Abstract
Given spatially sparse or lower dimensional experimental measurements, approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) and numerical simulations can be used to estimate unknown characteristics of complex multi-physics engineering systems. Here, we describe the ABC approach and use it to estimate the speed of high-temperature gases exiting an industrially relevant catalytic burner, as well as to estimate the completeness of combustion within the burner. Using vertical profiles of absorption-weighted average temperature from laser absorption spectroscopy (LAS) at three different burner operating conditions, we combine ABC and large eddy simulations (LES) to generate posterior distributions of inflow speeds and heat addition characteristics above the burner. We show that the ABC method correctly estimates trends in the inflow speed for different conditions, and we find that there is a strong likelihood of incomplete combustion for higher equivalence ratios. We evaluate the predictive capability of the approach using an observing system experiment, indicating that the ABC method, when combined with LES, is able to accurately predict LAS measurements. We thus demonstrate that ABC is an effective tool for obtaining additional insights from available experimental measurements, thereby improving understanding of real-world engineering systems.
Graphic abstract
Similar content being viewed by others
Availability of data and material
All data and analysis/figure scripts will be placed on Zenodo for permanent archiving.
References
Abdessalem AB, Dervilis N, Wagg D, Worden K (2018) Model selection and parameter estimation in structural dynamics using approximate Bayesian computation. Mech Syst Signal Process 99:306
Adowski TR, Bauman PT (2018) A numerical study of bayesian inference of surface catalycity in low speed reacting flow using laser absorption spectroscopy. In: 2018 Joint Thermophysics and Heat Transfer Conference (American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Atlanta, Georgia, 2018). https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2018-4290
Beaumont MA (2010) Approximate Bayesian computation in evolution and ecology. Annu Rev Ecol Evol Syst 41(379–406):1
Beaumont MA, Zhang W, Balding DJ (2002) Approximate Bayesian computation in population genetics. Genetics 162(4):2025
Bolshov MA, Kuritsyn YA, Romanovskii YV (2015) Tunable diode laser spectroscopy as a technique for combustion diagnostics. Spectrochim Acta Part B 106:45
Bonnie JM, Sanford G (1996) Computer program for calculation of complex chemical equilibrium compositions and applications. User’s Manual and Program Discription
Bouttier F, Kelly G (2001) Observing-system experiments in the ECMWF 4D-Var data assimilation system. Q J R Meteorol Soc 127(574):1469
Cai T, Tan T, Wang G, Chen W, Gao X (2009) Gas temperature measurements using wavelength modulation spectroscopy at \(1.39\,\mu \text{m}\). Opt Appl 39(1)
Chai T, Draxler RR (2014) Root mean square error (RMSE) or mean absolute error (MAE)? Arguments against avoiding RMSE in the literature. Geosci Model Dev 7(3):1247
Christopher JD, Lapointe C, Wimer NT, Hayden TRS, Grooms I, Rieker GB, Hamlington PE (2017) Parameter Estimation for a Turbulent Buoyant Jet with Rotating Cylinder Using Approximate Bayesian Computation. AIAA Paper, AIAA-2017-3629
Christopher JD, Wimer NT, Hayden TRS, Lapointe C, Grooms I, Rieker GB, Hamlington PE (2017) Parameter estimation for a turbulent buoyant jet using approximate bayesian computation. AIAA Paper, AIAA-2017-0531
Christopher JD, Wimer NT, Lapointe C, Hayden TRS, Grooms I, Rieker GB, Hamlington PE (2018) Parameter estimation for complex thermal-fluid flows using approximate Bayesian computation. Phys Rev Fluids 3:104602
