Variation in Soil Methane Release or Uptake Responses to Biochar Amendment: A Separate Meta-analysis
Agricultural soils play an important role in the atmospheric methane (CH4) budget, where paddy soils can contribute significant CH4 to atmosphere whereas upland soils may act as a source or sink of atmospheric CH4, dependent on soil water conditions. Biochar amendments have effects on soil CH4 production or oxidation processes in individual experiments, but the causative mechanisms are yet to be fully elucidated. To synthesize the response of soil CH4 release or uptake to biochar amendment, we performed a meta-analysis using data from 61 peer-reviewed papers with 222 updated paired measurements. When averaged across all studies, biochar amendment significantly decreased CH4 release rates by 12% for paddy soils and 72% for upland soils, and CH4 uptake rates by 84% for upland soils. Neither soil CH4 release nor uptake responses to biochar amendment were significant in field soils. Nitrogen (N) fertilizer application would weaken the response of soil CH4 release or uptake to biochar amendment. Biochar-incurred decreases in soil CH4 release and uptake rates were the largest in medium-textured soils or neutral-pH soils. Soil CH4 release or uptake responses to biochar were also significantly altered by biochar characteristics, such as feedstock source, C/N ratio, pH, and pyrolysis temperature. The results of this synthesis suggest that the role of biochar in soil CH4 mitigation potential might have been exaggerated, particularly in fields when biochar is applied in combination with N fertilizer.
Keywordsbiochar methane climate change paddy soil upland soil meta-analysis
This work was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China (41771268, 41771323), National Key Research and Development Program of China (2016YFD0201200), and Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (KYTZ201404, KYZ201621).
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- Anders E, Watzinger A, Rempt F et al. 2013. Biochar affects the structure rather than the total biomass of microbial communities in temperate soils. Agric Food Sci 22:404–23.Google Scholar
- Cayuela ML, Oenema O, Kuikman PJ, Bakker RR, van Groenigen JW. 2010. Bioenergy by-products as soil amendments? Implications for carbon sequestration and greenhouse gas emissions. Global Change Biol Bioenergy 2:201–13.Google Scholar
- Denman KL, Brasseur G, Chidthaisong A, and others. 2007. Couplings between changes in the climate system and biogeochemistry. In: Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M, Chen Z, Marquis M, Averyt KB, Tignor M, Miller HL, Eds. Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of working group I to the fourth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp 501–87Google Scholar
- IPCC. 2013. The physical science basis. In: Stocker TF, and others, Eds. Contribution of working group I to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp 5–14Google Scholar
- Jennions MD, Lortie CJ, Rosenberg MS, Rothstein HR. 2013. Publication and related biases. In: Handbook of meta-analysis in ecology and evolution, pp 207–36.Google Scholar
- Knoblauch C, Marifaat AA, Haefele MS. 2008. Biochar in rice based system: impact on carbon mineralization and trace gas emissions. http://www.biochar-international.org/2008/conference/posters
- R Development Core Team. 2016. R: a language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.Google Scholar
- Rondon M, Ramirez JA, Lehmann J. 2005. Greenhouse gas emissions decrease with charcoal additions to tropical soils. In: Proceedings of the 3rd USDA symposium on greenhouse gases and carbon sequestration, baltimore, USA, March 21–24, pp 208Google Scholar
- Rondon MA, Molina D, Hurtado M, and others. 2006. Enhancing the productivity of crops and grasses while reducing greenhouse gas emissions through biochar amendments to unfertile tropical soils. In: 18th world congress of soil science, July 9–15, Philadelphia, PA, Accessed June 2008.Google Scholar
- Spokas KA, Reicosky DC. 2009. Impacts of sixteen different biochars on soil greenhouse gas production. Ann Environ Sci 3:179–93.Google Scholar
- Van Zwieten L, Singh BP, Joseph S, and others. 2009. Biochar reduces emissions of non-CO2 GHG from soil. In: Lehmann J Joseph S Eds. Biochar for environmental management. Earthscan Publications, pp 227–49.Google Scholar
- Yaghoubi P, Yargicoglu E, Reddy K. 2014. Effects of biochar-amendment to landfill cover soil on microbial methane oxidation: initial results, Geo-Congress 2014 Technical Papers. American Society of Civil Engineers, pp 1849–58.Google Scholar
- Zhang AF, Bian RJ, Pan GX, Cui LQ, Hussain Q, Li LQ, Zhang JW, Zheng JF, Zhang XH, Han XJ, Yu XY. 2012b. Effects of biochar amendment on soil quality, crop yield and greenhouse gas emission in a Chinese rice paddy: a field study of 2 consecutive rice growing cycles. Field Crops Res 127:153–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar