The International Criminal Court and the Challenge from Truth Commissions. Res Publica 16 (2) (Mai 1): 209–225. doi: 10.1007/s11158-010-9111-5
  19. Kommers D (1997) The Constitutional Jurisprudence of the Federal Republic of Germany. Duke University Press, Duke University Press. U.S.AGoogle Scholar
  20. Kutz C (2000) Complicity: Ethics and Law for a Collective Age. Cambridge University Press, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Kutz C (2004) Justice in Reparations: The Cost of Memory and the Value of Talk. Philos Public Aff 32(3):277–312CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. LaVaque-Manty M (2006) Kant’s Children. Soc Theory Pract 3:32Google Scholar
  23. Lepora C, und Robert G (2010) Complicity and Its Conceptual Cousins. http://philrsss.anu.edu.au/people-defaults/goodinb/Lepora-Goodin_Complicity_3-11-10.pdf
  24. Lessa F, Payne L (eds) (2012) Amnesty in the Age of Human Rights Accountability. Comparative and International Perspectives, Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
  25. MacKinnon C (2004) Prosecutor v. Nahimana, Barayagwiza, & Ngeze. Case No. ICTR 99-52-T. Am J Int Law 8(2):325–330CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Mallinder L (2007) Can Amnesties and International Justice be Reconciled. Int J Transit Justice 1(2):208–230CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Mallinder L (2008) Amnesty, Human Rights and Political Transitions: Bridging the Peace and Justice Divide. Hart, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  28. Mallinder L (2010) Cross-National Perspectives on Amnesties. Transitional Justice Institute - University of UlsterGoogle Scholar
  29. Masuda M, Lawrence CIII, Delgado R, Crenshaw KW (1993) Words That Wound: Critical Race Theory, Assaultive Speech, And The First Amendment. Westview Press, BoulderGoogle Scholar
  30. May L (2004) Crimes Against Humanity: A Normative Account. Cambridge University Press, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. McMahan J (2009) Killing in War. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Osiel M (1999) Obeying Orders. Atrocity, Military Discipline, and the Law of War. Transaction Publishers, New BrrunswickGoogle Scholar
  33. Osiel M (2002) Mass Atrocity, Ordinary Evil, and Hannah Arendt. Criminal Consciousness in Argentina`s Dirty War. Yale University Press, New HavenGoogle Scholar
  34. Osiel M (2009) Making Sense of Mass Atrocity. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Pauer-Studer H, Velleman JD (2011) Distortions of Normativity. Ethical Theory and Moral Pract 14(3):329–356CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Pensky M (2008) Amnesty on Trial: Impunity, Accountability, and the Norms of International Law. Ethics & Glob Polit 1(1–2):1–40Google Scholar
  37. Post R (1995) Constitutional Domains: Democracy, Community, Management. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  38. Rosen G (2003) Culpability and Ignorance. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society: 61–84.Google Scholar
  39. Ryberg J (2010) Mass Atrocities, Retributivism, and the Threshold Challenge. Res Publica 16 (2) (Mai1): 169–179. doi: 10.1007/s11158-010-9113-3
  40. Sabini J, Silver M (2005) Lack of Character? Situationism Critiqued. Ethics 115(3):535–562CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Schauer F (1993) Playing by the Rules: A Philosophical Examination of Rule-Based Decision-Making in Law and in Life. Clarendon, London, 658CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Sher G (1989) Desert. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  43. Smith H (1983) Culpable Ignorance. Philos Rev XCII(4):543–571CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Straus S (2012) Retreating from the Brink. Theorizing Mass Violence and the Dynamics of Restraint. Perspect Polit 10:3433–662CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Su Y (2011) Collective Killings in Rural China During the Cultural Revolution. Cambridge University Press, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Trumbull CP (2007) Giving Amnesties a Second Chance. Berkeley J Int Aff 25(2):283–345Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Institute for Social ResearchNational University of MexicoMexicoMexico

Personalised recommendations