Advertisement

Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 85, Issue 4, pp 501–514 | Cite as

Are Ethical Codes of Conduct Toothless Tigers for Dealing with Employment Discrimination?

  • Lars-Eric PetersenEmail author
  • Franciska Krings
Article

Abstract

This study examined the influence of two organizational context variables, codes of conduct and supervisor advice, on personnel decisions in an experimental simulation. Specifically, we studied personnel evaluations and decisions in a situation where codes of conduct conflict with supervisor advice. Past studies showed that supervisors’ advice to prefer ingroup over outgroup candidates leads to discriminatory personnel selection decisions. We extended this line of research by studying how codes of conduct and code enforcement may reduce this form of discrimination. Eighty German managers evaluated and selected candidates from an applicant pool including Germans (ingroup members) and foreigners (outgroup members). Supervisor advice to prefer ingroup members lowered suitability ratings of outgroup members as well as their chances to be selected for an interview. Ethical codes of conduct referring to equal opportunities limited this form of discrimination, but only when codes were enforced by sanctions and integrated into organizational every-day practice. The implications of these findings for research and practice are discussed.

Keywords

personnel selection employment discrimination codes of conduct code enforcement 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Akaah I. P., E. Riordan: 1989, Judgements of Marketing Professionals About Ethical Issues in Marketing Research: A Replication and Extension, Journal of Marketing Research 26, 112–120CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Allen J., D. Davis: 1993, Assessing Some Determinant Effects of Ethical Consulting Behavior: The Case of Personal and Professional Values, Journal of Business Ethics 12, 449–458CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Arvey R. D., R. H. Faley: 1988, Fairness in Selecting Employees (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA)Google Scholar
  4. Badaracco Jr. J. J., A. P. Webb: 1995, Business Ethics: A View from the Trenches, California Management Review 37, 8–28Google Scholar
  5. Barnett T., D. Cochran, S. Taylor: 1993, The Internal Disclosure Policies of Private-Sector Employers: An Initial Look at Their Relationship to Employee Whistleblowing, Journal of Business Ethics 12, 127–137CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bertrand M., S. Mullainathan: 2004, Are Emily and Greg More Employable than Lakisha and Jamal? A Field Experiment on Labor Market Discrimination, American Economic Review 94, 991–1013CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Brass D. J., K. D. Butterfield, B. C. Skaggs: 1998, Relationships and Unethical Behaviour: A Social Network Perspective, Academy of Management Review 23, 14–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Brief A. P., R. T. Buttram, J. D. Elliot, R. M. Reizenstein, R. L. McCline: 1995, Releasing the Beast: A Study of Compliance with Orders to Use Race as a Selection Criterion, Journal of Social Issues 51, 177–193CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Brief A. P., J. Dietz, R. R. Cohen, S. D. Pugh, J. B. Vaslow: 2000, Just Doing Business: Modern Racism and Obedience to Authority as Explanations for Employment Discrimination, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 81, 72–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Brief A. P., J. M. Dukerich, P. R. Brown, J. F. Brett: 1996, What’s Wrong with the Treadway Commission Report? Experimental Analyses of the Effects of Personal Values and Codes of Conduct on Fraudulent Financial Reporting, Journal of Business Ethics 15, 183–198CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Brief A. P., J. M. Dukerich, L.-I. Doran: 1991, Resolving Ethical Dilemmas in Management: Experimental Investigations of Values, Accountability, and Choice, Journal of Applied Social Psychology 21, 380–396CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Brown M. E., L. K. Trevino: 2006, Ethical Leadership: A Review and Future Directions, Leadership Quarterly 17, 595–616CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Bundesagentur für Arbeit [Federal Employment Office Germany]: 2007, Arbeitsmarkt in Zahlen: Daten für 2006 [Employment statistics: Figures for 2006]. http://www.pub.arbeitsamt.de/hst/services/statistik/000100/ html/jahr/arbeitsmarkt_2006_gesamt.pdf
  14. Callan V. J.: 1992, Predicting Ethical Values and Training Needs in Ethics, The Journal of Business Ethics 11, 761–769CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Cassel C., P. Johnson, K. Smith: 1997, Opening the Black Box: Corporate Codes of Ethics in Their Organizational Context, Journal of Business Ethics 10, 10–24Google Scholar
