Abstract
Numerous head injury models exist that vary in mesh density by orders of magnitude. A careful study of the mesh convergence behavior is necessary, especially in terms of strain most relevant to brain injury. To this end, as well as to investigate the effect of element integration scheme on simulated strains, we re-meshed the Worcester Head Injury Model at five mesh densities (~ 7.2–1000 k high-quality hexahedral elements of the brain). Results from explicit dynamic simulations of three cadaveric impacts and an in vivo head rotation were compared. First, scalar metrics of the whole brain only considering magnitude were used, including peak maximum principal strain and population-based median strain. They were further extended to deep white matter regions and the entire brain elements, respectively, to form two “response vectors” to account for both magnitude and distribution. Using benchmark enhanced full-integration elements (C3D8I), a minimum of 202.8 k brain elements were necessary to converge for response vectors of the deep white matter regions. This model was further used to simulate with reduced integration (C3D8R). We found that hourglass energy higher than the common rule of thumb (e.g., up to 44.38% vs. < 10% of internal energy) was necessary to maintain comparable strain relative to C3D8I. Based on these results, it is recommended that a human head injury model should have a minimum number of 202.8 k elements, or an average element size of no larger than 1.8 mm, for the brain. C3D8R formulation with relax stiffness hourglass control using a high scaling factor is also recommended to achieve sufficient accuracy without substantial computational cost.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abaqus. Abaqus Online Documentation, Abaqus 2016., 2016.
Atsumi, N., Y. Nakahira, and M. Iwamoto. Development and validation of a head/brain FE model and investigation of influential factor on the brain response during head impact. Int. J. Veh. Saf. 9:1–23, 2016.
Bandak, F. A. On the Mechanics of impact neurotrauma : a review and critical synthesis. J. Neurotrauma 12:635–650, 1995.
Bigler, E. D., and W. L. Maxwell. Neuropathology of mild traumatic brain injury: relationship to neuroimaging findings. Brain Imaging Behav. 6:108–136, 2012.
Cai, Y., S. Wu, W. Zhao, Z. Li, Z. Wu, and S. Ji. Concussion classification via deep learning using whole-brain white matter fiber strains. PLoS ONE 13:e0197992, 2018.
Chafi, M. S., V. Dirisala, G. Karami, and M. Ziejewski. A finite element method parametric study of the dynamic response of the human brain with different cerebrospinal fluid constitutive properties. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. H. 223:1003–1019, 2009.
Chatelin, S., C. Deck, F. Renard, S. Kremer, C. Heinrich, J.-P. Armspach, and R. Willinger. Computation of axonal elongation in head trauma finite element simulation. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 4:1905–1919, 2011.
Chen, Y., and M. Ostoja-Starzewski. MRI-based finite element modeling of head trauma: spherically focusing shear waves. Acta Mech. 213:155–167, 2010.
Duhaime, A.-C., J. G. Beckwith, A. C. Maerlender, T. W. McAllister, J. J. Crisco, S. M. Duma, P. G. Brolinson, S. Rowson, L. A. Flashman, J. J. Chu, and R. M. Greenwald. Spectrum of acute clinical characteristics of diagnosed concussions in college athletes wearing instrumented helmets. J. Neurosurg. 117:1092–1099, 2012.
Garimella, H. T., and R. H. Kraft. Modeling the mechanics of axonal fiber tracts using the embedded finite element method. Int. J. Numer. Method. Biomed. Eng. 33:26–35, 2017.
Giordano, C., and S. Kleiven. Evaluation of axonal strain as a predictor for mild traumatic brain injuries using finite element modeling. Stapp Car Crash J. 58:29–61, 2014.
Hardy, W. N., M. J. Mason, C. D. Foster, C. S. Shah, J. M. Kopacz, K. H. Yang, A. I. King, J. Bishop, M. Bey, W. Anderst, and S. Tashman. A study of the response of the human cadaver head to impact. Stapp Car Crash J. 51:17–80, 2007.
