Dream Skepticism and the Conditionality Problem
- 141 Downloads
Recently, Ernest Sosa (2007) has proposed two novel solutions to the problem of dream skepticism. In the present paper, I argue that Sosa’s first solution falls prey to what I will refer to as the conditionality problem, i.e., the problem of only establishing a conditional—in this case, “if x, then I am awake,” x being a placeholder for a condition incompatible with dreaming—in a context where it also needs to be established that we can know that the antecedent holds, and as such can infer the consequent, i.e., “I am awake.” Sosa’s second solution, in terms of so-called reflective knowledge, is shown to land him in the dilemma of either facing yet another conditionality problem, or violating an internalist constraint that he explicitly grants the skeptic with respect to what kind of factors can be legitimately invoked in our account of how we may know the relevant antecedent. For these reasons, I conclude that Sosa has not solved the problem of dream skepticism.
KeywordsTrue Belief Imagination Model Perceptual Belief Animal Knowledge Internalist Constraint
The author would like to express his deep gratitude to Hilary Kornblith, Louise Antony, and two anonymous referees for this journal for valuable feedback on previous versions of this paper. Research underlying the present paper was conducted with generous support from the Fornander Foundation and the Hagendahl Commemoration Fund.
- Descartes, R. (1984/1641). Meditations on first philosophy. In J .Cottingham, R. Stoothoff & D. Murdoch (Eds.), The philosophical writings of descartes (vol. 2). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Hobson, J. A. (1999). Dreaming as delirium: How the brain goes out of its mind. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Putnam, H. (1981). Reason, truth and history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Stroud, B. (1989). Understanding human knowledge in general. In M. Clay & K. Lehrer (Eds.), Knowledge and skepticism (pp. 31–50). Boulder: Westview.Google Scholar
- Williams, B. (1978). Descartes: The project of pure inquiry. London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar