, Volume 79, Issue 5, pp 1069–1076 | Cite as

Is Knowledge True Belief Plus Adequate Information?



In When is True Belief Knowledge? (2012) Richard Foley proposes an original and strikingly simple theory of knowledge: a subject S knows some proposition p if and only if S truly believes that p and does not lack any important information. If this view is correct, Foley allegedly solves a wide variety of epistemological problems, such as the Gettier problem, the lottery paradox, the so-called ‘value problem’, and the problem of skepticism. However, a central component of his view is that whether a true belief counts as knowledge depends on the importance of the information that one has or lacks. My paper raises doubts about whether there is a non-circular way to distinguish important information from unimportant information. I argue that there is no way to distinguish important information from unimportant information without ultimately making reference to knowledge; thus, Foley’s new theory of knowledge does not achieve its goals.


True Belief Virtue Epistemologist Missing Truth Epistemic Goal Human Concern 



I am grateful to Nathan Ballantyne, Chris Cowie, Helen Marsh, and the audience at the Edinburgh Epistemology Conference in 2013. This paper was written while I was funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.


  1. Foley, R. (2012). When is true belief knowledge?. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  2. James, W. (1896). The will to believe. New World, 5, 327–347.Google Scholar
  3. Kelly, T. Forthcoming. How to be an epistemic permissivist. In M. Steup and J. Turri (Eds.) Contemporary Debates in Epistemology.Google Scholar
  4. Littlejohn, C. (2012). Review: When is true belief knowledge? Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews.Google Scholar
  5. Williams, B. (1973). Deciding to believe. In Williams (Ed.) Problems of the Self. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of PhilosophyFordham UniversityBronxUSA

Personalised recommendations