Cross-sectional analysis of speech and cognitive performance in 32 patients with classic galactosemia
Long-term outcome in classic galactosemia is disappointing with impaired IQ, reduced bone mineral density, and fertility problems. Moreover, speech impairment is common with conflicting reports regarding frequency, pattern, and relation to IQ.
To evaluate speech and cognitive performance in patients with galactosemia.
Speech performance was evaluated by means of the Hierarchische Wortlisten, a German word-repetition test for the diagnosis of apraxia of speech, using real words and pseudo-words. Cognitive performance was evaluated by use of age-appropriate German versions of the Wechsler Scales.
In a cohort of 32 patients (12 females, 20 males; mean age 21.2 ± 7.2 years) with classic galactosemia, the mean IQ was 76.2 ± 14.8. Eighty-four percent of the patients passed the speech test with errors. Speech errors were much more related to pseudo-words than real words and were predominantly observed in words with three and four syllables. The performance in producing words was correlated to the IQ scores.
Impairment of speech affects a significant number of patients with galactosemia, appears in early childhood, and persists into adulthood. The pattern of speech impairment may allow labeling as apraxia of speech. In many cases impaired speech is related to decreased IQ.
KeywordsApraxia Real Word Full Scale Intelligence Quotient Galactosemia Speech Impairment
Apraxia of speech
Full scale intelligence quotient
Performance intelligence quotient
Verbal intelligence quotient
This study was supported by a grant of the Sanitätsrat Dr. Emil Alexander Huebner und Frau Gemahlin-Stiftung. The sponsor had no role in planning, conducting, or analyzing the study. We are indebted to the patients with galactosemia who participated in this study. W. Angerstein and N. Hoffmüller kindly reviewed the manuscript and gave advice regarding diagnosis and definition of apraxia of speech. M. Schimeczek provided information regarding interpretation of the Hierarchische Wortlisten.
- Ad Hoc Committee on Childhood Apraxia of Speech of the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (2007) Childhood apraxia of speech: position statement. American Speech-Language-Hearing Association, Rockville, MDGoogle Scholar
- Liepold M (1998) Hierarchische Wortlisten. Ein Nachsprechtest für die Sprechdiagnostik. Verlag Modernes Lernen, DortmundGoogle Scholar
- Satzger W, Dragon E, Engel R (1996) Zur Normäquivalenz von HAWIE-R und HAWIE. Diagnostica 43:119–138Google Scholar
- Schallberger U (1987) HAWIK und HAWIK-R: ein empirischer Vergleich. Diagnostica 33:1–13Google Scholar