Skip to main content

Table 4 Summary of spigelian hernia data

From: Guidelines for laparoscopic treatment of ventral and incisional abdominal wall hernias (International Endohernia Society [IEHS])—Part III

Study No. of repairs Open sutured Open mesh Laparoscopic mesh Recurrence rate
Artioukh [214] 19 19    0
Campanelli [215] 32   32   0
Celdrán [216] 9   9   0
Larson [217] 81 75 5 1 3/75 (4 %), no mesh
Malazgirt [218] 34   34   0
Mittal [219] 10    10 0
Moreno-Egea [220] 28 (17 open but not stated if mesh was used)    11 0
Mouton [221] 35 21 14   3/21 (14 %), no mesh
Palanivelu [107] 8    8 0
Patie [222] 6    6 0
Saber [223] 8    8 0
Sanchez-Montes [224] 6   6   0
Singer [225] 8 8    0
Vos [226] 25 20 5   1/20 (5 %), no mesh
Weiss [227] 9 9    0
Total 318 152 105 44 7/318 (2.2 %)
Recurrence rate 7/318 (2.2 %) 7/152 (4.6 %) 0 0