Thoracotomy versus video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) in stage III empyema—an analysis of 217 consecutive patients
Pleural empyema is an infectious disease of the chest cavity, with a high morbidity and mortality. According to the American Thoracic Society, pleural empyema gets graduated into three stages, with surgery being indicated in intermediate stage II and chronic stage III. Evidence for the feasibility of a minimally-invasive video-assisted thoracoscopic approach in stage III empyema for pulmonary decortication is still little.
Retrospective single-center analysis of patients conducted to surgery for chronic stage III pleural empyema from 05/2002 to 04/2014 either by video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS, n = 110) or conventional open surgery by thoracotomy (n = 107). Multiple regression analysis and propensity score matching was used to evaluate the influence of operation technique (thoracotomy versus VATS) on the length of post-operative hospitalization.
Operation time was longer in the thoracotomy-group (p = 0.0207). Conversion rate from VATS to open surgery by thoracotomy was 4.5%. Post-operative complication- (61 patients in thoracotomy- and 55 patients in VATS-group), recurrence- (3 patients in thoracotomy- and 5 in VATS-group) and mortality-rates (6.5% in thoracotomy- and 9.5% in VATS-group) did not differ between both groups; the length of (post-operative) stay at intensive care unit was longer in the VATS-group (p = 0.0023). Duration of chest tube drainage and prolonged air leak rate were similar among both groups, leading to a similar overall and post-operative length of hospital stay in both groups. Adjusted to clinically and statistically relevant confounders, multiple regression analysis showed an influence of the surgical technique on length of post-operative stay after pair matching of the patients (n = 84 in each group) by propensity score (B = − 0.179 for thoracotomy = 0 and VATS = 1, p = 0.032) leading to a reduction of 0.836 days after a VATS-approach compared to thoracotomy.
VATS in late stage (III) pleural empyema is feasible and safe. The decrease in post-operative hospitalization demonstrated by adjusted multiple regression analysis may indicate the minimally-invasive approach being safe, more tolerable for patients, and more effective.
KeywordsVideo-assisted thoracoscopic surgery VATS Thoracotomy Pleural empyema Empyema thoracis Pleural infection
Compliance with ethical standards
Martin Reichert, Bernd Pösentrup, Andreas Hecker, Emmanuel Schneck, Jörn Pons-Kühnemann, Florian Augustin, Winfried Padberg, Dietmar Öfner, and Johannes Bodner have no conflicts of interest or financial ties to disclose.
- 2.Andrews NC, Parker EF, Shaw RR, Wilson NJ, Webb WR (1962) Management of non tuberculous empyema: a statement of the subcommittee on surgery. Am Rev Respir Dis 85:935–936Google Scholar
- 4.Reichert M, Steiner D, Kerber S, Bender J, Posentrup B, Hecker A, Bodner J (2016) A standardized technique of systematic mediastinal lymph node dissection by video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) leads to a high rate of nodal upstaging in early-stage non-small cell lung cancer. Surg Endosc 30:1119–1125CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 7.Reichert M, Hecker M, Witte B, Bodner J, Padberg W, Weigand MA, Hecker A (2016) Stage-directed therapy of pleural empyema. Langenbecks Arch Surg 402:15–26Google Scholar