# Mathematics lectures as narratives: insights from network graph methodology

- 419 Downloads
- 2 Citations

## Abstract

Although lecture is the traditional method of university mathematics instruction, there has been little empirical research that describes the general structure of lectures. In this paper, we adapt ideas from narrative analysis and apply them to an upper-level mathematics lecture. We develop a framework that enables us to conceptualize the lecture as consisting of collections of narratives to identify connections between the narratives and to use the narrative structure to identify key features of the lecture. In particular, we use the idea of framing and embedded narratives to identify central ideas in the lecture and to understand how examples, diagrams, and smaller claims contribute to the development of those ideas. Additionally, we create a graph structure for the lecture using the repetition of mathematical ideas across embedded narratives, and we employ graph-theoretic analysis to support our identification of framing narratives and to highlight particular roles of embedded narratives.

## Keywords

Narrative analysis Lecture Abstract algebra Graph theory## References

- Abbott, H. P. (2008).
*The Cambridge introduction to narrative*. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Andrà, C. (2013). How do students understand mathematical lectures? Note-taking as retelling of the teacher’s story.
*For the Learning of Mathematics, 33*(2), 18–23.Google Scholar - Artemeva, N., & Fox, J. (2011). The writing’s on the board: The global and the local in teaching undergraduate mathematics through chalk talk.
*Written Communication, 28*(4), 345–379.Google Scholar - Bal, M. (2009).
*Narratology: Introduction to the theory of narrative*(3rd ed., C. Van Boheemen, Trans.). Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar - Bowers, J. S., & Nickerson, S. (2001). Identifying cyclic patterns of interaction to study individual and collective learning.
*Mathematical Thinking and Learning, 3*(1), 1–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Bressoud, D., Mesa, V., & Rasmussen, C. (Eds.). (2015).
*Insights and recommendations from the MAA National Study of College Calculus*(MAA Notes). Washington, DC: Mathematical Association of America.Google Scholar - Brooks, P. (1992).
*Reading for the plot: Design and intention in narrative*. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar - Bruner, J. (1990).
*Acts of meaning*. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar - Childs, P., & Fowler, R. (2006).
*The Routledge dictionary of literary terms*. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar - Clauset, A. (2005). Finding local community structure in networks.
*Physical Review E, 72*(2), 026132.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Coulter, C. A., & Smith, M. L. (2009). The construction zone: Literary elements in narrative research.
*Educational Researcher, 38*, 577–590.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Crossley, M., & Vulliamy, G. (1997).
*Qualitative educational research in developing countries*. New York, NY: Garland.Google Scholar - Cuoco, A., Goldenberg, E. P., & Mark, J. (1996). Habits of mind: An organizing principle for a mathematics curriculum.
*The Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 15*(4), 375–402.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Czarniawska, B. (2004).
*Narratives in social science research*. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - de Freitas, E. (2012). The diagram as story: Unfolding the event-structure of the mathematical diagram.
*For the Learning of Mathematics, 32*(2), 27–33.Google Scholar - Dietiker, L. (2013). Mathematical texts as narrative: Rethinking curriculum.
*For the Learning of Mathematics, 33*(3), 14–19.Google Scholar - Emden, C. (1998). Conducting a narrative analysis.
*Collegian, 5*(3), 34–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Freeman, L. C., Borgatti, S. P., & White, D. R. (1991). Centrality in valued graphs: A measure of betweenness based on network flow.
*Social Networks, 13*(2), 141–154.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Fukawa-Connelly, T. P. (2012). A case study of one instructor’s lecture-based teaching of proof in abstract algebra: Making sense of her pedagogical moves.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 81*, 325–345.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Gansner, E. R., Koutsofios, E., North, S. C., & Vo, K. P. (1993). A technique for drawing directed graphs.
*IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering, 19*(3), 214–230.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Gerofsky, S. (1996). Selling mathematics: The language of persuasion in an introductory calculus course. In L. Puig & A. Gutierrez (Eds.),
*Proceedings of the 1996 Meeting: Psychology of Mathematics Education*(pp. 409–417). Valencia, Spain: University of Valencia.Google Scholar - Güçler, B. (2013). Examining the discourse on the limit concept in a beginning-level calculus classroom.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 82*, 439–453.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Hannah, J., Stewart, S., & Thomas, M. (2011). Analysing lecturer practice: The role of orientations and goals.
*International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 42*(7), 975–984.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Holley, K., & Coylar, J. (2012). Under construction: How narrative elements shape qualitative research.
*Theory Into Practice, 51*(2), 114–121.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Holley, K. A., & Colyar, J. (2009). Rethinking texts: Narrative and the construction of qualitative research.
*Educational Researcher 38*(9), 680–686.Google Scholar - Hora, M. T., & Ferrare, J. J. (2013). Instructional systems of practice: A multidimensional analysis of math and science undergraduate course planning and classroom teaching.
