Advertisement

Environmental Biology of Fishes

, Volume 94, Issue 1, pp 285–310 | Cite as

Strategies for reducing the ecological risks of hatchery programs: Case studies from the Pacific Northwest

  • Kathryn Kostow
Article

Abstract

The Pacific Northwest state and federal agencies and tribes that operate salmon and steelhead (Oncorhynchus sp.) hatcheries are authorized to develop and implement strategies to reduce the risks the programs pose to wild fish populations. This paper reviews five case studies from the states of Oregon and Washington, USA, where agencies and tribes have implemented or proposed programs that were intended to reduce ecological risks due to hatchery programs. The case studies are for Oregon coho salmon, Select Area terminal fisheries programs for Chinook and coho salmon in the lower Columbia River, Hood Canal chum salmon in Puget Sound Washington, Siletz River steelhead on the Oregon coast, and Okanogan River Chinook salmon in eastern Washington. The five case studies address a diversity of management objectives and species. They demonstrate some of the science and risk reduction strategies used to alleviate the ecological effects of hatcheries, and they document some of the results and outcomes of taking action. Elements of four of the case studies have been in place for nearly 20 years. The available science and the conservation ethic toward hatchery programs evolved significantly over this period, and management decisions and strategies have been influenced by public policy as well as by scientific information. Therefore the case studies also document some of the history, the evolution of ideas, the uncertainty, and the political controversy associated with the management of this risk factor. The paper concludes with six principles to help guide the development of future risk reduction programs.

Keywords

Hatchery Ecological risk Salmon and steelhead Risk reduction 

Notes

Acknowledgements

I would like to thank the following persons for assisting with the preparation of this paper by providing data and other information, and by offering helpful discussion and reviews: Shari Beals, Berry Berejikian, Bob Buckman, Douglas DeHart, Craig Foster, Patti Goldman, Kevin Goodson, Thom Johnson, Mark Lewis, John North, Steve Sanders, Michael Schmidt, Steve Smith, Tom Stahl, Tim Tynan, Chris Weller, Jeff Whisler, and Derek Wilson. I would also like to thank the Wild Salmon Center and Todd Pearsons for inviting me to participate in their 2010 conference on Ecological Interactions between Wild and Hatchery Salmon.

