Abstract
Determining the compressive strength of masonry structures is critical for assessing their service life and thus providing safety assurances to their occupants and valued stakeholders. This paper presents a methodology based on various data fusion systems for predicting the compressive strength using data collected from nondestructive testing. According to the experimental readings obtained from the laboratory tests for masonry wallettes, 44 samples are used to construct the training datasets and results validated against a masonry structure located in Kharagpur. The compressive strength of masonry units is predicted using statistical regression models and other state-of-the-art approaches. Two indices, namely the coefficient of determination (\(R^2\)) and root mean square error, are used to test the performance of different models. The results indicate that both neural network and neuro-fuzzy inference system have a superior predictive capacity than other models and can be reliably employed in the field to evaluate the compressive strength of brick–mortar masonry structures.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
ICOMOS Charter (2005) Principles for the analysis, conservation and structural restoration of architectural heritage. In: International committee on analysis and restoration of structures of architectural heritage. Recommendations for the analysis and restoration of structures of architectural heritage
Lourenço PB, Pina-Henriques J (2006) Validation of analytical and continuum numerical methods for estimating the compressive strength of masonry. Comput Struct 84(29–30):1977–1989
Köksal HO, Karakoç C, Yildirim H (2005) Compression behavior and failure mechanisms of concrete masonry prisms. J Mater Civ Eng 17(1):107–115
Binda L, Saisi A, Tiraboschi C (2000) Investigation procedures for the diagnosis of historic masonries Constr. Build Mater 14(4):199–233
Mishra M, Barman S, Maity D, Maiti DK (2018) Ant lion optimisation algorithm for structural damage detection using vibration data. J Civ Struct Health Monit 9(1):117–136
Masi A, Chiauzzi L (2013) An experimental study on the within-member variability of in situ concrete strength in RC building structures. Constr Build Mater 47:951–961
Brencich A, Sterpi E (2006) Compressive strength of solid clay brick masonry: calibration of experimental tests and theoretical issues. In: Laurenco PB, Roca P, Modena C, Agrawal S (eds) Structural analysis of historical construction. Macmillan, New Delhi, pp 1–8
Bogas JA, Gomes MG, Gomes A (2013) Compressive strength evaluation of structural lightweight concrete by non-destructive ultrasonic pulse velocity method. Ultrasonics 53(5):962–972
Sabbağ N, Uyanık O (2017) Prediction of reinforced concrete strength by ultrasonic velocities. J Appl Geophys 141:13–23
Gros XE (1996) NDT data fusion. Arnold Publisher, London, pp 1–205
McCann M, Forde MC (2011) Review of NDT methods in the assessment of concrete and masonry structures. NDT E Int 34(2):71–84
Nguyen NT, Sbartai ZM, Lataste JF, Breysse D, Bos F (2013) Assessing the spatial variability of concrete structures using NDT techniques—laboratory tests and case study. Constr Build Mater 49:240–250
IS 1992a IS 13311 (Part II): 1992 Non-destructive testing of concrete—methods of test (Rebound Hammer)
IS 1992b IS 13311 (Part I): 1992 non-destructive testing of concrete—methods of test (Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity)
Malhotra VM, Carino NJ (1991) Handbook on non-destructive testing of concrete. ASTM, CRC Press, Boca Raton
Rilem Report TC43-CND (1983) Draft recommendations for in situ concrete strength determination by combined non-destructive methods. Mater Struct 26(155):43–49
Uva G, Porco F, Fiore A (2016) The SonReb method: critical review and practical aspects. In: Proceedings of Italian concrete days, pp 161–171
Vasanellia E, Sileo M, Caliaa A, Aiello MA (2013) Non-destructive techniques to assess mechanical and physical properties of soft calcarenitic stones. Proc Chem 8:35–44
Breysse D (2012) Nondestructive evaluation of concrete strength: an historical review and a new perspective by combining NDT methods. Constr Build Mater 33:139–163
Vasconcelos G, Lourenco PB, Alves CSA, Pamplona J (2007) Prediction of the mechanical properties of granites by ultrasonic pulse velocity and Schmidt hammer hardness. In: North American Masonry Conference, Missouri USA
Debailleux L (2018) Schmidt hammer rebound hardness tests for the characterization of ancient fired clay bricks. Int J Archit Herit 13(2):288–297
Sbartai ZM, Laurens S, Elachachia SM, Payanc C (2012) Concrete properties evaluation by statistical fusion of NDT techniques. Constr Build Mater 37:943–950
Ramos LF, Miranda TF, Mishra M, Fernandes FM, Manning E (2015) A Bayesian approach for NDT data fusion: the Saint Torcato Church case study. Eng Struct 84(1):120–129
Mishra M (2013) A Bayesian approach for NDT data fusion. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Minho, Portugal
