Abstract
This paper investigates the legitimacy of using area-wide models in predicting aggregate variables in the Euro-area. We aim to compare the performance of area-wide versus national specific models for modeling money demand when using different aggregation schemes. A generalized Grunfeld and Griliches criterion and the Vuong test are used to discriminate between competitive models. Results show that the use of different aggregation methods is not irrelevant. In fact, due to the volatility of the exchange rates, the aggregate models fit better than the disaggregate whenever we employ ECU exchange rates. However, for fixed exchange rates expressed in Euro, the disaggregate models outperform the aggregate ones.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arnold IJM (1994). The myth of a stable European money demand. Open Econ Rev 5, 3: 249–259
Artis MJ, Bladen-Hovell RC, Zhang W (1993) A European money demand function. In: Masson PR, Taylor MP (eds) Policy issues in the operation of currency unions. Cambridge University Press, pp 240–263
Bayoumi T and Kenen PB (1993). How useful is an EC-wide monetary aggregate as an intermediate target for Europe?. Rev Int Econ 1: 209–220
Beyers A, Doornik JA and Hendry DF (2001). Constructing historical Euro-zone data. Econ J 111: F102–F121
Brand C and Cassola N (2004). A money demand system for Euro-area M3. Appl Econ 36: 817–838
Brand C, Gerdesmeier D, Roffia B (2002) Estimating the trend of M3 income velocity underlying the reference value for monetary growth, European Central Bank, Occasional Paper, No. 3
Calza A, Levy J, Gerdersmeier D (2001) Euro Area Money Demand: measuring the opportunity costs appropriately, Working paper 01/179, International Monetary Found, Washington
Cassard M, Lane TD and Masson PR (1997). Core-ERM money demand and effects on inflation. The Manchester School 65(1): 1–24
Clausen V (1998). Money demand and monetary policy in Europe. Rev World Econ 134(4): 712–739
Clements MP and Hendry DF (1993). On the limitations of comparing Mean Square Forecast errors. J Forecasting 12: 617–637
Coenen G and Vega JL (2001). The demand for M3 in the Euro-Area. J Appl Economet 16(6): 727–748
Dedola L, Gaiotti E and Silipo L (2001). Money demand in the Euro area: do national differences matter?. Temi di discussione Bank of Italy 405: 405
Fagan G and Henry J (1998). Long run money demand in Euro-area. Empir Econ 23: 483–506
Fagan G, Henry J and Mestre R (2005). An area-wide model for the Euro-area. Econ Model 22: 39–59
Golinelli R and Pastorello S (2002). Modelling the demand for M3 in the Euro-area. Euro J Finance 8(4): 371–401
Grunfeld Y and Griliches Z (1960). Is aggregation necessarily bad?. Rev Econ Stat 42: 1–13
Kremers JJM and Lane TD (1990). Economic and monetary integration and the aggregate demand for money in the EMS. IMF Staff Papers 37: 777–805
Hayo B (1999). Estimating a European demand for money. Scott J Polit Econ 46(3): 221–244
Inoue A and Kilian L (2005). In sample or out of sample tests of predictability: which one should we use?. Econometric Rev 22(4): 371–402
Marcellino M, Stock JH and Watson MW (2003). Macroeconomic forecasting in the Euro area: country specific versus area-wide information. Euro Econ Rev 47(1): 1–18
Monticelli C and Strauss-Kahn MO (1993). European integration and the demand for broad money. The Manch School 61(4): 345–366
Pesaran MH, Pierse RG and Kumar MS (1989). Econometric analysis of aggregation in the context of linear prediction models. Econometrica 57(4): 861–888
Sbrana G (2007). Testing for model selection in predicting aggregate variables. Giornale degli Econ Ann Econ 66(1): 3–28
Spencer P (1997). Monetary integration and currency substitution in the EMS: the case for a European monetary aggregate. Euro Econ Rev 41: 1403–1419
Vuong (1989). Likelihood ratio tests for model selection and non-nested hypothesis. Econometrica 57(2): 307–333
Wesche K (1997). The stability of European money demand: an investigation of M3H. Open Econ Rev 8: 371–391
Winder CCA (1997). On the construction of European area-wide aggregates: a review of the issues and empirical evidence. De Nederlandsche Bank Reprint Series 542: 542
Zellner A (2004) Statistics, econometrics and forecasting, the stone lectures in economics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 125–137
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This paper was written during my visiting research period at the Department of Economics, University of Southampton. I wish to thank John Aldrich, Jan Podivinsky, Grayham Mizon and Akos Valentinyi.
Financial support of the Universita degli Studi “Roma Tre” and the Marie Curie fellowship (HPMT-CT-2001-00353) are gratefully acknowledged.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sbrana, G. On the use of area-wide models in the Euro-zone. Stat Meth Appl 17, 499–518 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10260-007-0074-4
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10260-007-0074-4