References

  1. Ames J, Graves G, Weller C (eds) (2000) Summer Chum Salmon conservation initiative: an implementation plan to recover summer chum in the Hood Canal and Strait of Juan de Fuca region. WDFW and PNPTT, Olympia WA, p 797Google Scholar
  2. Araki H, Berejikian BA, Ford MJ, Blouin MS (2008) Fitness of hatchery-reared salmonids in the wild. Evol Apps 1:342–355CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bartholomew JL, Reno PW (2002) The history and dissemination of whirling disease. In Bartholomew JL and Wilson JC (eds) Whirling Disease: Reviews and Current Topics. Am Fish Soc Symp 29:3–24Google Scholar
  4. Berejikian B (1995) The effect of hatchery and wild ancestry and experience on the relative ability of steelhead trout fry (Oncorhynchus mykiss) to avoid a benthic predator. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 52:2476–2482CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Berejikian BA, Ford MJ (2004) Review of the Relative Fitness of Hatchery and Natural Salmon. US Dept. Commer, NOAA Tech Memo NMFS-NWFSC-61, p 28Google Scholar
  6. Berejikian BA, Van Doornik DM, Scheurer JA, Bush R (2009) Reproductive behavior and relative reproductive success of natural- and hatchery-origin Hood Canal summer chum salmon (Oncorhynchus keta). Can J Fish Aquat Sci 66:781–789CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Blumm MC (2002) Sacrificing the Salmon: a legal and policy history of the decline of Columbia Basin Salmon. Book World Publications Den Bosch, The NetherlandsGoogle Scholar
  8. Bottom DL, Simenstad CA, Burke J, Baptista AM, Jay DA, Jones KK, Casillas E, Schiewe MH (2005) Salmon at river’s end: the role of the estuary in the decline and recovery of Columbia River salmon. US Dept. Commer, NOAA Tech Memo NMFS-NWFSC-68, p 246Google Scholar
  9. Brannon EL, Amend DF, Cronin MA, Lannan JE, LaPatra S, McNeil WJ, Mobel RE, Smith CE, Talbot AJ, Wedemeyer GA, Westers H (2004) The controversy about salmon hatcheries. Fisheries 29:12–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Buhle ER, Holsman KK, Scheuerell MD, Albaugh A (2009) Using an unplanned experiment to evaluate the effects of hatcheries and environmental variation on threatened populations of wild salmon. Biol Con 142:2449–2455CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Busby PJ, Wainwright TC, Bryant GJ, Lierheimer LJ, Waples RS, Waknitz FW, Lagomarsino IV (1996) Status Review of West Coast Steelhead from Washington, Idaho, Oregon and California. US Dept. Commer, NOAA Tech Memo NMFS-NWFSC-27, p 261Google Scholar
  12. Chilton G (2009) Fish Propagation Annual Report for 2008. ODFW, Salem OR, p 135Google Scholar
  13. Collis K, Beaty RE, Crain BR (1995) Changes in catch rate and diet of northern squawfish associated with the release of hatchery-reared juvenile salmonids in a Columbia River reservoir. N Am J Fish Manag 15:346–357CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation (CTCR) (2004) Chief Joseph Dam hatchery program master plan. CTRC, Nespelem WA,p 183Google Scholar
  15. Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation (CTCR) (2009) Chief Joseph hatchery program monitoring and evaluation plan for summer/fall Chinook Salmon. CTRC, Nespelem WA, p 108Google Scholar
  16. Craig JA, Hacker RL (1940) The history and development of the fisheries of the Columbia River. Bull Bureau Fish No 32, Washington DC, p 216Google Scholar
  17. Emlen JM, Reisenbichler RR, McGie AM, Nickelson TE (1990) Density-dependence at sea for coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch). Can J Fish Aquat Sci 47:1765–1772CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Flagg TA, Waknitz FW, Maynard DJ, Milner GB, Mahnken CVW (1995) The effect of hatcheries on native coho salmon populations in the lower Columbia River. In: Schramm HL, Piper RG (eds) Uses and Effects of Cultured Fishes in Aquatic Ecosystems. Am Fish Soc Symp 15:366–375Google Scholar
  19. Fleming IA, Jonsson B, Gross MR (1994) Phenotypic divergence of sea-ranched, farmed, and wild salmon. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 51:2808–2824CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Fraser DJ (2008) How well can captive breeding programs conserve biodiversity? A review of salmonids. Evol Apps 1:535–586Google Scholar
  21. Hargreaves NB, LeBrasseur RJ (1986) Size selectivity of coho (Oncorhynchus kisutch) preying on juvenile chum (O. keta) salmon. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 43:581–586CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Hawkins SW, Tipping JM (1999) Predation by juvenile hatchery salmonids on wild fall Chinook salmon fry in the Lewis River, Washington. Cal Fish and Game 85:124–129Google Scholar
