Advertisement

Monash Bioethics Review

, Volume 21, Issue 4, pp S66–S81 | Cite as

The ethics of germ line gene manipulation — a five dimensional debate

  • Lucy Carter
Articles
  • 122 Downloads

Abstract

Contributors to the debate surrounding the ethics of germ line gene manipulation have by and large concentrated their efforts on discussions of the potential risks that are associated with the use of this technology. Many international advisory committees have ruled out the acceptability of germ line gene manipulation at least for the time being. The purpose of this work is to generate much needed discussion on the many other ethical issues concerning the implementation of not only germ line gene manipulation but also other related biotechnologies. In this paper I systematically investigate and analyse the most salient issues put forward by proponents and opponents alike. I argue that if germ line manipulation proves to be a safe and effective procedure, then the principle of beneficence imposes on the medical profession a moral duty to pursue the technology.

Keywords

Potential Risk Ethical Issue Medical Profession Advisory Committee Germ Line 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Bibliography

  1. Anderson, F. Human gene therapy: scientific and ethical considerations. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1985:10:275–291.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Baird, P. Altering human genes: social, ethical, and legal implications. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 1994:37(4):566–575.Google Scholar
  3. Berger, E. & Gert, B. Genetic disorders and the ethical status of germ-line gene therapy. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1991:16:667–683.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bonnicksen, A. National and international approaches to human germ-line gene therapy. Politics and the Life Sciences 1994:13:39–49.Google Scholar
  5. Chadwick, R. Playing god. Cogito 1989:3:186–193.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Courts, MC. Human gene therapy. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 1994:4(1):63–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. De Wachter, M. Ethical aspects of human germ-line gene therapy. Bioethics 1993:7(2/3): 166–177CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Drlica, Karl (1997) Understanding DNA and Gene Cloning, John Wiley & Sons, New York.Google Scholar
  9. Fletcher, J. & Anderson, W. Germ-line gene therapy: a new stage of debate. Law, Medicine and Healthcare 1992:20(1–2):26–39.Google Scholar
  10. Fowler, G. et al. Germ-line gene therapy and the clinical ethos of medical genetics. Theoretical Medicine 1989:10:151–165.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Glannon, W. Genes, embryos, and future people. Bioethics 1998:12(3): 187–211.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Glover, J. What Sort of People Should There Be? Penguin Books, Hammondsworth, 1984Google Scholar
  13. Grey, W. Playing god, in Encyclopedia of Applied Ethics, Chadwick, R. ed., Academic Press, 1998, pp. 525–530.Google Scholar
  14. Hanser, M. Harming future people. Philosophy and Public Affairs 1990:19(1):47–70.Google Scholar
  15. Harris, J. Wonderwoman and Superman: The Ethics of Human Biotechnology, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1992Google Scholar
  16. Harris, J. Is gene therapy a form of eugenics? Bioethics 1993:7(2/3): 178–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Hayry, M. & Hayry, H. (Genetic engineering, in Encyclopedia of Applied Ethics, Chadwick, R. ed., Academic Press, 1998, pp.407–417.Google Scholar
  18. Holtug, N. Altering humans — the case for and against human gene therapy. Cambridge Quarterly Healthcare Ethics 1997:6(2): 157–174.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Holtug, N. Human gene therapy: down the slippery slope? Bioethics 1993:7(5):402–419.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Juengst, E. Germ-line gene therapy — back to basics. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1991:16(6):587–592.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Keenan, J. What is morally new in genetic manipulation? Human Gene Therapy 1990:1(3):289–298.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Lappé, M. Ethical issues in manipulating the human germ line. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1991:16:621–639.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Lucassen, E. The ethics of genetic engineering. Journal of Applied Philosophy 1996:13(1):51–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Mauron, A. & Thévoz, J. Germ-line engineering: a few European voices. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1991:16:667–683.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Moseley, R. Commentary: maintaining the somatic/germ-line distinction: some ethical drawbacks. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1991:641–647.Google Scholar
  26. Munson, R. & Davis, L. Germ-line gene therapy and the medical imperative. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 1992:2(2): 137–158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. National Health and Medical Research Council (Ethical Aspects of Research on Human Gene Therapy, Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra, 1987Google Scholar
  28. National Health and Medical Research Council Guidelines for Ethical Review of Research Proposals for Human Somatic Cell Gene Therapy and Related Procedures, Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra, 1999Google Scholar
  29. National Health and Medical Research Council Human Gene Therapy and Related Procedures, Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra, 1995Google Scholar
  30. Resnik, D. Debunking the slippery slope argument against human germ-line gene therapy. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1994:19:23–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Resnik, D. Genetic engineering and social justice: a Rawlsian approach. Social Theory and Practice 1997:23(3):427–448.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Richter, G. & Bacchetta, M. Interventions in the human genome: some moral and ethical considerations. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1998:23(3):303–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Rosenkratz, J. Custom kids and the moral duty to genetically engineer our children. High Technology Law Journal 1987:2(1): 1–53.Google Scholar
  34. Singer, P. & Wells, D. The Reproduction Revolution: New Ways of Making Babies, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1984Google Scholar
  35. Walters, L. & Palmer, J. The Ethics of Human Gene Therapy, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1997, pp. 60–98.Google Scholar
  36. Williams, B. Which slopes are slippery? in Moral Dilemmas in Modern Medicine, Lockwood, M. ed., Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1985, pp. 126–137.Google Scholar
  37. Wood-Harper, J. (Manipulation of the germ-line, in Ethics and Biotechnology, Dyson, A. & Harris, J. eds, Routledge, London, 1994, pp. 121–143.Google Scholar
  38. Zimmerman, B. Human germ-line therapy: the case for its development and use. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 1991:16:593–612.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Monash University 2002

Authors and Affiliations

  • Lucy Carter
    • 1
  1. 1.The Office of Public Policy and Ethics Institute for Molecular BioscienceThe University of QueenslandAustralia

Personalised recommendations