Alternative Interpretation of the Dataset on K-12 Calculator Usage and College Grades as Analysed by Wilson and Naiman (2003, 2004)
- 70 Downloads
The short communication on ‘K-12 Calculator Usage and College Grades’ by Wilson and Naiman (2004) reports that ‘there is a (negative) connection between’ college mathematics grades at Johns Hopkins University and heavy calculator usage in K-12' (p. 121). This response argues that such a conclusion risks oversimplifying the situation examined; evidence from an earlier version of the report suggests that the multi-course dataset is non-homogeneous, and that a correspondingly less generalised conclusion would be more appropriate. This response also notes some other limitations of the mechanism of comparison employed.
KeywordsShort Communication Alternative Interpretation College Mathematics Calculator Usage Heavy Calculator
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Wilson, S.W. and Naiman, D.Q.: 2003, ‘Effect of K-12 calculator usage on college grades’, Unpublished paper accessed at http://www.math.jhu.edu/~wsw/ED/calc.pdf on 28 June 2005.