Constantine PG, Wang Q, Doostan A, Iaccarino G (2011) A surrogate accelerated Bayesian inverse analysis of the HyShot II flight data. AIAA Paper, AIAA-2011-2037
Cottilard SA (2011) Catalytic combustion. Nova Science Publ., New York
Csilléry K, Blum MGB, Gaggiotti OE, François O (2010) Approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) in practice. Trends Ecol Evolut 25(7):410
Daily JW (1997) Laser induced fluorescence spectroscopy in flames. Prog Energy Combust Sci 23(2):133
Daun KJ, Grauer SJ, Hadwin PJ (2016) Chemical species tomography of turbulent flows: discrete ill-posed and rank deficient problems and the use of prior information. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transf 172:58
Doronina OA, Christopher JD, Towery CAZ, Hamlington PE, Dahm WJA (2018) Autonomic closure for turbulent flows using approximate bayesian computation. AIAA Paper, AIAA-2018-0594
Doronina OA, Towery CAZ, Christopher JD, Grooms I, Hamlington PE (2019) Turbulence model development using Markov chain Monte Carlo approximate Bayesian computation. AIAA Paper, AIAA-2019-1883
Duraisamy K, Iaccarino G, Xiao H (2019) Turbulence Modeling in the Age of Data. Annu Rev Fluid Mech 51(1):357
Dwight RP, Han Z (2009) Efficient uncertainty quantification using gradient-enhanced kriging. AIAA Paper, AIAA-2009-2276
Ebert V, Fernholz T, Giesemann C, Pitz H, Teichert H, Wolfrum J, Jaritz H (2000) Simultaneous diode-laser-based in situ detection of multiple species and temperature in a gas-fired power plant. Proc Combust Inst 28(1):423
Emmert J, Grauer SJ, Wagner S, Daun KJ (2019) Efficient Bayesian inference of absorbance spectra from transmitted intensity spectra. Opt Express 27(19):26893
Emmert J, Wagner S, Daun KJ (2020) Quantifying the spatial resolution of the maximum a posteriori estimate in linear, rank-deficient, Bayesian hard field tomography. Measur Sci Technol. https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6501/abb550
Estumano DC, Hamilton FC, Colaço MJ, Leiroz AJK, Orlande HRB, Carvalho RN, Dulikravich GS (2015) Bayesian estimate of mass fraction of burned fuel in internal combustion engines using pressure measurements. Eng Optim IV, 997–1003
Fagundes NJR, Ray N, Beaumont MA, Neuenschwander S, Salzano FM, Bonatto SL, Excoffier L (2007) Statistical evaluation of alternative models of human evolution. Proc Natl Acad Sci 104(45):17614
Fox CW, Roberts SJ (2012) A tutorial on variational Bayesian inference. Artif Intell Rev 38(2):85
Frank J, Kaiser S (2008) High-resolution imaging of dissipative structures in a turbulent jet flame with laser Rayleigh scattering. Exp Fluids 44:221
Goldenstein CS, Hanson RK (2015) Diode-laser measurements of linestrength and temperature-dependent lineshape parameters for H2O transitions near \(1.4\,\mu \text{ m }\) using Voigt, Rautian, Galatry, and speed-dependent Voigt profiles. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transf 152:127
Goldenstein CS, Mathews GC (2020) Simulation technique enabling calibration-free frequency-modulation spectroscopy measurements of gas conditions and lineshapes with modulation frequencies spanning kHz to GHz. Appl Opt 59(5):1491
Goldenstein CS, Strand CL, Schultz IA, Sun K, Jeffries JB, Hanson RK (2014) Fitting of calibration-free scanned-wavelength-modulation spectroscopy spectra for determination of gas properties and absorption lineshapes. Appl Opt 53(3):356
Goldenstein CS, Spearrin RM, Jeffries JB, Hanson RK (2017) Infrared laser-absorption sensing for combustion gases. Prog Energy Combust Sci 60:132
Grauer SJ (2018) Bayesian methods for gas-phase tomography. PhD Thesis
Grauer SJ, Hadwin PJ, Daun KJ (2016) Bayesian approach to the design of chemical species tomography experiments. Appl Opt 55(21):5772
