Abstract
For many years, a group of sculpted clay faces, in desperate and immediate need of conservation, tenuously clung to the walls of the dug-out space called a “tunnel” beneath the former Wesleyan Methodist Church, the home of a noted abolitionist and social-reform oriented congregation in downtown Syracuse, New York. Archaeological and historical research indicates a 19th-century origin for the faces. The church openly participated in abolition and the Underground Railroad, and housed a national abolitionist press. However, even in a pro-emancipation community such as Syracuse, the dangers for refugees fleeing bondage were real, and the consequences of capture were life threatening. This was particularly true after the passage of the Fugitive Slave Act in 1850. This study presents evidence that the clay faces may have been created by African American refugees from slavery. Moreover, it describes a community’s efforts to conserve and protect this resource.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
American Wesleyan 1877 American Wesleyan, 8 November 1877.
Armstrong, Douglas V., and LouAnn Wurst 1998 Faces of the Past: Archaeology of an Underground Railroad Site in Syracuse, New York. Syracuse University Archaeological Research Center Report, Volume 10 (1).
Brieaddy, Frank 1998 The Post Standard, 7 January 1998:Sec B2.
Brown, Kenneth L., and Doreen C. Cooper 1990 Structural Continuity in an African American Slave and Tenant Community. Historical Archaeology, 24(4): 7–19.
Chase, Franklin H. 1924 Syracuse and Its Environs: A History. Lewis Historical Pub, New York, NY.
Cross, Whitney R. 1950 The Burned Out District: Social and Intellectual History of Enthusiastic Religion in Western New York, 1800–1850. Cornell University Press, New York.
Fordham, Monroe (editor) 1989 The African American Presence in New York State History: Four Regional History Surveys. New York African American Institute, SUNY Albany, NY.
Gunderson, Rev. Gunnar A. n.d. A history of the congregation. Typed letter, The First Gospel Church. Syracuse, NY.
Hardin, Evamaria, and Jon Crispin 1993 Syracuse Landmarks: An AIA Guide to Downtown Historical Districts. Syracuse University Press, Syracuse, NY.
Kaufman, Paul Leslie 1994 Logical Luther Lee and the Methodist War against Slavery. Doctoral dissertation, Department of History, Kent State University, OH.
Knappenburger, Rev. J. B. 1933 Reflections of a Minister. Newspaper file 1933, Onondaga Historical Association, Syracuse, NY.
Lee, Rev. Luther 1843 No title. True Wesleyan, 28 October. Wesleyan Archives, Indianapolis, IN.
Lee, Rev. Luther 1850 Editorial. True Wesleyan, 9 November. Wesleyan Archives, Indianapolis, IN.
Lee, Rev. Luther 1882. Autobiography of the Rev. Luther Lee D. D. Phillips and Hunt, New York, NY.
Matlack, Lucius C. 1849 The History of American Slavery and Methodism, from 1780–1849. Wesleyan Book Concern, New York, NY.
Meyers, John L. 1962 The Beginning of the Anti-Slavery Agencies in New York State, 1833–1836. New York History, 43: 149–181.
National Park Service 1995 Underground Railroad: Special Resources Study. National Parks Service, Denver Service Center, CO.
New York State Office of Parks Recreation and Historic Preservation 1997 Guide to the Survey of Historic Resources Associated with African Americans in New York State. New York State Department of Parks Recreation and Historic Preservation, Albany, NY.
Sernett, Milton 1989 On Freedom’s Threshold: The African American Presence in Central New York, 1760–1940. In The African American Presence in New York State History: Four Regional History Surveys, Monroe Fordham, editor. New York African American Institute, SUNY, Albany, NY.
Sperry, Earl E. 1924 The Jerry Rescue. Onondaga Historical Association, Syracuse, NY.
Syracuse Journal 1858 Syracuse Journal, 3 July 1858.
Syracuse Journal 1879 Syracuse Journal, 14 March 1879.
Syracuse Planning Department 1979 National Register Nomination Form for the Columbus Circle/Montgomery Street National Register District. Manuscript, Community Planning, Syracuse, NY.
Syracuse Planning Department 1981 Local Columbus Circle/Montgomery Street Preservation District, Case File PD-80-1. Manuscript, Community Planning, Syracuse, NY.
Syracuse Standard 1852 Syracuse Standard, 18 June 1852.
Syracuse Standard 1858 Syracuse Standard, 10 July 1858.
Syracuse Standard 1898 Syracuse Standard, 10 January 1898.
Wesley, John 1774 Thoughts on Slavery. In The Works of John Wesley. Zondervan Publishing House, Grand Rapids, MI.
WM-ACM (Wesleyan Methodist, Annual Conference Minutes) 1843 Annual Conference Minutes. Wesleyan Archive, Indianapolis, IN.
WM-ACM (Wesleyan Methodist, Annual Conference Minutes) 1854–1855 Annual Conference Minutes. Wesleyan Archive, Indianapolis, IN
WMC-MR (Wesleyan Methodist Church, Membership Record) 1843 Membership Record of the Wesleyan Methodist Church of Syracuse (1843–1846). Onondaga Historical Association, Syracuse, NY.
WMC-MR (Wesleyan Methodist Church, Membership Record) 1851 Membership Record of the Wesleyan Methodist Church of Syracuse (1847–1858). Onondaga Historical Association, Syracuse, NY.
WMC-TR (Wesleyan Methodist Church, Trustee Records) 1843 Founding of the Wesleyan Methodist Church. Onondaga Historical Association, Syracuse, NY.
WMC-TR (Wesleyan Methodist Church, Trustee Records) 1845 Electing Trustees and Planning for the Construction of a Building. Onondaga Historical Association, Syracuse, NY.
WMC-TR (Wesleyan Methodist Church, Trustee Records) 1847 Note on Payment of Loan on Building. Onondaga Historical Association, Syracuse, NY.
WMC-TR (Wesleyan Methodist Church, Trustee Records) 1854 Note on Gift for Abolition Cause to Luther Lee. Handwritten manuscript, Onondaga Historical Association, Syracuse, NY.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Armstrong, D.V., Wurst, L. Clay Faces in an Abolitionist Church: The Wesleyan Methodist Church in Syracuse, New York. Hist Arch 37, 19–37 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03376601
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03376601