Environmental and Resource Economics

, Volume 32, Issue 4, pp 533–550 | Cite as

Stochastic Dominance Analysis of Soil and Water Conservation in Subsistence Crop Production in the Eastern Ethiopian Highlands: The Case of the Hunde-Lafto Area

  • Wagayehu Bekele


The aim of this paper is to analyze whether investment in soil and water conservation results in a higher yield and income and/or mitigate variability in yield and income to subsistence farm households in the Hunde-Lafto area. Net returns from crop production with and without soil and water conservation (SWC) are compared based on stochastic dominance (SD) criteria. A non-parametric first order SD and normalized second order are used for data analysis. Analysis is based on the Soil Conservation Research Program (SCRP) database for the Hunde-Lafto research unit. The results of the analysis suggest that adopting a conservation strategy results in higher grain yield and net return than in not adopting. The normalized second order SD analysis results do not support the hypothesis that conservation strategy is unambiguously better than a noconservation strategy in reducing variability in yield and net return to farmers. However, conservation strategy has shown second order dominance at lower levels of yield and income that often correspond to unfavorable rainfall conditions. This makes it a preferred strategy to cope with the most prevalent risk factor of moisture shortage. Therefore, appropriate policies to help and encourage farmers to adopt SWC structures will contribute to improving the welfare of subsistence farm households in the study area and in other similar settings in the country. Designing and implementing SWC techniques that may result in unambiguous second order SD dominance will further improve the desirability and adoption of conservation measures.