*The Journal of the Learning Sciences, 22*(2), 212–257.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Juzwik, M. (2006). Situating narrative-minded research: A commentary on Anna Sfard and Anna Prusak’s “telling identities”.
*Educational Researcher, 35*(9), 13–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Kleinberg, J. (1999). Authoritative sources in a hyperlinked environment.
*Journal of the ACM, 46*(5), 604–632.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Labov, W. (1972).
*Language in the inner city*. Philadelphia: Univ. of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar - Margolin, U. (2012). Mathematics and narrative: A narratological perspective. In A. K. Doxiádis & B. Mazur (Eds.),
*Circles disturbed: The interplay of mathematics and narrative*(pp. 481–507). Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar - Mark, J., Cuoco, A., Goldenberg, E. P., & Sword, S. (2010). Contemporary curriculum issues: Developing mathematical habits of mind.
*Mathematics Teaching in the Middle School, 15*(9), 505–509.Google Scholar - Mills, M. (2012, February). Investigating the teaching practices of professors when presenting proofs: The use of examples. In S. Brown, S. Larsen, K. Marrongelle, & M. Oehrtman (Eds.),
*Proceedings of the 15th Conference for Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education*(pp. 512–516). Portland, OR: Portland State University.Google Scholar - Mishler, E. G. (1986).
*Research interviewing: Context and narrative*. London: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar - Movshovitz-Hadar, N., & Hazzan, O. (2004). The rhetoric of an outstanding lecturer or how to present it?
*International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 35*(6), 813–827.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM). (2000).
*Principles and standards for school mathematics*. Reston, VA: Author.Google Scholar - National Governors Association Center for Best Practices & Council of Chief State School Officers. (2010).
*Common core state standards*. Washington, DC: Authors.Google Scholar - Netz, R. (2005). The aesthetics of mathematics: A study. In P. Mancosu, K. F. Jørgensen, & S. A. Pedersen (Eds.),
*Visualization, explanation and reasoning styles in mathematics*(pp. 251–293). Dordrecht: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Palmer, A. (2004).
*Fictional minds*. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.Google Scholar - Paterson, J., Thomas, M., & Taylor, S. (2011). Decisions, decisions, decisions: What determines the path taken in lectures?
*International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 42*(7), 985–995.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Pemberton, J., Devaney, R., Hilborn, R., Moses, Y., Neuhauser, C., Taylor, T., et al. (2004).
*Undergraduate education in the mathematical and physical sciences: Interim report of the Joint Subcommittee of the NSF Education and Human Resources and Mathematical and Physical Sciences Advisory Committees*. Washington DC: National Science Foundation. Retrieved from http://www.nsf.gov/attachments/102806/public/JSACInterimReportEHR-MPSSpring2004.pdf - Polkinghorne, D. E. (1988).
*Narrative knowing and the human sciences*. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar - Potter, J. (1996).
*Representing reality: Discourse, rhetoric, and social construction*. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Riessman, C. K. (2005). Narrative analysis. In
*Narrative, memory & everyday life*(pp. 1–7). Huddersfield: University of Huddersfield.Google Scholar - Ryan, M. (1991).
*Possible worlds, artificial intelligence and narrative theory*(p. 1991). Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar - Seaman, C. E., & Szydlik, J. E. (2007). Mathematical sophistication among preservice elementary teachers.
*Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education, 10*, 167–182.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Smith, M. (2010). Engaging characters: Further reflection. In J. Eder, F. Jannidis, & R. Schneider (Eds.),
*Characters in fictional worlds. Understanding imaginary beings in literature, film, and other media*(pp. 232–258). New York: De Gruyter.Google Scholar - Solomon, Y., & O’Neill, J. (1998). Mathematics and narrative.
*Language and Education, 12*(3), 210–221.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Speer, N., Smith, J., & Horvath, A. (2010). Collegiate mathematics teaching: An unexamined practice.
*The Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 29*, 99–114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Thomas, R. S. D. (2002). Mathematics and narrative.
*The Mathematical Intelligencer, 24*(3), 43–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Tsay, J. J., Judd, A. B., Hauk, S., & Davis, M. K. (2011). Case study of a college mathematics instructor: Patterns of classroom discourse.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 78*(2), 205–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Weber, K. (2004). Traditional instruction in advanced mathematics classrooms: A case study of one professor’s lectures and proofs in an introductory real analysis course.
*The Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 23*, 115–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Weinberg, A., Fukawa-Connelly, T., & Wiesner, E. (2015). Characterizing instructor gestures in a lecture in a proof-based mathematics class.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics*. Advance Online Publication. doi: 10.1007/s10649-015-9623-1.Google Scholar - Wood, L., Joyce, S., Petosz, P., & Rodd, M. (2007). Learning in lectures: Multiple representations.
*International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 38*(7), 907–915.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Wood, L., & Smith, G. (2004).
*Language of University Mathematics*. Paper presented at the 10th International Congress on Mathematical Education, Topic Study Group 25.Google Scholar