Suicide is Neither Rational nor Irrational
- 401 Downloads
Richard Brandt, following Hume, famously argued that suicide could be rational. In this he was going against a common ‘absolutist’ view that suicide is irrational almost by definition. Arguments to the effect that suicide is morally permissible or prohibited tend to follow from one’s position on this first issue of rationality. I want to argue that the concept of rationality is not appropriately ascribed – or withheld – to the victim or the act or the desire to commit the act. To support this, I explore how the concept is ascribed and withheld in ordinary situations, and show that it is essentially future-oriented. Since the suicide victim has no future, it makes no sense to call his act rational or irrational. The more appropriate reaction to a declared desire for suicide, or to the news of a successful suicide, is horror and pity, and these are absent from Brandt’s account, as is a humble acknowledgement of the profound mystery at the heart of any suicide.
Key wordssuicide rationality Richard Brandt despair pity internal reasons
My thanks to Marina Barabas for the idea behind this paper.
- Battin M (1996) The death debate: Ethical issues in suicide. Prentice-Hall, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Brandt R (1975) The morality and rationality of suicide. In Perlin S (Ed) A handbook for the study of suicide. Oxford University Press, Oxford (reprinted as ‘The rationality of suicide’)Google Scholar
- Cavell S (1979) The claim of reason. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Clark B (1989) Whose life is it anyway? In Speakerman (Ed) Heinemann, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Diamond C (1991) Anything by argument? In The realistic spirit. MIT, BostonGoogle Scholar
- Joyce J (1996) Dubliners. Penguin Popular Classics, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Williams B (1981) Internal and external reasons. In Moral luck. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UKGoogle Scholar
- Winch P (1972) Moral integrity. In Ethics and action. Macmillan, LondonGoogle Scholar