erosion Ethiopia net return soil and water conservation stochastic dominance 

JEL classifications

Q24 renewable resources and conservation 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Admassie, Y. 1995Twenty Years to Nowhere. Property Rights, Land Management, and Conservation in EthiopiaUppsala UniversitySwedenPh.D. ThesisGoogle Scholar
  2. Blaike, P. 1985The Political Economy of Soil Erosion in Developing CountriesLongman Development StudiesNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  3. Blaike, P., Brookfield, H. 1987Land Degradation and SocietyMethuen & Co. LtdLondonGoogle Scholar
  4. Bojo, J. (1992), ‘Cost-Benefit Analysis of Soil and Water Conservation Projects: A Review of 20 Empirical Studies’, in K. Tato and H. Hurni, eds., Soil Conservation for Survival: A Reviewed Selection of Papers Presented at the International Soil Conservation Conference in Ethiopia/Kenya, 1989. Soil and Water Conservation Society (SWCS).Google Scholar
  5. Bono, R. and W. Seiler (1983), The Soils of the Suke-Hararghe Research Unit (Ethiopia): Classification, Morphology and Ecology, SCRP Research Report 2Google Scholar
  6. Chichilnisky, G. 1997‘The Costs and Benefits of Benefit-Cost Analysis’Environmental and Development Economics2202206CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Clark, R. 1996Methodologies for the Economic Analysis of Soil Erosion and ConservationUniversity of AngliaNorwichCSERGE working paper GEC 96-13, Overseas Development GroupGoogle Scholar
  8. CSA (1988, 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995), Average Retail Prices of Goods and Services in Rural Areas by Region, Statistical Bulletin Numbers 57, 83, 93, 96, 106, 107, 115, 117, 124, 143, Addis-Ababa, Ethiopia.Google Scholar
  9. Graaff, J. 1996The Price of Soil Erosion: An Economic Evaluation of Soil Conservation and Watershed DevelopmentWageningen Agricultural Universitythe NetherlandsPh.D. ThesisGoogle Scholar
  10. Eckholm, E. P. 1976Losing Ground: Environmental Stress and World Food ProspectsUnited Nations Environmental Program and Worldwatch Institute, Norton and CopNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  11. Ekbom, A. 1995 The Economics of Soil Conservation: A Case Study of the Economic and Agro-Ecological Implications of Soil Conservation on Maize Cultivation in Muranga District, KenyaGothenburg UniversitySwedenEnvironmental Economics Unit at Department of Economics, Working paper No. 2Google Scholar
  12. Enters, T. 1998Methodologies for the Economic Assessment of the On- and Off-site Impacts of Soil ErosionInternational Board for Soil Research and ManagementBangkok Issue in sustainable management no. 2Google Scholar
  13. Formby, P. J., Smith, J. W., Zheng, B. 1999‘The Coefficient of Variation, Stochastic Dominance and Inequality: A New Approach’Economic Letters62319323CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Greene, W. H. 2003Econometric Analysis5Prentice-Hall International Inc.USAGoogle Scholar
  15. Hoben, A. 1996‘The Cultural Construction of Environmental Policy: Paradigms & Policies in Ethiopia’Leach, Mearns,  eds. The Lie of the Land: Challenging Received Wisdom on the African EnvironmentThe International African InstituteLondonGoogle Scholar
  16. Hurni, H. 1988‘Degradation and Conservation of the Resources in the Ethiopian Highlands’Mountain Research and Development8123130Google Scholar
  17. Hurni, H. (1993), ‘Land Degradation, Famine, and Land Resource Scenarios in Ethiopia’, in D. Pimentel, ed., World Soil Erosion and Conservation. Cambridge Studies in Applied Ecology and Resource Management.Google Scholar
  18. Klemme, R. M. 1985‘A Stochastic Dominance Comparison of Reduced Tillage Systems in Corn and Soybean Production Under Risk’American Journal of Agricultural Economics67550557Google Scholar
  19. Mas-Collel, A., Whinston, M. D., Green, J. R. 1995Microeconomic TheoryOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  20. Oriade, C. A., Dillon, C. R., Keisling, T. C. 1999‘Economics of Wheat Reduced Management in Double Crop Soybean’Journal of Production Agriculture124248Google Scholar
  21. Post, T. (2002), Empirical test for stochastic dominance Efficiency,’ referred on December 4, 2002
  22. Rockstrom, J., J. Barron and P. Fox (2001), Rainwater Management for Increased Productivity Among Smallholders in Drought Prone Environments, paper presented on 2nd WARFSA/Waternet integrated water resource management: Theory, Practice, cases: Cape Town, pp 319–330.Google Scholar
  23. Schlafli, K. (1985), Land Use, Production and Land Distribution in the Agucho Valley. Ethiopia, SCRP Research Paper 11Google Scholar
  24. Shiferaw, B., Holden, T. S. 1998‘Resource Degradation and Adoption of Land Conservation Technologies in the Highlands of Ethiopia: A Case Study of Andit Tid, North Sheawa’Agricultural Economics18233247CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Shively, G. E. 1999‘Risk and Returns from Soil Conservation: Evidence from Low-Income Farms in the Philippines’Agricultural Economics215367CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Shively, G. E. 2000Soil ‘Conservation and Risk in a Model of Low-Income Agriculture’Environmental Monitoring and Assessment625569CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Soil Conservation Research Program (SCRP)1996Database Report (1982–1993), Series III: Hunde-Lafto Research UnitUniversity of Berne in Association with the Ministry of AgricultureEthiopiaGoogle Scholar
  28. Tolcha, T. (1991), Aspects of Soil Degradation and Conservation Measures in Agucho Catchments, SCRP Research Report 19Google Scholar
  29. Weersink, A., Walker, M., Swanton, C., Shaw, J. 1992‘Economic Comparison of Alternative Tillage Systems Under Risk’Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics40199217Google Scholar
  30. Williams, J. R. 1988A Stochastic Dominance Analysis of Tillage and Crop Insurance Practices in Semi Arid Regions’American Journal of Agricultural Economics70112120Google Scholar
  31. Yiridoe, E. K., Weersink, A., Hooker, D. C., Vyn, T. J., Swanton, C. 2000‘Income Risk Analysis of Alternative Tillage Systems for Corn and Soybean Production on Clay Soil’Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics48161174 special issueGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Agricultural Economics, College of AgricultureAlemaya UniversityDire-DawaEthiopia

Personalised recommendations