  23. Hindar K, Ryman N, Utter F (1991) Genetic effects of cultured fish on natural fish populations. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 48:945–957CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Hunter JG (1959) Survival and production of pink and chum salmon in a coastal stream. J Fish Res Bd Can 16:835–886CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Johnsen BO, Jensen AJ (1986) Infestations of Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar by Gyrodactylus salaries in Norwegian rivers. J Fish Biol 29:233–241CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Johnson OW, Flagg TA, Maynard DJ, Milner GB, Waknitz FW (1991) Status review for lower Columbia River Coho Salmon. US Dept Commer, NOAA Tech Memo NMFS F/NWC-202, p 94Google Scholar
  27. Johnson OW, Grant WS, Kope RG, Neely K, Waknitz FW, Waples RS (1997) Status review of Chum Salmon from Washington, Oregon, and California. US Dept Commer, NOAA Tech Memo NMFS-NWFSC-32, p 280Google Scholar
  28. Johnson SL (1984) Freshwater environmental problems and coho production in Oregon. Fish Info Rept 84–11. ODFW, Corvallis OR, p 34Google Scholar
  29. Kostow K (1995) Biennial Report on the status of wild fish in Oregon. ODFW, Clackamas OR, p 213Google Scholar
  30. Kostow K (1997) The status of salmon and steelhead in Oregon. In: Stouder DJ, Bisson PA, Naiman RJ (eds) Pacific Salmon and their ecosystems: status and future options. Chapman and Hall, New York, pp 145–178CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Kostow K (2009) Factors that contribute to the ecological risks of salmon and steelhead hatchery programs and some mitigating strategies. Rev Fish Biol Fish 19:9–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Kostow KE, Zhou S (2006) The effect of an introduced summer steelhead hatchery stock on the productivity of a wild winter steelhead population. Trans Am Fish Soc 135:825–841CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Krkosek M, Lewis MA, Volpe JP (2005) Transmission dynamics of parasitic sea lice from farm to wild salmon. Proc R Soc Ser B Biol Sci 272:6898–696CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Leider SA, Hulett PL, Loch JJ, Chilcote MW (1990) Electrophoretic comparison of the reproductive success of naturally spawning transplanted and wild steelhead trout through the returning adult stage. Aquacul 88:239–252CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Lichatowich JA (1999) Salmon without rivers: a history of the Pacific Salmon crisis. Island, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  36. Lichatowich JA, McIntyre JD (1987) Use of hatcheries in the management of Pacific anadromous salmonids. Am Fish Soc Symp 1:131–136Google Scholar
  37. McGie AM (1980) Analysis of relationships between hatchery coho salmon transplants and adult escapements in coastal watersheds. Fish Info Rept 80–6. ODFW, Corvallis OR, p 19Google Scholar
  38. McGie AM (1984) Commentary: Evidence for density dependence among coho salmon stocks in the Oregon Production Index area. In Pearcy WG (ed) The influence of ocean conditions on the production of salmonids in the North Pacific. Oregon State University Sea Grant Publ, pp 37–49Google Scholar
  39. Myers RA, Levin SA, Lande R, James FC, Murdoch WW, Paines RT (2004) Hatcheries and endangered salmon. Science 303:1980PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Naish KA, Taylor JE, Levin PS, Quinn TP, Winton JR, Huppert D, Hilborn R (2008) An evaluation of the effects of conservation and fishery enhancement hatcheries on wild populations of Salmon. Adv Mar Bio 53:61–194CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) (2008) Endangered species Act Section 7(a)(2) consultation, biological opinion and Magnuson-Stevens fishery conservation and management act essential fish habitat consultation: consultation on treaty Indian and Non-Indian fisheries in the Columbia River Basin subject to the 2008–2017 US v. Oregon Management Agreement. NMFS, Seattle WA, p 685Google Scholar
  42. Nehlsen W, Williams JE, Lichatowich JA (1991) Pacific salmon at the crossroads: Stocks at risk from California, Oregon, Idaho and Washington. Fisheries 16:4–21Google Scholar
  43. Nickelson T (2003) The influence of hatchery coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) on the productivity of wild coho salmon populations in Oregon coastal basins. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 60:1050–1056CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Nickleson TE, Solazzi MF, Johnson SL (1986) Use of hatchery coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) presmolts to rebuild wild populations in Oregon coastal streams. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 43:2443–2449CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Nielsen JL (1994) Invasive cohorts: Impacts of hatchery-reared coho salmon on the trophic, developmental, and genetic ecology of wild stocks. In: Stouder DJ, Fresh KL, Feller R (eds) Theory and Application in Fish Feeding Ecology. USC Belle Baruch Press Columbia, pp 361–385Google Scholar