Kheder GF (1999) A two stage procedure for assessment of in situ concrete strength using combined non-destructive testing. Mater Struct 32:410–417
Demirboga R, Turkmen R, Karakoc MB (2004) Relationship between ultrasonic velocity and compressive strength for high-volume mineral-admixtured concrete. Cem Concr Res 34(12):2329–2336
Jain A, Kathuria A, Kumar A, Verma Y, Murari K (2013) Combined use of non-destructive tests for assessment of strength of concrete in structure. Proc Eng 54(2013):241–251
Brozovsky J (2014) Determine the compressive strength of calcium silicate bricks by combined nondestructive method. Sci World J 2014:1–5
Nobile L (2015) Prediction of concrete compressive strength by combined non-destructive methods. Meccanica 50(2):411–417
Binda L, Fontana A, Frigerio G (1988) Mechanical behaviour of brick masonries derived from unit and mortar characteristics. In: Proceedings of the 8th international brick/block masonry conference Dublin, pp 205–16
Atkinson RH, Noland JL, Abrams DP (1982) A deformation theory for stack bonded masonry prisms in compression. In: Proceedings of 7th international brick masonry conference, Melbourne University, Melbourne pp 565–576
CEN (1998) EN 1052-1:1998 Methods for test for masonry—Part I: determination of compressive strength
ACI Committee 530 (1999) Building code requirements for masonry structure. American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills
MSJC (2002) Masonry Standards Joint Committee, Building code requirements for masonry structures, ACI 530-02/ASCE 5-02/TMS 402-02, American Concrete Institute, Structural Engineering Institute of the American Society of Civil Engineers, The Masonry Society, Detroit
Mann W (1982) Statistical evaluation of tests on masonry by potential functions. In: Sixth international brick masonry conference
Hendry AW, Malek M (1986) Characteristic compressive strength of brickwork from collected test results. Mason Int 7:15–24
Dayaratnam P (1987) Brick and reinforced brick structures. Oxford and IBH, New Delhi
Bennett R, Boyd K, Flanagan R (1999) Compressive properties of structural clay tile prisms. J Struct Eng 123(7):920–926
Kaushik HB, Rai DC, Jain SK (2007) Stress-strain characteristics of clay brick masonry under uniaxial compression. J Mater Civ Eng 19(9):728–739
Ramamurthy K, Sathish V, Ambalavanan R (2000) Compressive strength prediction of hollow concrete block masonry prism. ACI Struct J 97(1):61–67
Dymiotis C, Gutlederer BM (2007) Allowing for uncertainties in the modeling of masonry compressive strength. Constr Build Mater 16(7):1385–1393
Gumaste KS, Rao KSN, Reddy BVV, Jagadish KS (2007) Strength and elasticity of brick masonry prisms and wallettes under compression. Mater Struct 40(2):241–253
Costigan A, Pavía S, Kinnane O (2015) An experimental evaluation of prediction models for the mechanical behavior of unreinforced, lime-mortar masonry under compression. J Build Eng 4:283–294
Trtnik G, Kavcic F, Turk G (2009) Prediction of concrete strength using ultrasonic pulse velocity and artificial neural networks. Ultrasonics 49:53–60
Mishra M, Agarwal A, Maity D (2019) Neural-network-based approach to predict the deflection of plain, steel-reinforced, and bamboo-reinforced concrete beams from experimental data. SN Appl Sci 1:584. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42452-019-0622-1
Mashrei MA, Abdulrazzaq N, Abdalla TY, Rahmand MS (2010) Neural networks model and adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system for predicting the moment capacity of ferrocement members. Eng Struct 32(6):1723–1734
Zhou Q, Wang F, Zhu F (2016) Estimation of compressive strength of hollow concrete masonry prisms using artificial neural networks and adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference systems. Constr Build Mater 125:417–426
Garzón-Roca J, Marco CO, Adam JM (2013) Compressive strength of masonry made of clay bricks and cement mortar: estimation based on neural networks and fuzzy logic. Eng Struct 48:21–27
ud Darain AKM, Shamshirband S, Jumaat MZ, Obaydullah M (2015) Adaptive neuro fuzzy prediction of deflection and cracking behavior of NSM strengthened RC beams. Constr Build Mater 98:276–285
Bilgeham M (2011) Comparison of ANFIS and NN models—with a study in critical buckling load estimation. Appl Soft Comput 11(4):3779–3791
Zhu F, Wu Y (2014) A rapid structural damage detection method using integrated ANFIS and interval modeling technique. Appl Soft Comput 25:473–484
Sobhani J, Najimi M, Pourkhorshidi AR, Parhizkar T (2010) Prediction of the compressive strength of no-slump concrete: a comparative study of regression, neural network and ANFIS models. Constr Build Mater 24(5):709–718
Öztas̨ A, Pala M, Özbay E, Kanca E, C̨ağlar N, Bhatti MA (2006) Predicting the compressive strength and slump of high strength concrete using neural network. Constr Build Mater 20(9):769–775
Madandoust R, Bungey JH, Ghavidel R (2012) Prediction of the concrete compressive strength by means of core testing using GMDH-type neural network and ANFIS models. Comput Mater Sci 51(1):261–272