Grauer SJ, Hadwin PJ, Sipkens TA, Daun KJ (2017) Measurement-based meshing, basis selection, and prior assignment in chemical species tomography. Opt Express 25(21):25135
Grauer SJ, Tsang RW, Daun KJ (2017) Broadband chemical species tomography: measurement theory and a proof-of-concept emission detection experiment. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transf 198:145
Greenshields C (2016) OpenFOAM | The OpenFOAM Foundation http://openfoam.org/
Hanson RK, Falcone PK (1978) Temperature measurement technique for high-temperature gases using a tunable diode laser. Appl Opt 17(16):2477
Hayden TRS, Rieker GB (2016) Large amplitude wavelength modulation spectroscopy for sensitive measurements of broad absorbers. Opt Express 24(24):27910
Hayden TRS, Malarich N, Petrykowski DJ, Nigam SP, Christopher JD, Lapointe C, Wimer NT, Hamlington P, Rieker GB (2019a) OH radical measurements in combustion environments using wavelength modulation spectroscopy and dual-frequency comb spectroscopy near 1491 nm. Appl Phys B 125
Hayden T, Petrykowski D, Sanchez A, Nigam S, Lapointe C, Christopher J, Wimer N, Upadhye A, Strobel M, Hamlington P, Rieker G (2019b) Characterization of OH, \(\text{ H}_2\text{ O }\), and temperature profiles in industrial flame treatment systems interacting with polymer films. Proc Combust Inst 37(2):1571
Hayden TRS, Wimer NT, Lapointe C, Christopher JD, Nigam SP, Upadhye A, Strobel M, Hamlington PE, Rieker GB (2020) Characterization of the Buoyant Jet above a Catalytic Combustor Using Wavelength Modulation Spectroscopy. Combust Sci Technol 192(6):997
Huang Q, Wang F, Zhang H, Yan J, Ni M, Cen K (2013) In-situ CO measurement of gas and oil combustion flame using near infrared tunable diode laser with direct and modulated absorption signals. Opt Commun 306:99
Jahn W, Rein G, Torero JL (2012) Forecasting fire dynamics using inverse computational fluid dynamics and tangent linearisation. Adv Eng Softw 47(1):114
Khalil M, Najm HN (2018) Probabilistic inference of reaction rate parameters from summary statistics. Combustion Theory and Modelling pp 1–31
Lintusaari J, Gutmann MU, Dutta R, Kaski S, Corander J (2017) Fundamentals and recent developments in approximate Bayesian computation. Syst Biol 66(1):e66
Lucas DD, Gowardhan A, Cameron-Smith P, Baskett RL (2016) Impact of meteorological inflow uncertainty on tracer transport and source estimation in urban atmospheres. Atmos Environ 143:120
Ma L, Wu Y, Xu W, Hammack SD, Lee T, Carter CD (2016) Comparison of 2D and 3D flame topography measured by planar laser-induced fluorescence and tomographic chemiluminescence. Appl Opt 55(20):5310
Madsen H (2003) Parameter estimation in distributed hydrological catchment modelling using automatic calibration with multiple objectives. Adv Water Resour 26(2):205
Marin JM, Pudlo P, Robert CP, Ryder RJ (2012) Approximate Bayesian computational methods. Stat Comput 22(6):1167
Marjoram P, Molitor J, Plagnol V, Tavaré S (2003) Markov chain Monte Carlo without likelihoods. Proc Natl Acad Sci 100(26):15324
Mcenally CS, Pfefferle LD, Schaffer AM, Long MB, Mohammed RK, Smooke MD, Colkei MB (2000) Characterization of a coflowing methane/air non-premixed flame with computer modeling, Rayleigh-Raman imaging, and on-line mass spectrometry. Proc Combust Inst 28(2):2063
McManus T, Sutton J (2020) Simultaneous 2D filtered Rayleigh scattering thermometry and stereoscopic particle image velocimetry measurements in turbulent non-premixed flames. Exp Fluids 61:134
Mosbach S, Braumann A, Man PLW, Kastner CA, Brownbridge GPE, Kraft M (2012) Iterative improvement of Bayesian parameter estimates for an engine model by means of experimental design. Combust Flame 159(3):1303