Ji, S., H. Ghadyani, R. P. Bolander, J. G. Beckwith, J. C. Ford, T. W. McAllister, L. A. Flashman, K. D. Paulsen, K. Ernstrom, S. Jain, R. Raman, L. Zhang, and R. M. Greenwald. Parametric comparisons of intracranial mechanical responses from three validated finite element models of the human head. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 42:11–24, 2014.
Ji, S., and W. Zhao. A pre-computed brain response atlas for instantaneous strain estimation in contact sports. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 43:1877–1895, 2015.
Ji, S., W. Zhao, J. C. Ford, J. G. Beckwith, R. P. Bolander, R. M. Greenwald, L. A. Flashman, K. D. Paulsen, and T. W. McAllister. Group-wise evaluation and comparison of white matter fiber strain and maximum principal strain in sports-related concussion. J. Neurotrauma 32:441–454, 2015.
King, A. I., K. H. Yang, L. Zhang, W. Hardy, and D. C. Viano. Is head injury caused by linear or angular acceleration?, 2003.
Kleiven, S. Predictors for traumatic brain injuries evaluated through accident reconstructions. Stapp Car Crash J. 51:81–114, 2007.
Kleiven, S., and W. N. W. Hardy. Correlation of an FE model of the human head with local brain motion—consequences for injury prediction. Stapp Car Crash J. 46:123–144, 2002.
Kleiven, S., and W. N. W. Hardy. Correlation of an FE model of the human head with local brain motion-consequences for injury prediction. Stapp Car Crash J. 46:123–144, 2002.
Kleiven, S., and H. von Holst. Consequences of head size following trauma to the human head. J. Biomech. 35:153–160, 2002.
Krueger, R. Development of benchmark examples for delamination onset and fatigue growth prediction. Tech Rep NF1676L-11493, NASA;, 2011.
Langer, P., M. Maeder, C. Guist, M. Krause, and S. Marburg. More than six elements per wavelength: the practical use of structural finite element models and their accuracy in comparison with experimental results. J. Comput. Acoust. 25:1750025, 2017.
Laurent, H., R. Greze, M. C. Oliveira, L. F. Menezes, P. Y. Manach, and J. L. Alves. Numerical study of springback using the split-ring test for an AA5754 aluminum alloy. Finite Elem. Anal. Des. 46:751–759, 2010.
Mao, H., H. Gao, L. Cao, V. V. Genthikatti, and K. H. Yang. Development of high-quality hexahedral human brain meshes using feature-based multi-block approach. Comput. Methods Biomech. Biomed. Eng. 16:271–279, 2013.
Mao, H., F. Guan, X. Han, and K. H. Yang. Strain-based regional traumatic brain injury intensity in controlled cortical impact: a systematic numerical analysis. J. Neurotrauma 28:2263–2276, 2011.
Mao, H., L. Zhang, B. Jiang, V. V. V. Genthikatti, X. Jin, F. Zhu, R. Makwana, A. Gill, G. Jandir, A. Singh, and K. H. H. Yang. Development of a finite element human head model partially validated with thirty five experimental cases. J. Biomech. Eng. 135:11102, 2013.
Miller, L. E., J. E. Urban, and J. D. Stitzel. Development and validation of an atlas-based finite element brain model model. Biomech Model. 15:1201–1214, 2016.
Post, A., E. S. Walsh, T. B. Hoshizaki, and M. D. Gilchrist. Analysis of loading curve characteristics on the production of brain deformation metrics. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part P 226:200–207, 2012.
Rashid, B., M. Destrade, and M. D. Gilchrist. Mechanical characterization of brain tissue in compression at dynamic strain rates. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 10:23–38, 2012.
Rashid, B., M. Destrade, and M. D. Gilchrist. Mechanical characterization of brain tissue in tension at dynamic strain rates. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 33:43–54, 2014.
Ruan, J., T. Khalil, and A. King. Finite element modeling of direct head impact. Proc. 37th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 69–81, 1993.https://doi.org/10.4271/933114.