Yuan Z, Wang LN, Ji X (2014) Prediction of concrete compressive strength: research on hybrid models genetic based algorithms and ANFIS. Adv Eng Softw 67:156–163
Khademi F, Jamal SM, Deshpande N, Londhe S (2016) Predicting strength of recycled aggregate concrete using artificial neural network, adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system and multiple linear regression. Int J Sustain Built Environ 5(2):355–369
Sadrmomtazi A, Sobhani J, Mirgozar MA (2013) Modeling compressive strength of EPS lightweight concrete using regression, neural network and ANFIS. Constr Build Mater 42:205–216
Cüneyt Aydin A, Tortum A, Yavuz M (2006) Prediction of concrete elastic modulus using adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system. Civ Eng Environ Syst 23(4):295–309
Ahmadi-Nedushan B (2012) Prediction of elastic modulus of normal and high strength concrete using ANFIS and optimal nonlinear regression models. Constr Build Mater 36:665–673
Duan ZH, Kou SC, Poon CS (2013) Using artificial neural networks for predicting the elastic modulus of recycled aggregate concrete. Constr Build Mater 44:524–532
Bedirhanoglu I (2014) A practical neuro-fuzzy model for estimating modulus of elasticity of concrete. Struct Eng Mech 51(2):249–265
Saridemir M (2009) Predicting the compressive strength of mortars containing metakaolin by artificial neural networks and fuzzy logic. Adv Eng Softw 40(9):920–927
Singh R, Kainthola A, Singh TN (2012) Estimation of elastic constant of rocks using an ANFIS approach. Appl Soft Comput 12(1):40–45
Marashi M, Torkashvand AM, Ahmadi A, Esfandyari M (2018) Adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system: estimation of soil aggregates stability. Acta Ecol Sin 39(1):95–101
Moayedi H, Hayati S (2018) Modelling and optimization of ultimate bearing capacity of strip footing near a slope by soft computing methods. Appl Soft Comput 66:208–219
Esmaeili M, Osanloo M, Rashidinejad F, Bazzazi AA, Taji A (2014) Multiple regression, ANN and ANFIS models for prediction of backbreak in the open pit blasting. Eng Comput 30(4):549–558
Ghasemi E, Kalhori H, Bagherpour R (2016) A new hybrid ANFIS-PSO model for prediction of peak particle velocity due to bench blasting. Eng Comput 32(4):607–614
Jiang W, Arslan CA, Tehrani MS et al (2018) Simulating the peak particle velocity in rock blasting projects using a neuro-fuzzy inference system. Eng Comput 1:9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00366-018-0659-6
Terzi S (2013) Modeling for pavement roughness using the ANFIS approach. Adv Eng Softw 57:59–64
Orban Z, Gutermann M (2009) Assessment of masonry arch railway bridges using non-destructive in-situ testing methods. Eng Struct 31(10):228–2298
Wu RT (2018) Data fusion approaches for structural health monitoring and system identification: past, present, and future. Struct Health Monit 1–35 https://doi.org/10.1177/1475921718798769
Bhatia AS (2018) Determination of compressive strength of the burnt clay brick mortar masonry structure (Unreinforced) using non-destructive experimental techniques. M. Tech thesis Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, 73 pages
Mishra M, Bhatia AS, Maity D (2019) Support vector machine for determining the compressive strength of brick-mortar masonry using NDT data fusion (case study: Kharagpur, India). Appl Sci 1(6):564. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42452-019-0590-5
Bureau of Indian Standard (BIS) 3495-1 TO 4 (1992) Methods of tests of burnt clay building bricks, pp 1–10
Bureau of Indian Standard (BIS) (1992) Common burnt clay building bricks. IS 1077:1992
Bureau of Indian Standard (BIS) (1999) Specification for sand for masonry mortars IS:2116-1980, 1980
RILEM, TC 127-MS MS. D.2 (1998) Determination of masonry rebound hardness. Mater Struct 31:375–377
RILEM (1996) Measurement of ultrasonic pulse velocity for masonry units and walletttes, pp 467–469
Hagan MT, Menhaj MB (1994) Training feedforward networks with the Marquardt algorithm. IEEE Trans Neural Netw 5(6):989–993
Jang JSR (1993) ANFIS: adaptive-network-based fuzzy inference system. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern 23(3):665–685
Takagi T, Sugeno M (1985) Fuzzy identification of systems and its applications to modelling and control. IEEE Trans Syst 15:116–132
Zadeh LA (1965) Fuzzy sets. Inf Control 8:338–353
MATLAB (2010) Version 7.10.0 (R2010a) Natick. The MathWorks Inc., Massachusetts
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
No potential conflict of interest is reported by the authors.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mishra, M., Bhatia, A.S. & Maity, D. A comparative study of regression, neural network and neuro-fuzzy inference system for determining the compressive strength of brick–mortar masonry by fusing nondestructive testing data. Engineering with Computers 37, 77–91 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00366-019-00810-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00366-019-00810-4