Nott DJ, Marshall L, Brown J (2012) Generalized likelihood uncertainty estimation (GLUE) and approximate Bayesian computation: What’s the connection? Water Resources Research 48(12)
Oberkampf, WL, Trucano T (2000) Validation methodology in computational fluid dynamics. AIAA Paper, AIAA-2000-2549
Oberkampf WL, Roy CJ (2010) Verification and validation in scientific computing. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Oberkampf WL, Trucano TG (2002) Verification and validation in computational fluid dynamics. Prog Aerosp Sci 38(3):209
Oberkampf WL, Trucano TG, Hirsch C (2004) Verification, validation, and predictive capability in computational engineering and physics. Appl Mech Rev 57(5):345
Olson B (2016) Stochastic weather generation with approximate bayesian computation. Master’s thesis, University of Colorado at Boulder
Pan R, Daun KJ, Dreier T, Schulz C (2017) Uncertainty quantification and design-of-experiment in absorption-based aqueous film parameter measurements using Bayesian inference. Appl Opt 56(11):E1
Pandey S, Schumacher J, Sreenivasan KR (2020) A perspective on machine learning in turbulent flows. J Turbulence 0(0):1
Pemha E, Nyobe EN (2011) Genetic algorithm approach and experimental confirmation of a laser-based diagnostic technique for the local thermal turbulence in a hot wind tunnel jet. Progress Electromagn Res 28:325
Philippe LC, Hanson RK (1993) Laser diode wavelength-modulation spectroscopy for simultaneous measurement of temperature, pressure, and velocity in shock-heated oxygen flows. Appl Opt 32(30):6090
Qu Z, Ghorbani R, Valiev D, Schmidt FM (2015) Calibration-free scanned wavelength modulation spectroscopy-application to H 2 O and temperature sensing in flames. Opt Express 23(12):16492
Rieker GB, Jeffries JB, Hanson RK (2009) Calibration-free wavelength-modulation spectroscopy for measurements of gas temperature and concentration in harsh environments. Appl Opt 48(29):5546
Rohmer J, Rousseau M, Lemoine A, Pedreros R, Lambert J, Benki A (2018) Source characterisation by mixing long-running tsunami wave numerical simulations and historical observations within a metamodel-aided ABC setting. Stoch Environ Res Risk Assess 32:967–984. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00477-017-1423-y
Rothman LS, Gordon IE, Babikov Y, Barbe A, Benner DC, Bernath PF, Birk M, Bizzocchi L, Boudon V, Brown LR (2013) The HITRAN2012 molecular spectroscopic database. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transf 130:4
Sadegh M, Vrugt JA (2013) Bridging the gap between GLUE and formal statistical approaches: approximate Bayesian computation. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci 17(12)
Salinger AG, Pawlowski RP, Shadid JN, van Bloemen Waanders BG (2004) Computational analysis and optimization of a chemical vapor deposition reactor with large-scale computing. Ind Eng Chem Res 43(16):4612
Schmidt A, van der Kley S, Wagner S (2020) Optically accessible generic exhaust gas test bench for the investigation of fundamental SCR-relevant processes. Appl Opt 59(23):6953
Schulz C, Sick V (2005) Tracer-LIF diagnostics: quantitative measurement of fuel concentration, temperature and fuel/air ratio in practical combustion systems. Prog Energy Combust Sci 31(1):75
Scott DW (1979) On optimal and data-based histograms. Biometrika 66(3):605
Sipkens TA, Hadwin PJ, Grauer SJ, Daun KJ (2018) Predicting the heat of vaporization of iron at high temperatures using time-resolved laser-induced incandescence and Bayesian model selection. J Appl Phys 123(9):095103
Smith RC (2013) Uncertainty quantification: theory, implementation, and applications, vol 12. SIAM, New Delhi
Sousa J, García-Sánchez C, Gorlé C (2018) Improving urban flow predictions through data assimilation. Build Environ 132:282