  46. North J, Miller M, Sewall J, Jones T, Dietrichs A, Miethe T (2006) Select Area Fishery Evaluation Project: 1993–2005 Final Project Completion Report. US Depart Energy, BPA, Portland OR, p 152Google Scholar
  47. Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (ODFW) (1982) Comprehensive plan for production and management of Oregon’s anadromous salmon and trout, part 2. Coho salmon plan considerations. ODFW, Portland OR, p 189Google Scholar
  48. Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (ODFW) (1998) Siletz River basin fish management plan. ODFW, Salem OR, p 126Google Scholar
  49. Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (ODFW) (2001) Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife’s endangered species management plan for lower Columbia Coho Salmon. ODFW, Salem OR, p 47Google Scholar
  50. Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (ODFW) (2007) Oregon Coast Coho conservation plan for the State of Oregon. ODFW, Salem OR, p 63Google Scholar
  51. Pacific Fishery Management Council (PFMC) (1999) Final amendment 13 to the Pacific Coast Salmon plan: fishery management regime to ensure protection and rebuilding of Oregon coastal natural coho. PFMC, Portland OR, p 84Google Scholar
  52. Parker RR (1971) Size selective predation among juvenile salmonid fishes in a British Columbia inlet. J Fish Res Bd Can 28:1503–1510CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Pearcy WG (1997) Salmon production in changing ocean domains. In: Stouder DJ, Bisson PA, Naiman RJ (eds) Pacific Salmon and their ecosystems: status and future options. Chapman and Hall, New York, pp 331–352CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Reisenbichler RR (1988) Relation between distance transferred from natal stream and recovery rate for hatchery coho salmon. N Am J Fish Manag 8:172–174CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Reisenbichler RR, McIntyre JD (1977) Genetic differences in growth and survival of juvenile hatchery and wild steelhead trout, Salmo gairdneri. J Fish Res Bd Can 34:123–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Ryman N, Laikre L (1991) Effects of supportive breeding on the genetically effective population size. Con Biol 5:325–329CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Sands NJ, Rawson K, Currens KP, Graeber WH, Ruckelshaus MH, Fuerstenberg RR, Scott JB (2009) Determination of independent populations and viability criteria for the Hood Canal summer chum salmon evolutionarily significant unit. US Dept Commer, NOAA Tech Memo NMFS-NWFSC-101, p 58Google Scholar
  58. Taylor JE (1999) Making Salmon: an environmental history of the northwest fisheries crisis. University of Washington Press, SeattleGoogle Scholar
  59. Wallis J (1963) An evaluation of the Siletz River Salmon Hatchery. Oregon Fish Commission, Clackamas OR, p 41Google Scholar
  60. Waples RS (1991) Genetic interactions between hatchery and wild salmonids: lessons from the Pacific Northwest. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 48:124–133CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW), Western Washington Treaty Tribes (WWTIT) (1993) 1992 Washington State Salmon and Steelhead Stock Inventory. WDFW, Olympia WA, p 212Google Scholar
  62. Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW), Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (ODFW) (2002) Status Report: Columbia River Fish Runs and Fisheries: 1938–2000. ODFW, Clackamas OR, p 324Google Scholar
  63. Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW), Point No Point Treaty Tribes (PNPTT) (2007) Five-year review of the Summer Chum Salmon Conservation Initiative: Supplemental Report No. 7, Summer Chum Salmon Conservation Initiative – An Implementation Plan to Recover Summer Chum in the Hood Canal and Strait of Juan de Fuca Region. WDFW, Olympia WA, p 235Google Scholar
  64. Weber WG, Fortune JD (1974) Siletz summer steelhead study. Oregon Wildlife Commission, Portland OR, p 121Google Scholar
  65. Weitkamp LA, Wainwright TC, Bryant GJ, Milner GB, Teel TJ, Kope RG, Waples RS (1995) Status Review of Coho Salmon from Washington, Oregon and California. US Dept Commer, NOAA Tech Memo NMFS-NWFSC-24, p 258Google Scholar
  66. Whisler G, Gale G, Hulett P, Wilson J, Meshke S, Dietrichs A, Miethe T (2009) Select area fishery enhancement project, FY 2007–08 Annual Report. US Depart Energy, BPA, Portland OR, p 103Google Scholar
  67. Willis MJ (1979) Out-system transfers of coho salmon stocks in coastal river systems. Fish Info Rept 79–9. ODFW, Corvallis OR, p 12Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Oregon Department of Fish and WildlifeClackamasUSA

Personalised recommendations