Drawing on recent ideas in the literature to model ‘animal spirits’, the paper considers the investment of heterogeneous firms that probabilistically switch between optimism and pessimism. Combining the herding component in the endogenous transition probabilities with a Harrodian feedback, a one-dimensional macroeconomic adjustment equation is set up. Assuming a ‘neutral’ herding coefficient and considering the local dynamics around the steady state with normal utilization, the equation shows a one-to-one correspondence with the neo-Kaleckian baseline model of Harrodian instability. The paper thus provides a rigorous specification of its sentiment adjustment story. In a second and innovative step, the firms are additionally allowed to be neutral. In this variant, up to three ‘fully-adjusted’ steady states come into being, which, however, cannot be distinguished from a macroeconomic point of view. While two of them exhibit the usual instability, it turns out that the equilibrium with the highest share of neutral agents can easily be locally stable. The result shows that the common macroeconomic view of Harrodian instability that essentially treats all firms alike may be too simple. Also, the economic significance of the paper’s findings goes beyond the present very limited framework.
Franke R (2008) Microfounded animal spirits and Goodwinian income distribution dynamics. In: Flaschel P, Landesmann M (eds) Effective demand, income distribution and growth. Research In memory of the work of Richard M. Goodwin. Routledge, London, pp 372–398Google Scholar
Franke R (2012) Microfounded animal spirits in the new macroeconomic consensus. Stud Nonlin Dyn Econometr 16:4Google Scholar
Franke R (2017) Some thoughts about conflicting claims in a long-run equilibrium. Working paper, University of KielGoogle Scholar
Franke R, Westerhoff F (2017) Taking stock: a rigorous modelling of animal spirits in macroeconomics. J Econ Surv 31:1152–1182. Reprinted in R. Veneziani and L. Zamparelli (eds): Analytical Political Economy, Oxford: Wiley Blackwell; pp 5–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Franke R, Westerhoff F (2019) Different compositions of animal spirits and their impact on macroeconomic stability. Econ Model 76:117–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gomes O, Sprott JC (2017) Sentiment-driven limit cycles and chaos. J Evol Econ 27:729–760CrossRefGoogle Scholar