Spearrin RM, Goldenstein CS, Jeffries JB, Hanson RK (2014) Quantum cascade laser absorption sensor for carbon monoxide in high-pressure gases using wavelength modulation spectroscopy. Appl Opt 53(9):1938
Stroud JR, Katzfuss M, Wikle CK (2018) A Bayesian adaptive ensemble Kalman filter for sequential state and parameter estimation. Mon Weather Rev 146(1):373
Sun K, Chao X, Sur R, Goldenstein CS, Jeffries JB, Hanson RK (2013) Analysis of calibration-free wavelength-scanned wavelength modulation spectroscopy for practical gas sensing using tunable diode lasers. Meas Sci Technol 24(12):125203
Sunnåker M, Busetto AG, Numminen E, Corander J, Foll M, Dessimoz C (2013) Approximate Bayesian Computation. PLoS Comput Biol 9(1):e1002803
Toni T, Welch D, Strelkowa N, Ipsen A, Stumpf MPH (2009) Approximate Bayesian computation scheme for parameter inference and model selection in dynamical systems. J R Soc Interface 6(31):187
Vakilzadeh MK, Beck JL, Abrahamsson T (2018) Using approximate Bayesian computation by Subset Simulation for efficient posterior assessment of dynamic state-space model classes. SIAM J Sci Comput 40(1):B168
van der Kley S, Emmert J, Schmidt A, Dreizler A, Wagner S (2020) Tomographic spectrometer for the temporally-resolved 2D reconstruction of gas phase parameters within a generic SCR test rig. Proc Combust Inst. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proci.2020.09.009
Vrbik I, Deardon R, Feng Z, Gardner A, Braun J (2012) Using individual-level models for infectious disease spread to model spatio-temporal combustion dynamics. Bayesian Anal 7(3):615
Vrugt JA, Sadegh M (2013) Toward diagnostic model calibration and evaluation: approximate Bayesian computation. Water Resour Res 49(7):4335
Wagner S, Fisher BT, Fleming JW, Ebert V (2009) TDLAS-based in situ measurement of absolute acetylene concentrations in laminar 2D diffusion flames. Proc Combust Inst 32(1):839
Wang S, Xu X (2006) Parameter estimation of internal thermal mass of building dynamic models using genetic algorithm. Energy Convers Manag 47(13–14):1927
Wang Y, Chatterjee P, de Ris JL (2011) Large eddy simulation of fire plumes. Proc Combust Inst 33(2):2473
Weller HG, Tabor G, Jasak H, Fureby C (1998) A tensorial approach to computational continuum mechanics using object-oriented techniques. Comput Phys 12(6):620
Yamaguchi M, Iriguchi T, Nakazawa T, Wu CC (2009) An observing system experiment for Typhoon Conson (2004) using a singular vector method and DOTSTAR data. Mon Weather Rev 137(9):2801
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge helpful discussions with Mark Strobel, Melvyn Branch, and Aniruddha Upadhye.
Funding
D.P., C.L., N.T.W., and T.R.S.H. acknowledge gift support from the 3M Company. O.A.D. was supported by NASA award NNX15AU24A-03. C.L. was supported by the NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program under award DGE 1144083. P.E.H. was supported, in part, by AFOSR Award No. FA9550-17-1-0144. J.D.C. and G.B.R. were supported, in part, by NSF Award No. CBET 1454496 and AFOSR Award No. FA9550-17-1-0224. Computing resources were provided by DoD HPCMP under a Frontier project award and by the Air Force Research Laboratory.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest or competing interests.
Code availability
The code used to perform the simulations is OpenFOAM, which is open-source and publicly available at https://openfoam.org.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Christopher, J.D., Doronina, O.A., Petrykowski, D. et al. Flow parameter estimation using laser absorption spectroscopy and approximate Bayesian computation. Exp Fluids 62, 43 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00348-020-03122-2
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00348-020-03122-2