Non-photosynthetic oxygen production and non-respiratory oxygen uptake in the dark: a theory of oxygen dynamics in plankton communities

Abstract

Plankton respiration is commonly measured in terms of oxygen uptake, usually employing the Winkler method, much less commonly the polarographic method. Both methods produce results that can be misinterpreted when H₂O₂ production and decomposition are ignored. This paper: (1) presents experimental evidence of significant H₂O₂ involvement during plankton incubation in dark bottles, (2) explains how results differ between the Winkler and polarographic methods in the presence of H₂O₂, (3) discusses how this difference is clouded by side issues of variability inherent in the Winkler technique and the use of different bottle sizes, and (4) shows that unexpected and variable results of light-/dark-bottle incubations can all be explained by a theory of H₂O₂ production and decomposition. During an initial period in the dark, when plankton respiration has been poisoned by mercuric chloride or chloroform, O₂ increase can be measured with a polarographic oxy‐gen sensor (POS). The trend in O₂ changes is linear for several days when only respiration is occurring, but curvilinear when there is concurrent O₂ production. O₂ production in the dark and H₂O₂ decomposition are one and the same process. Measurement of oxygen by Winkler analysis and POS produce different results when H₂O₂ is present because the former method measures oxidizing equivalent while a POS measures O₂ pressure. A real difference in results between the two methods is prima facie evidence that H₂O₂ is involved. The synthesis of this new empirical evidence with diverse knowledge from various fields shows that the common practice of estimating gross community primary production from oxygen changes in light and dark bottles is based on untenable assumptions.