  16. Chonko L. B., S. D. Hunt: 1985, Ethics and Marketing Management: An Empirical Examination, Journal of Business Research 13, 339–359CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Clark M. A., S. L. Leonard: 1998, Can Corporate Codes of Ethics Influence Behavior?, Journal of Business Ethics 17, 619–630Google Scholar
  18. Cowton C., P. Thompson: 2000, Do Codes Make a Difference? The Case of Bank Lending and the Environment, Journal of Business Ethics 24, 165–178CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Dietz J., L.-E. Petersen: 2006, Diversity Management, in G. Stahl, I. Björkman (eds.), Handbook of Research in International HR Management (Edward Elgar Pub., Cheltenham, UK), pp. 223–243Google Scholar
  20. Ely R. J., D. A. Thomas: 2001, Cultural Diversity at Work: The Effects of Diversity Perspectives on Work Group Processes and Outcomes, Administrative Science Quarterly 46, 229–273CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Falkenberg L., I. Herremans: 1995, Ethical Behavior in Organizations: Directed by the Formal or Informal Systems? Journal of Business Ethics 14, 133–143CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Farrell B., D. Cobbin, H. Farrell: 2002, Can Codes of Ethics Really Produce Consistent Behavior?, Journal of Managerial Psychology 17, 468–490CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Ferrell O. C., S. J. Skinner: 1988, Ethical Behavior and Bureaucratic Structure in Marketing Research Organizations, Journal of Marketing Research 25, 103–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Ford R. C., B. Gray, R. Landrum: 1982, Do Organizational Codes of Conduct Really Affect Employees’ Behavior?, Management Review 71, 53–55Google Scholar
  25. Foroohar, R.: 2002, ‹Race in the Boardroom’, Newsweeks, February 18, 34–38Google Scholar
  26. Frazer R. A., U. J. Wiersma: 2001, Prejudice Versus Discrimination in the Employment Interview: We may Hire Equally, But Our Memories Harbour Prejudice, Human Relations 54, 173–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Gorman C. D., W. H. Clover, M. E. Doherty: 1978, Can We Learn Anything About Interviewing Real People from “Interviews” of Paper People? Two Studies of the External Validity of a Paradigm, Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 22, 165–192CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Harris M. M.: 1989, Reconsidering the Employment Interview: A Review of Recent Literature and Suggestions for Future Research, Personnel Psychology 42, 691–726CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hegarty W. H., H. P. Sims: 1979, Organizational Philosophy, Policies, and Objectives Related to Unethical Decision Behavior: A Laboratory Experiment, Journal of Applied Psychology 64, 331–338CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Huffcutt A. I., P. L. Roth: 1998, Racial Group Differences in Employment Interview Evaluations, Journal of Applied Psychology 83, 179–189CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hunt S. D., L. B. Chonko, J. B. Wilcox: 1984, Ethical Problems of Marketing Researchers, Journal of Marketing Research 21, 309–324CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Kaptein M.: 1998, Ethics Management: Auditing and Developing the Ethical Content of Organizations. (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht)Google Scholar
  33. Kaptein M.: 2004, Business Codes of Multinational Firms: What do they Say?, Journal of Business Ethics 50, 13–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Kaptein M., M. S. Schwartz: 2008, The Effectiveness of Business Codes: A Critical Examination of Existing Studies and the Development of an Integrated Research Model. Journal of Business Ethics 77, 111–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Kaptein M., J. Wempe: 1998, Twelve Gordian Knots When Developing a Code of Conduct, Journal of Business Ethics 17, 853–869CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Kitson A.: 1996, Taking the Pulse: Ethics and the British Cooperative Bank, Journal of Business Ethics 15, 1021–1031CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Koppelman R. E., A. P. Brief, R. A. Guzzo: 1990, The Role of Climate and Culture in Productivity, in B. Schneider (ed.), Organizational Climate and Culture (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco)Google Scholar
  38. Krings F., J. Olivares: 2007, At the Doorstep to Employment: Discrimination Against Immigrants as a Function of Applicant Ethnicity, Job Type, and Raters’ Prejudice, International Journal of Psychology 42, 406–417CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Kühne, P., N. Oztürk and K.-W. West: 1994, Gewerkschaften und Einwanderung [Unions and Immigration] (Bund-Verlag, Köln/Germany)Google Scholar