Sabet, A. A., E. Christoforou, B. Zatlin, G. M. Genin, and P. V. Bayly. Deformation of the human brain induced by mild angular head acceleration. J. Biomech. 41:307–315, 2008.
Sahoo, D., C. Deck, and R. Willinger. Development and validation of an advanced anisotropic visco-hyperelastic human brain FE model. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 33:24–42, 2014.
Sullivan, S., S. A. Eucker, D. Gabrieli, C. Bradfield, B. Coats, M. R. Maltese, J. Lee, C. Smith, and S. S. Margulies. White matter tract-oriented deformation predicts traumatic axonal brain injury and reveals rotational direction-specific vulnerabilities. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 14:877–896, 2014.
Takhounts, E. G., R. H. Eppinger, J. Q. Campbell, R. E. Tannous, E. D. Power, and L. S. Shook. On the development of the SIMon finite element head model. Stapp Car Crash J. 47:107–133, 2003.
Takhounts, E. G., S. A. Ridella, R. E. Tannous, J. Q. Campbell, D. Malone, K. Danelson, J. Stitzel, S. Rowson, S. Duma, V. Hasija, R. E. Tannous, J. Q. Campbell, D. Malone, K. Danelson, J. Stitzel, S. Rowson, and S. Duma. Investigation of traumatic brain injuries using the next generation of simulated injury monitor (SIMon) finite element head model. Stapp Car Crash J. 52:1–31, 2008.
Ward, C. C., and R. B. Thompson. The development of a detailed finite element brain model. Stapp Car Crash Conf. Proc. SAE Technical Paper 751163, 1975.https://doi.org/10.4271/751163.
Yanaoka, T., Y. Dokko, and Y. Takahashi. Investigation on an Injury Criterion Related to Traumatic Brain Injury Primarily Induced by Head Rotation. SAE Tech. Pap. 2015-01-1439, 2015.https://doi.org/10.4271/2015-01-1439.copyright.
Yang, K., H. Mao, C. Wagner, F. Zhu, C. C. Chou, and A. I. King. Modeling of the Brain for Injury Prevention. In: Studies in Mechanobiology, Tissue Engineering and Biomaterials, edited by L. E. Bilston. Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, 2011, pp. 69–120. http://www.springerlink.com/index/U7368378332M5820.pdf.
Zhang, L., K. H. Yang, R. Dwarampudi, K. Omori, T. Li, K. Chang, W. N. Hardy, T. B. Khalil, and A. I. King. Recent advances in brain injury research: a new human head model development and validation. Stapp Car Crash J. 45:369–394, 2001.
Zhao, W., Y. Cai, Z. Li, and S. Ji. Injury prediction and vulnerability assessment using strain and susceptibility measures of the deep white matter. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 16:1709–1727, 2017.
Zhao, W., B. Choate, and S. Ji. Material properties of the brain in injury-relevant conditions—experiments and computational modeling. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 80:222–234, 2018.
Zhao, W., J. C. Ford, L. A. Flashman, T. W. McAllister, and S. Ji. White matter injury susceptibility via fiber strain evaluation using whole-brain tractography. J. Neurotrauma 33:1834–1847, 2016.
Zhao, W., and S. Ji. White matter anisotropy for impact simulation and response sampling in traumatic brain injury. J. Neurotrauma 2018:5, 2018.
Zhao, W., C. Kuo, L. Wu, D. B. Camarillo, and S. Ji. Performance evaluation of a pre-computed brain response atlas in dummy head impacts. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 45:2437–2450, 2017.
Zhao, W., and S. Ji. Parametric investigation of regional brain strain responses via a pre-computed atlas. IRCOBI Conf. 208–220, 2015.
Acknowledgment
Funding is provided by the NIH Grants R01 NS092853 and R21 NS088781.
Disclosure
No competing financial interests exist.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Associate Editor Raj K. Prabhu oversaw the review of this article.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Zhao, W., Ji, S. Mesh Convergence Behavior and the Effect of Element Integration of a Human Head Injury Model. Ann Biomed Eng 47, 475–486 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-018-02159-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-018-02159-z