  40. Laczniak G. R., E. J. Inderrieden: 1987, The Influence of Stated Organizational Concern Upon Ethical Decision Making, The Journal of Business Ethics 6, 297–307CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Lin T. R., G. H. Dobbins, J. L. Farh: 1992, A Field Study of Race and Age Similarity Effects on Interview Ratings in Conventional and Situational Interviews, Journal of Applied Psychology 77, 363–371CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Marnburg E.: 2000, The Behavioral Effects of Corporate Ethical Codes: Empirical Findings and Discussion, Business Ethics: A European Review 9, 200–210CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. McCabe D., L. Trevino, K. Butterfield: (1996). The Influence of Collegiate and Corporate Codes of Conduct on Ethics-Related Behavior in the Work-Place, Business Ethics Quarterly 6, 461–476CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. McConahay J. B.: 1986, Modern Racism, Ambivalence, and the Modern Racism Scale. in J. F. Dovidio, S. L. Gaertner (eds.), Prejudice, Discrimination, and Racism (Academic Press, New York), pp. 91–125Google Scholar
  45. Münz, R., W. Seifert and R. Ulrich: 1999, Zuwanderung nach Deutschland: Strukturen, Wirkungen, Perspektiven [Immigration to Germany: Structures, Effects, Perspectives] (Campus Verlag, Frankfurt/Germany)Google Scholar
  46. Murphy P. E., J. E. Smith, J. M. Daley: 1992, Executive Attitudes, Organizational Size and Ethical Issues: Perspectives on a Service Industry, Journal of Business Ethics 11, 11–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Petersen L.-E., J. Dietz: 2000, Social Discrimination in a Personnel Selection Context: The Effects of an Authority’s Instruction to Discriminate and Followers’ Authoritarianism, Journal of Applied Social Psychology 30, 206–220CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Petersen L.-E., J. Dietz: 2005, Prejudice and Enforcement of Workforce Homogeneity as Explanations for Employment Discrimination, Journal of Applied Social Psychology 35, 144–159CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Pierce M. A., J. W. Henry: 1996, Computer Ethics: The Role of Personal, Informal, and Formal Codes, Journal of Business Ethics 15, 425–437CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Purcell T. V.: 1978, Institutionalizing Ethics on Corporate Boards, Review of Social Economy 36, 41–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Rich, A. J., P. H. Smith and P. H. Mihalek: 1990, ‹Are Corporate Codes of Conduct Effective?’, Management Accountant, 72, 34–35Google Scholar
  52. Schneider B., R. A. Guzzo, A. P. Brief: 1992, Establishing a Climate for Productivity Improvement, in W. K. Hodson (ed.), Maynard´s Industrial Engineering Handbook (4th ed.). (McGraw-Hill, New York)Google Scholar
  53. Schwartz M.: 2001, The Nature of the Relationship Between Corporate Codes of Ethics and Behaviour, Journal of Business Ethics 32, 247–262CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Singhapakdi, A. and S. J. Vitell: 1990, ‹Marketing Ethics: Factors Influencing Perceptions of Ethical Problems and Alternatives’, Journal of Macromarketing (Spring), 4–18Google Scholar
  55. Stevens J. H., H. Steensma, D. Harrison, P. Cochran: 2005, Symbolic or Substantive Document? The Influence of Ethics Codes on Financial Executives Decisions, Strategic Management Journal 26, 181–195CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Trevino L. K., K. D. Butterfield, D. M. Mcabe: 1998, The Ethical Context in Organizations: Influences on Employee Attitudes and Behaviors, Business Ethics Quarterly 8, 441–416CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Urbany J. E.: 2005, Inspiration and Cynicism in Values Statements, Journal of Business Ethics 62, 169–182CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Wagner U., M. Hewstone, U. Machleit: 1989, Contact and Prejudice Between Germans and Turks: A Correlational Study, Human Relations 42, 561–574CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Wagner U., R. van Dick, A. Zick: 2001, Sozialpsychologische Analysen und Erklärungen von Fremdenfeindlickkeit in Deutschland [Social Psychological Analyses and Explanations for Hostility Toward Foreigners in Germany], Zeitschrift für Sozialpsychologie 32, 59–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Weaver G. R., L. K. Trevino: 1999, Compliance and Values Orientated Ethics Programs: Influence on Employees’ Attitudes and Behavior, Business Ethics Quarterly, 9, 315–335CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Weber, J: 1981, ‹Institutionalizing Ethics into the Corporation’, MSU Business Topics (Spring), 47–52Google Scholar
  62. Weeks W. A., J. Nantel: 1992, Corporate Codes of Ethics and Sales Force Behavior: A Case Study, Journal of Business Ethics 11, 753–760CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Wood G., M. Rimmer: 2003, Codes of Ethics: What are they Really and What Should Be?, International Journal of Value-Based Management 16, 181–195CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Social and Organizational PsychologyUniversity of Halle-WittenbergHalle (Saale)Germany
  2. 2.Faculty of Business and Economics (HEC)University of Lausanne1015 Lausanne-DorignySwitzerland

Personalised recommendations